Who is Allah?

following is secular historical view

It is thus clear that the mass conversion of Arabia to Islam does not testify to any spiritual crisis, religious decadence, or decline of pagan belief. Indeed, in behavioural terms, the better part of Arabia was still pagan in the nineteenth century. What the mass conversions show is that Muhammad’s God had something very attractive to offer here and now. When Sa’d, the pre-Islamic deity, scared away the camels of his devotees, the latter concluded that “Sa’d is just a rock”: the power that he was supposed to have exercised had proved unreal. But when Muhammad established himself, they concluded that “Allah is great.” The Arabs converted to Islam because Allah was a greater power than any other spirit endowed with a name and a cult so far known in Arabia, and the problem is not the ease with which they could convert, but the inducement. What was it that Allah had to offer?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *

How is that possible? No one heard of Allah or Islam before Muhamad came about, what, around 1400 years or so?
[/QUOTE]

Moses heard about Allah - Jesus did as well as Ishaq, Dawood and Solomon or Abraham.. read Quran u will know all.. it seems its really hard for u to comprehend monolithic religions like Jewishsm, christainity and Islam..

Allah is an arabic word for Almighty - we pray saying "Khuda" in urdu.. in punjabi we say "Rab" and in English God

^ Yup - that adds weight to the fact. Islam and Allah had to be sufficiently distant, if not opposite, of anything before. I guess before was interpreted as "just before" and not "all before"! chalk one more for pragmatism

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *
^ Yup - that adds weight to the fact. Islam and Allah had to be sufficiently distant, if not opposite, of anything before. I guess before was interpreted as "just before" and not "all before"! chalk one more for pragmatism
[/QUOTE]

and it true.. Islam is a continuation of a process and not a new thing.. muslims belief in earliar prophets of God liek Jesus, Moses, Abraham is a basic faith element.. but with time and space message from God got tainted and was the reasn for new messenger of God.. muslims believe Muhammad (PBUH) was the last in line with the message from God.. since at time of Muhammad civilization had advanced to such a state the message would be preserved in its originality till end of time.. and originality of Quran as word of God is a binding factor behind more than billion muslims..

Good it cleared ur concept a bit about Allah and u will not think Allah is only supreme being for muslims only.. as God is one and only and is for the whole humanity even some believe it or not.

But Who has written/interpreted the Quran???Was it the Prophet himelf or was it someone before him?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Corporate Spy: *
But Who has written/interpreted the Quran???Was it the Prophet himelf or was it someone before him?
[/QUOTE]

i highly doubt it was someone before him. he'd have taken the credit himself then..no?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Degas: *

Moses heard about Allah - Jesus did as well as Ishaq, Dawood and Solomon or Abraham.. read Quran u will know all.. it seems its really hard for u to comprehend monolithic religions like Jewishsm, christainity and Islam..

Allah is an arabic word for Almighty - we pray saying "Khuda" in urdu.. in punjabi we say "Rab" and in English God
[/QUOTE]

My "^ yup" was to something rviks posted.

I find nothing difficult to comprehend about islam. It's pretty straight forward, like most other religions. What's screwed up is some people's interpretations and practice of it. Such as "Allah" is the only god etc.

Or such as you citing what's on trial to be by itself evidence. Noone heard of Koran before Isla, Noone heard of Islam before Muhamad. Yet you want to claim an antiquity bordering on eternity using what you think is said in Koran as proof.

Tom

But you seem to be missing the point.

The Qur'aan lays a challenge to those who don't believe in it's authenticity or raise doubts about it being a Divine Revelation. It is the only scripture on the face of the earth which is still in it's original format and has not been changed. Why, because God has taken personal guardianship of the scriptures, as stated in the Qur'aan.

Furthermore, when the Qur'aan states that Islam has been here from day one, it is up to the doubters to prove otherwise. Once the doubters get past the challenge part, then they can move onto Islam being here for x amount of time or not. The irony is that the Qur'aan actually states that you cannot get past the challenge part. Thus you are back to square one and recurring.

