Reject A bcos he hangs out in malls (immature), making sure he has the newest aftershave on the market and laughs out loud too much - this indicates some level of insecurity and lack of inner confidence, displays the need to prove something or must b accepted by society.
Reject B bcos too much outward religiousness may set alarm bells if he seems the type to stop thinking for himself and blindly follows mullahs who don't know what they r talking about or have no link with the real world. However, smiles more than he laughs is good.
Wait for a mixture of social person, with a healthy questioning mind who understands and practices religion without being oppressive, and who has inner confidence.