Re: Breaking News: Another Bomb blast in Lahore
We'll not be able to solve this problem until the Pakistani people stop "justifying" the acts of tribal people as a rational reaction to Lal Masjid incident. When I studied in Pakistan, the "Islamic Studies" books emphasized that Islam was a blessing for the Arab culture as it liberated them from traditions of revenge killing and endless bloodshed. If the religiously inclined people in Pakistan keep justifying these acts as legitimate revenge (that too against innocent people), they have a lot to learn about Islam they claim to love so much.
I completely agree!
[quote]
Now if pockets of tribal people want to continue these atrocities, and if it really is a revenge of their perceived greivances, then let's call it that, but for God's sake stop hiding behind Islam then, and don't defend the tribals as the torch bearers of Islam that you want us to follow into heaven (on our polio-ridden legs I suppose?)
[/quote]
They have new (not-so) interpretation for their "revenge" desires, its called AlQaida, which allows them to call it Islamic as well as twist any event to justify their terror/act.
[quote]
If its' just a revenge, then are we also going to allow the criminals prosectured by our government to kill innocent people as a 'revenge' ? The people holed up in Lal Masjid were not killed indescriminately. They were challenging the writ of the state, trying to establish their own government within the government, and as a result, were asked to turn themselves in to the government. They ones who did, were let go safely. The remaining chose to stay in and fight. What should have been done. Next time a Police squad corners a bunch of thungs in a building, do you just want them to say oh sorry, you may go free because you refuse to surrender?
[/quote]
Though I agree with you what you said here but the incident/event was not so simple as one would think reading your post.
[quote]
Now all those people talking about "negotiating" with these people. Please note the following:
The deal can't be that you stop suicide bombing and we'll never enter your areas. We could have done that, but then these guys start staging against attacks across the border and also harbor people who plan to commit terrorist acts against other countries. If this is being done in Pakistani areas, Pakistan is responsible for that. Is Pakistan at war with U.S. ? Is Paksitan at war with Afghanistan? If not, then we cannot allow these people to drag us up into a war with other countries. IF they continue doing so, they are criminals and terrorists and should be treated as such.
The only deal can be, that you live peacefully in your areas, following whatever prehistoric barbaric traditions you like, and we'll leave you alone as long as you don't indulge in cross border adventures. Now, you have seen that in the recnet past, they have often bombed the meetings of tribal elders who were discussing various peace options. These people won't even refrain from killing their own people, just to create anarchy and a culture of violence in which their warlord status statys in tact. And you call them "Muslims", and "Innocent" and just reacting to their grievances. Oh come on...
[/quote]
Bhai mere, you are merely repeating words of some major/ISPR from some press release, however you are forgetting some ground realities. The people who are being "harbored" by the locals are no one but the guest of ISI when US invaded Afghanistan, locals were asked to support them, keep them as guest and what not. Now the same people are being told to not keep those "guests"! Well, the people we are dealing with are "tribals". Government should've been straight and clean in its dealing from day one, but unfortunately we can't even say its "clean" even now.
As the saying goes: "haathion ki jang mai fasal to barbaad hoti hay"
So on one hand we have one "haathi-group" as "army/US etc" while the other haathi-group is tribals (not all)/AlQaida/Taliban while the "fasal" is all of us (civilians). By no means I wish to defend atrocities but wanted to clarify some issues which I saw in your post.