Therefore, the burden of proof does not lie with Muslims. On the contrary, it lies with the Non Believers.

Islam means 'submisson to God', not some meaning on the borders of 'we are a religion that came 1400 years and are only here for a select few'.

How diificult is it to comprehend 'submission to God' and applying it to Adam onwards, even without Scriptures.

Not that difficult, you'll be pleased to know.

^ Nice try but no beedi.

1) You may think the Koran throws a challenge at non-believers but non-believers by definition don't care and so the challenge is meaningless.

2) You say Koran brings one back to square one - yup, that's called stagnating the believer

3) By merely not accepting it, non-believers have disproven its claims; In other words all one needs to disprove circular logic is to simply recognize the lack of reasoning

4) And therefore the claims of Islam having been around for eternity simply doesn't wash since there is no answer either from koran or practitioners to the question why nobody heard about it before Muhamad came around.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by sholay: *
Tom

But you seem to be missing the point.

The Qur'aan lays a challenge to those who don't believe in it's authenticity or raise doubts about it being a Divine Revelation. It is the only scripture on the face of the earth which is still in it's original format and has not been changed. Why, because God has taken personal guardianship of the scriptures, as stated in the Qur'aan.

Furthermore, when the Qur'aan states that Islam has been here from day one, it is up to the doubters to prove otherwise. Once the doubters get past the challenge part, then they can move onto Islam being here for x amount of time or not. The irony is that the Qur'aan actually states that you cannot get past the challenge part. Thus you are back to square one and recurring.

Therefore, the burden of proof does not lie with Muslims. On the contrary, it lies with the Non Believers.

Islam means 'submisson to God', not some meaning on the borders of 'we are a religion that came 1400 years and are only here for a select few'.

How diificult is it to comprehend 'submission to God' and applying it to Adam onwards, even without Scriptures.

Not that difficult, you'll be pleased to know.
[/QUOTE]

What brother Sholay has written is correct.

I would to add a few last paragraphs from book written by the Alija Izetbegovic - Former President of Bosnia And Herzegovina.

The book is titled 'Islam Between East and West'

Please read it carefully and try to absorp what he has stated.

The will show that Islam started from day 1 of Creation.

Nature has determinism, man has destiny. The acceptance of this destiny is the supreme and final idea of Islam. Destiny -- does it exist and what form does it take? Let us look at our own lives and see what has remained of our most precious plans and the dreams of our youth?

Do we not come helplessly into the world faced with our own personality, with higher or lower intelligence, with attractive or repulsive looks, with an athletic or dwarfish stature, in a king's place or in a beggar's hut, in a tumultuous or peaceful time, under the reign of a tyrant or a noble prince, and generally in geographical and historical circumstances about which we have not been consulted? How limited is what we call our will, how tremendous and unlimited is our destiny!

Man has been cast down upon this world and made dependent on many facts over which he has no power. His life is influenced by both very remote and very near factors. During the Allied invasion of Europe in 1944, there was, for a moment, a general disturbance in radio communications which could have been fatal for the operations under way. Many years later, the disturbance was explained as a huge explosion in the Andromeda constellation, several million light years away form our planet. One type of catastrophic earthquake on the earth is due to changes on the sun's surface. As our knowledge of the world grows, so does our realization that we will never be complete masters of our fate. Even supposing the greatest possible progress of science, the amount of factors under our control will always be insignificant compared to the amount of those beyond it. Man is not proportional to the world. He and his lifetime are not the measuring units of the pace of things. This is the cause of man's eternal insecurity, which is psychologically reflected in pessimism, revolt, despair, apathy, or in submission to God's will.

Islam arranges the world by means of upbringing, education, and laws. That is its narrower scope; submission to God is the broader one.
Individual justice can never be fully satisfied within the conditions of existence. We can follow all Islamic rules which, in their ultimate result, should provide us with the "happiness in both worlds"; moreover, we can follow all other norms, medical, social and moral but, because of the terrific entanglement of destinies, desires and accidents, we can still suffer in body and soul. What can console a mother who has lost her only son? Is there any solace for a man who has been disabled in an accident?

