Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
comercial script and alphabets are same for both but words are different.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
comercial script and alphabets are same for both but words are different.
you mean urdu and Punjabi? What do you think Urdu script can cater all the sounds of Punjab properly?
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
I know Balochi and Pashto are used as medium of education in Balochistan and KPK. I myself studied in Sindhi Medium Schools. Why they don't use Punjabi as a medium in Punjab?
I'm not sure whether Punjabi is taught as a language at school level. Here in Sindh we were taught English, Urdu, Sindhi as well as Arabic languages at school level. Recently they were going to introduce Chines language too :D
could be a reason that there are no punjabi qaum parast.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
you mean urdu and Punjabi? What do you think Urdu script can cater all the sounds of Punjab properly?
yes offcourse.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
could be a reason that there are no punjabi qaum parast.
Thats another topic beyond this forum's jurisdiction. I think protecting your mother tongue and transferring it to your next generation is the best quality, whatever it is named by others.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
you mean urdu and Punjabi? What do you think Urdu script can cater all the sounds of Punjab properly?
yes,
but to read original(thaith) accent between the lines, you have to be native.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
yes, but to read original(thaith) accent between the lines, you have to be native.
Exactly. Thats what I was saying to STA about the word 'Sohniya'
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
Thats another topic beyond this forum's jurisdiction. I think protecting your mother tongue and transferring it to your next generation is the best quality, whatever it is named by others.
is mauzoo par ek thread bhii hai Kinzz kii...mere Khayaal se waqt/jaa e rihaaish ke saath saath maadrii zabaaneN bhii badaltii rahtii haiN...jab tak puraanii peeRhii zinda hotii hai tab tak yeh aHsaas hotaa hai...phir 2-3 pushtoN ke ba'd zabaan hii badal jaatii hai...agar vaalidain ke aabaaii mulk aur rishtedaaroN se koii contact nahiiN to phir zabaan daanii koii ahmiyat nahiiN rakhtii...angrezii to sabhii ko aatii hai aajkal.
mere ghar men uRdu kaa bol baalaa hai magar mere bheteeje aur bhateejiyoN ko ek lafz Urdu kaa nahiiN aataa, na hii vo desi khaane khaate haiN aur na hii kabhii vo India gaye to ab unke liye Urdu ba Haisiyat maadrii zabaan cheh ma'nii daarad?
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
Does that mean Punjabi also suffered in India due to politics?
No, I don't think so, seprate punjab state dominated by sikhs in population made punjabi(gurmukhi script) as medium of instruction, Hindus in punjab also speak in punjabi, same is with pahadi of himachal which was influneced by punjabi, for haryanavis they always spoke in haryanavi, khadi boli of hindi for centuries, Punjab suffered a lot but not punjabi:)
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
Thats another topic beyond this forum's jurisdiction. I think protecting your mother tongue and transferring it to your next generation is the best quality, whatever it is named by others.
I appreciate KP and Sindh in this regard even if it was possible due to qaum parast. I love my mother tongue too.
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
sara qasoor aap ka hai, aap itni mushkil zaban main unko na darate to wo bhi aaj Urdu bolte 
j/k
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
Thats good to hear that they use Punjabi as medium of instructions in Indian Punjab 
I think, if in Pakistan people of Punjab wanted, they could have made it medium of instruction too
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
noon and Re of Urdu doesn't full criteria of actual word. You can't understand this STA, because you don't know the exact essence of Punjabi word
I think you are talking about pronunciation and sound of alphabet N in word sohniya right?
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
I think you are talking about pronunciation and sound of alphabet N in word sohniya right?
Yes ninja
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
lol…ho saktaa hai…par, mere Bhai aur Bhabhi to aur bhii mushkil Urdu bolte haiN magar maiN ne to nahiiN chhoRii Urdu bolnii 
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
Exactly. Thats what I was saying to STA about the word 'Sohniya'
read this word with punjabi accent, N in word 'Sohniya' will read some what combinition of N(Noon) and T (Tay) and R(RRay)
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
read this word with punjabi accent, N in word 'Sohniya' will read some what combinition of N(Noon) and T (Tay) and R(RRay)
There is no letter in Urdu, that can fulfill this technicality :D
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
There is no letter in Urdu, that can fulfill this technicality :D
We have an alphabet in hindi and marathi which can help in replicating exact pronunciation of sohniya
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
we do have that in Sindhi. If Punjab needs it, we will give them. No need for import from India 
Re: Why Punjabi is not taught in Pakistani schools?
So sindhi script is little different than urdu script?