Why Bollywood Songs are not good for Muslims ?!

hey man I already said lollywood aint so hot either, which basically means that any lower versions liek punjabi, pushto stuff is even worse, just like when i say bollywood sucks it is looking at the top level of stuff there and it automatically means that tamil, telegu, marathi whatever stuff is even worse

jazakallah Some1.. u have expressed appreciation before too, and I can only thank you. even though we are from different countries we can be polite with each other.

[quote]

I ask again - do you have a twin brother named "Anil Khan" ?
[/QUOTE]

why do you keep bringing up this anil khan? i am hardly a pathan yar, i am brown as a nut, my grandparents used to call themselves Indians before changing their minds about the issue after 1947.

or mainy apne post main yeh baat kahaan kahee thee k poetry main mubaalgha nahi hona chaeye ? **mainy arz kia tha AISA mubaalgha bhi aa jata jo shirk main chala jata hay **

jaisay hum shirkiyaa natoon k baray main kehtay k app salal Allaho alyhi waslaam ki muhaabat main itna agay berh jana k Allah ki siffat main un ko shreek maan laiyna

app nay jo shair ki wazaahat mujhay dee .. main is per app ko itna Aagah kerna chaahoon gee

ilm ul aaqaaid per mustanad kitaab Sharh-ul- Aqqaaid (arabic book hay or wifaaq-ul- madaaris(deo band) kay ders-e-nizame main shaamil hay )

is k ilawa app Sora Aayraaf main 179 ayat** lil laa hee asmaa’ul husna fad’oo bihaa** ki tafseer zaroor dekheye

is sub main is tmam mufsreen karaam nay is baat ki wazaahat ki hay

Allah tala k ley aisay Alfaaz ka istimaal jis k saath shreiyat Warid nahi hoyee woh mana hay

**HOSLAY yeh lafz aisa hay jo aapnay maani main nuqs or aaib ka ahtimaal rakha hay **
Allah her aaib or nuqs say paak hay

baat bohat assan see hay .. STP nay jis cheez ki teraf ishaara kia hay woh bohat hee aham or naazuk masla hay .. app lyrics main doobay hoon ya kisi or sur main is cheez ka jawaaz app islaam main kissi daleel say saabit nahi ker saktay k shirkiya alfaaz moun say nikaltay rahay

umeed hay app mera moa’qaf samjh gaye hon gay
JAzaak Allah !

Re: Why Bollywood Songs are not good for Muslims ?!

why single out bollywood songs? ...western songs must be the devils music, they are 10 times worse.

The christians called rock and roll/blues (Elvis/Beatles) "the devils music" back in the 1950's.

Re: Why Bollywood Songs are not good for Muslims ?!

If muslims commits shriks by listening to songs like om shanti Om ..we hindus might be doing the same by listening songs which have words like khuda, allah etc etc but I guess our god has a big heart and he really dont care abt such things.

good for u could be bad for some one else
one has to be careful abt his actions and its consequences
thats where our deen guides us

Not really ...my friend....the general conduct of "Mullahs" everywhere, the regular issue of fatwas, the "cultural policing" by the taliban is what I will say is an exension of what "Submission to Peace" does here on this forum. Enforcing your "religious-ness" on others.

There are extremists in the every religion, but you will have to agree with me that in the Muslim world, there are way too many of them.

We were tallking about the holier than though self righteous approach, and you seem to be changing your tune as I mentioned the observed behavior in religion forum on this site. we can see the interactions of many non muslim indians in the religion section on this site, and lets just say the flaming, the constant one upmanship, the pissing contests are nothing more than this holier than thou self rightous crap really not intendeed to have a healthy discussion but just a more stealthmanner of pointing fingers at someone and say 'ha ha'

almost everyone in this thread has opposed STP's view, but that is not what you see, you only see the initial post.

Re: Why Bollywood Songs are not good for Muslims ?!

songs that have bhajan or hindu gods name are supposed to be avoided anyway...

chor do bollywood ko....

my fav song these days is kabhi kabhi aditi zindigi main yuhi koi apna lagta hai...from movie jaane tu ya jaane na.
nice movie na.
sigh is king ki bari tareef suni hai ji

I remember a song that went something like "haseeno ko atay hain kiya kiya bahanay, **Khuda bhee na janay* to hum kaisay janay"*

Sorry to hurt you guys but aap logo ki thinking hi negative hai...yes.

for instance i remember a song from movie K3G" yeh dil ki baatein dil hi jaane ya jaane Khuda"
So moral of the story is " listen to good songs, like me"

hi chintu
where are you from in india?
actually main indians pe search kar rahi hoon:)

Re: Why Bollywood Songs are not good for Muslims ?!

Songs are unislamic anyways so why even bother to listen to them and moreover create a fuss abt it.........for others it a great way to entertain themselves. And there will be a group of ppl who are stuck in the middle like the thread-starter will always hear to the songs and then crib about them. It's kind of guilty pleasure for them.

So it means you donot listen to songs....bare naak ho :)
so What do you do to entertain your self dude?

When, Did I say, I don't hear to songs, I love songs and hear all of them.......From Sarkai Lo Khatiya to Sweet home Alabama. Just trying to say to Anti-Bollywood and Bollywood lovers group that keep doing what they do, Just don't try to justify what you are doing and imposing it on others.

:rotfl: STP bhai, I just know one thing that someone is listening to too many songs nowadays

I am joking brother :smiley:

or should we say there are so many of them with so many views, its hard to have "one rule", that they don't care about such things anymore.

I'd say...there are so many of them and still have no rules......Which make the religion/way of living greater.

Atleast none of my many gods impose anything on me . I can use my brain to figure what is good or bad for me. My god doesnt treat me like a machine or a slave.