We ought to become conscious of our human condition. We are immersed in situation. I can work to change my situation, but there are situations which are essentially unchangeable, even when their appearance takes a new look, and when their victorious power is veiled: l must die; I must suffer; I must fight; I am a victim of chance; I get inevitably entangled in guilt. These basic conditions of our existence are referred to as "the border situations." Sure, "man is bound to improve everything that can be improved in this world. After that, children will still go on dying unjustly even in the most perfect of societies. Man, at best, can only give himself the task of reducing arithmetically the sufferings of this world. Still, injustice and pain
will continue and, however limited, they will never cease to be blasphemy."

Submission to God or revolt -- these are two different answers to the same dilemma.

In submission to God, there is some of every (human) wisdom except one: shallow optimism. Submission is the story of human destiny, and that is why it is inevitably permeated with pessimism: for "every destiny is tragic and dramatic if we come down to its bottom. "Recognition of destiny is a moving reply to the great human theme of inevitable suffering. It is the recognition of life as it is and a conscious decision to bear and to endure. In this point, Islam differs radically from the superficial idealism and optimism of European philosophy and its naive story about "the best of all possible worlds." Submission to God is a mellow light coming from beyond pessimism.

As a result of one's recognition of his impotence and insecurity, submission to God itself becomes a new potency and a new security. Belief in God and His providence offers a feeling of security which cannot be made up for with anything else. Submission to God does not imply passivity as many people wrongly believe. In fact, "all heroic races have believed in destiny." Obedience to God excludes obedience to man. It is a new relation between man and God and, therefore, between man and man.

It is also a freedom which is attained by following through with one's own destiny. Our involvement and our struggle are human and reasonable and have the token of moderation and serenity only through the belief that the ultimate result is not in our hands. It is up to us to work, the rest is in the hands of God.

Therefore, to properly understand our position in the world means to submit to God, to find peace, not to start making a more positive effort to encompass and to overcome everything, but rather a negative effort to accept the place and the time of our birth, the place and the time that are our destiny and God's will. Submission to God is the only human and dignified way out of the unsolvable senselessness of life, a way out without revolt, despair, nihilism, or suicide. It is a heroic feeling not of a hero, but of an ordinary man who has done his duty and accepted his destiny.

**Islam does not get its name from its laws, orders, or prohibitions, nor from the efforts of the body and soul it claims, but from something that encompasses and surmounts all that: from a moment of cognition, from the strength of the soul to face the times, from the readiness to endure everything that an existence can offer, from the truth of submission to God.

**Submission to God, thy name is Islam!

^ That adds very little to what's being discussed. The only arguement you have is what's said in the Koran about islam and koran itself came about with Muhamad.

Tom

The challenge is to all mankind and Jinns put together.

Secondly, just because you do not accept something, does not mean it doesn't exist. You do not accept Islam, but does it mean it doesn't exist?NO.

Thirdly, the Qur'aan has confirmed Islams existence, so it doesn't really matter what you say. Because the Qur'aan also states that if God was to open up the heavens and make humans ascend and descend all day long, the non believers would only say that their eyes have been bewitched.

Furthermore there are many prophecies about Prophet Muhammad (s) in the revealed scriptures of old (Old and New Testaments, including those of the Zoroastrians and Hindus). Even your scriptures, the Vedas mention Muhammed PBUH.

All major books of the Hindus prophesy about Prophet Mohammad. In addition to many of his qualities, his life events, Abraham, Ka'bah, Bakkah (Makkah) and Arabia, the prophecies mention his name as Mahamad, Mamah, and Ahmad. The name Mahamad appears in the Puranas, Mamah in Kuntap Sukt (in Atharva Veda) and Ahmad in Sama Veda. Many different classifications as to the degree of importance of the Vedas have been made. For example, in Shatpath it is stated that Sama Veda is the essence of all the Vedas. At another place in Taitttriya Brahmana, it is stated that “This world was created from Brahma, the Vaishas were created from the mantras of the Rig Veda, the Kashtriyas were created from Yajur Veda and Brahmans were created from Sama Veda.”

