Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

WASHINGTON — The reigning national spelling champion is a 14-year-old kid whose one-liners kept everyone laughing a year ago. His parents moved to the United States from central India, and he wants to be a neurosurgeon when he grows up.

Last year’s runner-up — and one of this year’s favorites at the Scripps National Spelling Bee — is an all-business 13-year-old Indian-American boy from Michigan. He’s also set his sights on neurosurgery.Another favorite expected to be onstage for Thursday night’s nationally televised finals is a 13-year-old Kansas girl with a sweet smile and a last name that’s a spelling challenge unto itself. You guessed it: Her family comes from India, and she wants to be a neurosurgeon.

“Is that right?” said Naresh Chand, bursting out in laughter. “That’s a coincidence. That’s a big coincidence.”

Naresh is father of the Sidharth Chand, whose mishap in the final round last year allowed Sameer Mishra to claim the title.

Trailing closely behind both was Kavya Shivashankar, a three-time finalist who tied for fourth. The three have come to know each other through the bee — spellers are a tight-knit community, keeping tabs on each other through e-mails and instant messages throughout the year — but it never occurred to any of them that they share more than a heritage.

“They only want (to be) neurosurgeons. How many people are going to go for neurosurgery?” Sidharth’s mother, Sunita, said with a shrug and a laugh.
Those who follow the bee see the Indian-neurosurgeon quirk as less of a coincidence. In the same way that Hakeem Olajuwon’s success in the NBA inspired a generation of Nigerians to take up basketball, Sidharth, Sameer and Kavya can trace their roots to Balu Natarajan of Chicago, who in 1985 became the first Indian-American national bee champion.

Balu inspired others, who in turn became role models for more would-be champions. Kavya’s heroine is Nupur Lala, who won the bee in 1999 and was featured in the documentary “Spellbound.” Sameer was motivated when his friend Anurag Kashyap won in 2005 and was coached by older sister Shruti, a three-time national bee participant. Altogether there have been eight Indian-American champions, including six of the past 10.

Indian-American kids dominate spelling bee :: CHICAGO SUN-TIMES :: Nation

While it’s tempting to suggest the spellers were just showing off by picking a long word as a potential occupation, their choice of neurosurgery isn’t surprising. The 293 competitors in Washington this week are bright kids flush with big goals. In a survey conducted by the bee, physician was listed as the No. 1 career ambition, followed by author, lawyer, scientist and engineer. Sameer, for his part, thinks his mind is perfectly wired to study the brain.
“It’s really interesting how I can memorize a lot of words, (while) some people have a knack for logic for math and stuff,” Sameer said in a telephone interview from his home in Indiana. “It’s a really interesting aspect of the brain.”

Kavya’s father said his daughter became fascinated with medicine in 2005, when she won a spelling bee that featured nothing but medical terms. Kavya was also quick to point out that her idol, Lala, is now a research assistant in the brain and cognitive sciences lab at MIT.

“I’ve always been interested in how the body works, and especially the brain,” Kavya said. “I always thought it was really interesting.”
Sidharth is a different case altogether. He came home one day as a fifth-grader with news he had won his school’s bee. His mother had no idea what he was talking about, but from that day on, spelling became his passion.

He’s one of the rare spellers wearing a suit and tie for his photograph in the official bee guide. Sidharth seemed nervous Tuesday and skipped the annual speller’s barbecue on Monday to study declining an interview so he wouldn’t be distracted from reams of pages of words and notes.

He allowed a reporter into his hotel room just long enough to be photographed, so the origin of the neurosurgeon ambition listed in his bio remained a mystery — even to his parents.

“He doesn’t have any friends from the spelling circle,” Sunita said. “He’s not a very social kind of a person, so where this neurosurgeon business comes from, I don’t have a clue.”

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

Because Indian parents are obsessed with academics. You'll hardly hear about Indian kids dominating sports :D

Good good. Neat.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

Coz they have population of over Billion, if they still compare themselves to UK (70 million) .. then please sure ;)

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

You have to admit that Indians are all over the place now…you even get to see Indian names on children shows on TV now. Yeah the population is something…man, something must be done about that :no:

You can make a difference, i have yet to dive :halo:

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

hum do humarey do :D

I agree. A big reason is that there is fierce competition in India due to the huge population, and the focus on doing well academically is a lot. The firts generation Indians in the US have the same values that they impart to their kids.

