Re: Why make Dua when everything is pre written??
Dear kakaballi, first of all, I have no idea who is educated and who is not or to what level on this forum. Secondly, My responses are general not addressed to anyone just for sake of explanations of things from my point of view in case anyone is interested in knowing alternative point of view. However, if anyone responds then I do share further information if I have to and the reason for giving links is because I have collected my thoughts in one place. It saves me writing same thing over and over again and again. Sometimes I do copy paste as well from whatever I have written already just to bring things to attention of people just as other people bring things to my attention. In other words this is how we learn from each other by way of trying to get explanations of each other about various things.
Whenever we talk about things, deen of islam is always part of it and deen of islam is dependent upon the quran so it become necessary to let people know what the text of the quran means in its own context as I understand it. This does not mean whatever I am saying is the only right thing but it is till someone explains it even better. The main things is rules of interpretation of the quranic text which are unchallengeable. So long as any interpretation of the quran is based upon those rules it cannot be wrong provided it is logical and consistent. All interpretations of the quran by mullahs are not based upon concrete rules and that is why they are full of mistakes and most of them came after people chose alternative to deen of islam in form of religion of islam. This is why these interpretations turned deen of islam irrelevant.
This thread is about duaa and taqdeer this is why I explained words duaaa and gave link as well so that people could see more detailed explanation there. The reason is so that people do not waste time in inquiring and responding one question at a time and throwing about verses of the quran or hadith reports. That is not the way to understand the quran or the hadith. To undersatnd the quran or hadith people need to go through whole of the quran to see what context one can get from the text of the quran. Whatever context one comes up with that is free of conflicts within and with respect real world realities that is the correct meaning of a verse in which one should use it. Merely quoting verses of the quran or their translations are no use for this purpose because people do not have any idea what the other related verses mean and whether a translator got it right or wrong.
All of my posts are very much relevant because I am putting forth related ideas which also need to be accommodated because it is also possible that one talks about one thing but contradict all the others being unaware about them. All dots need to be found out and connected together so that everything makes sense. This is why all people who have partial information and understanding of things cannot get out of confusion. On top of all this we have people whose job it is to confuse other people so that they fail to find any concrete answer which unites humanity. In my explanation of things I tried to take away this opportunity from all those who claim to be muslims or nonmuslims to divide humanity to continue their dirty game to make people divide and keep them divided and in painful suffering thereby.
This is why it is important that people educated themselves and see who is playing games with them so that they become alert and move away from supporting such people who are in actual fact responsible for their painful suffering. They are both religious as well as secular. Deen of islam does not suit agendas of both of them because on one hand mullahs want to rule the world and on the other the secular. Deen of islam on the other hand is basically all about brotherhood of humanity for the good of all human beings.
This is why mullahs invented maslae taqdeer so that kings have a free rein. Allah has provided mankind with all they will ever need but he has provided them with guidance for its production and distribution so that needs and wants of all people are fulfilled satisfactorily through proper management of land and resources by way of proper organisation and regulation of humanity into a proper human community.
Mullahs tell people all things belong to Allah and it is Allah who has made people rich and poor so people must accept this situation as it is and try to live life as best as they can ie live with it and not complain about it and wait for browny points instead to be rewarded in hereafter. A very cunning trick for getting free labour. This is why mullahs invented the idea of ZAKAAH in the sense we know it today whereby people are given the hope of help and not actual help. Charity and many other idea have been brought in to keep people at bay this way so that they do not rise against the rulers, money lenders and mullahs. These tricks and mechanisms worked for a while but ultimately things were turned upside down by way of bloody revolutions when people became fed up with tricks and mechanisms of rulers, money lenders and mullahs. These are the facts which mullahs try their best to hide in their quranic translations. This is how they clothe truth with their falsehood in order prevent education based revolution. That is what the quran is about ie it about helping people change their world for the betterment of themselves through education and training.
The quran is a book that deals with real world issues not imaginary world issues as mullahs will have us believe. Since people have been fooled by each other so they are running to all sorts of people to find out what future holds in store for them. Watch tv programs, ads in papers and magzines etc. Why people have job problems? Why all other kinds of problems? It is because people have fallen out with each other so each and every person is living for himself having no concern for anyone else other than as a rival and predator to hunt down each other. This is why people want to know what taqdeer holds for them because they have been made to think they cannot escape whatever Allah has decided for them. Why people think that way? It is because mullahs interpreted the scriptures that way so that people think that way. Kings were put in place and people were told by mullahs that kings are put in place by God so whatever they do it the will of God so accept the will of God and live with it.
Now look at videos again and see if you can understand why my posts are relevant to topics but in a very different way than one is directed to think either by mullahs or secular. My explanations are deen based explanations that is why they are very different and make no sense till they are seen in their own proper context. This is like we both have our own pieces of jig saw puzzles very different from each other and when we try to build those jig saw puzzles one of us is stuck with pieces that do not fit together at all. The other way to look at it is that we each have two different translations of the quran and one of us is trying to fit one piece of translation of one translation into the other so it looks out of place. This is why each translation needs to be read through on its own to see what the translator is actually trying to convey as the actual message of the quran as per his own understanding of the text. If one translation of the quran in a language was ok then why have many others? It is because each of the translators felt he has seen some lacks in the other translations so one rather have his own version to express one’s alternative ideas.
However the question is, if there is has to be an alternative translation then there have to be some key differences otherwise what is the point of having an alternative translation? Yet if we put together all translations we see them as copies of each other and there is no real individuality aspect in them. So why these people wasted their own time and time of other people if they had nothing significantly different to share? Something very odd is going on among mullahs of various sects ie they are together in making fool of masses. Rulers rob their people by force by putting heavy taxes on them but mullahs make them empty their pockets through making them tremble with fear of God or for acting as intermediaries between them and God. So there are very many points that converge on a very same topic.
I means there is a huge difference between ideologies of people who are looking for supernatural helpers from God and people who know they are on their own and all God has done is provided them with his guidance to act on it. This is why people who look for supernatural interventions sit idle and end up destroyed but those who know they depend upon their own efforts carry on doing what they know needs to be done to make progress. No surprise there why this ummah is in the state of existence that it is. Because its mullahs have told it that help is going to come from God to change things for the better for them. Meanwhile other people went ahead and did what was needing doing and overtook this ummah by surprise and are now sitting on top of these people as their masters. The fact is Allah does not change state of existence of a people just by sending them guidance but he wants them to act on it and change their own state of existence for the better and unless they will do that outcome will be no change. If there is no change then that means a people are a dead people because sign of living people is changes they bring about constantly in their societies. Life means movement.
regards and all the best.