The compiler of the Puranas, Mahrishi Vyasa, is highly honored among the Hindus as a great rishi and learned person. He was a pious and God fearing man. He also wrote the Gita and the Maha Bharat. Among the eighteen volumes of the Puranas is one by the title ‘Bhavishya Puran,’ literally meaning future events. The Hindus regard it as the Word of God. The prophecy containing Prophet Muhammad by name is found in Prati Sarg Parv III: 3, 3, Verse 5.

The translation of Verses 5-27 (Sanskrit text of the Puranas, Prati Sarg Parv III: 3, 3) is presented below from the work of Dr. Vidyarthi.

“A malechha (belonging to a foreign country and speaking foreign language) spiritual teacher will appear with his companions. His name will be Mahamad. Raja (Bhoj) after giving this Mahadev Arab (of angelic disposition) a bath in the 'Panchgavya' and the Ganges water, (i.e. purging him of all sins) offered him the presents of his sincere devotion and showing him all reverence said, 'I make obeisance to thee.' 'O Ye! the pride of mankind, the dweller in Arabia, Ye have collected a great force to kill the Devil and you yourself have been protected from the malechha opponents (idol worshipers, pagans).' ‘O Ye! the image of the Most Pious God the biggest Lord, I am a slave to thee, take me as one lying on thy feet.'

Several more prophecies are found in Atharva Veda: (1) XX: 21, Mantras 6, 7, and 9, (2) XX: 137, Mantras 7 through 9, and (3) X: 2, Mantras 26, 27, 29, 30, and 32. Similarly, in Rig Veda, additional prophecies are found in: (1) VII: 96, Mantras 13 through 16, and (2) I: 53, Mantras 6 and 9. Finally, a prophecy is found in Sama Veda III: 10, Mantra 1.

Time to get reading Tom.

Tomsawyer,

Brother Sholay has given you enough ‘homework’ reading and to contemplate over to last you a few weeks. I’m just adding a few paragraphs I have searched for you over the net.

Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) in Zoroastrian holy scriptures.
“The Zoroastrian holy scriptures have changed over time. The Gathas were the original revelation, which Zoroaster delivered to his people. Only 5 books have survived. The scripture was first written in Gathic; a dead language which is reserved for few scholars only. Later Priests would add to the Gathas, in the Avestan language, to make up the rest of the Zoroastrian holy book, now known as the Avesta (or Zend Avesta). This book was translated by the conquering Sasanids into the Pahlavi tongue. What survives today is estimated to be only a quarter of the original 21 books of the Avesta.

The excerpt displayed here is from a portion of the Avesta known as the Dadistan. The prophecy specifically contained in Sasan 1, verses 54-61:

When such deeds the Persians will commit, a man from among the Arabs will be born, from among the followers of whom, crown and throne, and kingdom and religion of the Persians all shall be overthrown and dissolute. And the arrogant people shall be subjugated. They will see instead of the house of idols and the temple of fire, the house of worship of Abraham without any idols in it; the Qibla. And they will be a mercy for the worlds and then they will capture places of the temples of fire, Madain or Ctesiphon, and of the surrounding places of eminence and sanctity, and their religious leader will be an eloquent man and his message or what he will say will be well connected.

The "sum and substance" of the prophecy can be stated that when the Zoroastrians forsake their religion and their deeds become unprincipled in ignorance, a man will arise in Arabia (a prophet), whose adherents will conquer the arrogant Persians and overrule them. They will turn from idolatry and fire-worship to worship at the House of God, the Ka'ba of Abraham, which will be cleansed of all idols. The followers of this Arabian Prophet will be a "mercy onto the world." This is also the title given to Prophet Muhammad in the Qur'an. The cohorts of this Arab Prophet will become the masters of Persia, Madian, Tus, Balkh, and neighboring territories. Their Prophet will be eloquent in speech and his message will be clear and logical (well connected).”