However, I like to think that genes do play some part in Indians doing well academically across the world :p

P.S. Its not just Indian parents who are obsessed with academics, but somehow not all kids do well academically. Go figure...;)

We are talking about Indians in US. Indians are less than 1% in US and they are represented way above in acedemics and professional workforce. Look at any bee competitions (Spelling Bee, Geography Bee, Math Bee).Out of 41 finalists 14 were Indians.

Go to any IT Related meeting, you see more Indians than whites. Most of the Masters and Phd programs in US universities are dominated by Indians, so is the college faculty.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

its coz indian moms beat their kids into mugging up the dictionary, and indian dads dont know how to play any games anyway.

Congrats to the Indian American kids for setting up great example for the immigrants.

In fact most of the Asian kids (Indians, Chinese, Koreans and non-Islamist Pakistanis) do really really well in academics.

The bottom line is, you work hard and you will get the reward.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

:omg: :rotfl:

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

I think that the whole united states is asking this question...lol

p.s. I have some indian friends who work really hard and some who don't, but I guess indians winning most of the spelling bee competitions is a mystrey

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

I watched a documentary on this last year - parents pressured the poor child 8-9 months before the competition, hired a tutor for him who'd help with 'foreign language-based' words. During the competition the father set up his god on the table and said thanks after the son correctly spelled each word. Anyone remember?

**Indian spellers d-o-m-i-n-a-t-e

**The Free Press

Mankato eighth-grader Daniel Halvorson was ousted Wednesday from the Scripps National Spelling Bee, which came as no surprise to those who follow this sort of thing.

Daniel Halvorson was jettisoned not because he can’t spell well but because, well, his name is Daniel Halvorson.
Which is to say, it’s not Avvinash Radakrishnan, Sameer Mishra or Kavya Shivashankar, who won the title Thursday by spelling her last name.

But seriously, she won it by spelling “laodicean,” which means lukewarm or indifferent to religion or politics.

Indian-American kids dominate this thing each year; they’ve won seven of the past 11 bees.

The Free Press, Mankato, MN - Indian spellers d-o-m-i-n-a-t-e

Why some child whose family has been in this country about 16 minutes can spell “palimpsest,” “heleoplankton” and “akropodion” defies credulity.

Yet each year this Indian kiddie cartel puts a linguistic whippin’ on all comers. How come?

Without delving too far into the minefield of ethnic stereotyping, suffice to say that Indian kids’ upbringing fuels their spelling prowess.
Put another way, if American parents prodded their offspring toward academic excellence they way they push them in sports, you’d see Ben and Betsy battling toe to toe with the likes of Nitish and Saptarshi.

Not to mention Akshay Buddiga, who in 2004 gave the national bee a bounty of publicity when he fainted dead away, got up and proceeded to correctly spell “alopecoid,” a word I accidentally pronounced the other day when I stifled a sneeze.

In the Indian-American community, I suppose, Buddiga’s stunning recovery was the sports equivalent of a kid felled by a brush-back pitch, popping up and smacking a game-winning homer.

No wonder the pressure got to young Akshay. In some Indian households, parents drill kids on spelling as if they were in some sort of Merriam-Webster dictionary boot camp.

In the 1999 documentary “Spellbound” depicting the spelling bee subculture, one Indian child’s father made the kid spell 7,000 words a day, and a relative paid 1,000 people in India to chant his name.

Two, four, six, eight — who do we appreciate? Kadakia! Kadakia! Kadakia!
The national spelling bee has taken on the aura of a sporting event, to the extent that early rounds are televised on the sports network ESPN.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

Oh No, Who Won the Spelling Bee?
Posted on May 29, 2009 03:28:00 PM by Sandip Roy

New America Media Blogs

How do you spell STEREOTYPE?
Two of the three top winners of the Spelling Bee are Indian-American. Again. Kavya Shivashankar took first place. Anamika Viramani came second.

Did second place winner Tim Ruiter really crack under pressure or was it the combined yogic energy of a billion-plus Indians at work?

What the heck is it with Indian Americans?

Here’s the memo to my fellow Indian Americans – All the spelling bees have been won. Let’s try something else now.
I guess its not just Indians. When a Korean woman won the LPGA it set off a golfing craze in South Korea. Last year there were so many Korean women (45!) in the LPGA, it came up with an obviously racist rule about how you needed to be fluent in English in order to play golf! That thankfully was rescinded but I am worried now someone will try and come up with something similar for Spelling Bees.

If your name has more than 3 syllables you can’t compete in the Bee. You will have an unfair advantage. No, Mr. Shivshankar, I know your daughter has been practicing for years just to win the Spelling Bee but rules are rules.

That’s kind of scary. After she spelled Laodicean to become Queen Bee, Kavya Shivashankar said it was her dream and she hopes she could coach her little sister next.
Noooo. Stop. Please make this madness stop.

But why do Indian-Americans do so well at Spelling Bees? I confess I loved words. I used to get up early in the morning before everyone awoke and sit on the windowsill in the early morning light with a tattered old Oxford English dictionary, just reading it. But I wasn’t doing it to learn spellings. I just liked words.

Maybe we have good memories because we come from a culture where we had to learn reams and reams of dates and dynasties just to pass a history exam. The Tughlaqs, the Khiljis, the Aibaks, the Mughals, the Hoysalas, the Mauryas, the Guptas, the Pallavas, not to mention the three battles of Panipat.

Maybe it’s just good old fashioned family values. Kavya’s coach was her father. It’s a cool way to while away long car drives when you are driving across state lines to the tri-state Gujarati association Navaratri potluck dinner.

Perhaps just having to spell our names over and over again in America, hearing that slight shocked pause from the telemarketer when your name pops up on the screen (unless they are a call center in Chennai), spelling has become second nature to our community.
Why do Indian Americans want their kids to win the spelling bee so badly? I mean there are no spelling bees in India, certainly no national competitions – of course, India has over 20 languages. Maybe that’s the clue. My native Bengali has two n’s, 2 r’s (one r, one rrrr), three s’s. Once you’ve learned the hard way which ‘s’ is used when and the rules governing the n’s, Laodicean seems like child’s play.

But it’s not just Spelling Bee. On May 20 two Indian American teens, Arjun Kandaswamy and Shantan Kroviddi took two of the top three positions in the National Geography Bee.
Well, I thought, its kinda cutely nerdy to have your ambition be “I wanna be spelling bee champion.” It’s not necessarily the mark of an over-achiever.
Then I read more about this year’s winners. Kavya’s hobbies include swimming, cycling and traditional Indian dance. She plans on becoming a neurosurgeon. Anamika’s hobbies include violin, Indian classical music, dance, and golf. She hopes to attend Harvard Medical School, where she hopes to specialize in cardiovascular surgery.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

Last year Anamika was second. This year she is first. Anamika now became the third consecutive Indian-American champion National Spelling Bee. This years National Geography Bee winner is also Indian Amercan. Aadith Moorthy of Palm Harbor, Florida won the National Geographic Bee challenge.

In fact, the Indian American dominance of the spelling bee has become so associated with the community’s success, that US President Barack Obama actually mentioned that he had met Anamika Veeramani at the White House the same day he attended a reception held at the State Department in honour of External Affairs Minister SM Krishna at the conclusion of the inaugural US-India Strategic Dialogue in Washington on Thursday.

Why Indian Kids Kick Butt At Spelling Bees

http://www.npr.org/blogs/talk/2010/06/03/127404554/why-indian-kids-kick-butt-at-spelling-bees

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

I have seen many Indians who have better English than natives, seriously. They write remarkably well.. I do not know about their system of education but there must be some special focus on English whatsoever!

This would be the case of kids raised in US and UK. Back in India , majority speak very poor English and tend to translate from mother tongue.

Re: Why do Indian kids dominate all bee competitions?

for every five frikkin desi nerds I would like to see one athlete or rockstar, only then the caricature desi image will improve..

but more power to the spelling bee champs I guess.