Happy reading

http://www.gupistan.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=124193#post1982207

Sholay! :ROTFL" This is waaaay too much. Do me a favor and tell me where you’re getting these Veda & Purana ‘stuff’ from. It’s way too far out! (Please don’t mix up Mahadev and Mohamad unless you’re prepared to accept a lot of other things attributed to Mahadev)

I’m asking you guys and dolls a simple question and you keep diverting the issue. How do you call Islam & Allah older than about 1400 years when nobody heard of these!

Yes Sholay...is there any concrete evidence tht Islam existed before Prophet except being written in the Quran?

Recently Father Pecerillo, a famous Franciscan Archeologist, found more than twenty churches in Madaba at the south of Jordan. From the Forth Century we found houses in Syria, Lebanon, Iraq and Palestine with this inscription in Arabic :“Bismi Allah al-Rahman al-Raheem” which shows that even people before Islam used this Holy name, “Allah”, for GOD Almighty, which proves that the name of GOD Almighty in the Noble Quran, “Allah”, is the correct one.
http://www.answering-christianity.com/allah6.htm

Islam was always there as i said but as a muslim we do believe that the bible has been altered so you might not the word Allah or islam there.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *
1) You may think the Koran throws a challenge at non-believers but non-believers by definition don't care and so the challenge is meaningless.
[/QUOTE]

Those who don't care wouldn't care to open it to find the challenge. It is given to people who said at that time that Hazrat Muhammed (PBUH) was a poet and he wrote it himself (even though he didn't know how to write.)So the challenge was in answer to that .

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *
2) You say Koran brings one back to square one - yup, that's called stagnating the believer

[/QUOTE]

Hey you would say that, wouldn't you? You don't believe in it. And from what i can see, you have very little knowledge of it as well. Genuinely (without any bais)read it some time, i am no scholar either so check some knowledgable people out who may explain it to you.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *
3) By merely not accepting it, non-believers have disproven its claims; In other words all one needs to disprove circular logic is to simply recognize the lack of reasoning.

[/QUOTE]

What are you saying here?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by TomSawyer: *
4) And therefore the claims of Islam having been around for eternity simply doesn't wash since there is no answer either from koran or practitioners to the question why nobody heard about it before Muhamad came around.

[/QUOTE]

Yeah, but if you compare it with other holy scriptures you will see the difference. No offence but Bible evolves into something new every year how is it still a word of God is beyond me. And if you really want to look into it, there are very old scripts of Quran go right ahead and check it not a word is altered.
And as to why nobody heard of it? are you even following the discussion muslims believe that Bible and other scriptures were from Allah but they have been altered so Quran was revealed. As bible was revealed after jews altered their books. As to why we Quran is not changed its because Allah promised that His word will remain unchanged so that humans can find the truth (since there will be no other books). This is also because there will be no other messenger so the message is complete.
Hope that helped!

Tom

And I'm giving you a simple answer.

Even your own scriptures as well as others confirm Islam and Mohammed PBUH before the 1400 years you have attached to it.

You don't accept the Qur'aan, you don't accept the Bible, you don't accept the Torah, you don't accept the Psalms, you don't accept the Vedas, and you don't accept the Parsi Scriptures.

What more do you want?

Whether I accept or not is immaterial to my simple question. (In fact I accept all of these holy works you list because a lot of good people in each of these religions accept them and that's good enough for me).

My question came about because someone said Islam and Allah have been around for eternity and that doesn't wash because noone heard of it before Mohamad came about.

Alright someone a couple of posts ago says someone found something from 4th century (BC?) that mentioned Allah. It doesn't add up but I guess the real arguement is that's what you guys & dolls believe and that should be it as far as you're concerned.

Tomsawyer,

From the time of Adam (AS) the Message has been the Unity of the Creator. This has been the essence of Islam. Allah (swt) (Creator for you) sent this Message to all the Nations by sending His Messengers to them all. Over time all these messages were corrupted by the people beyond recognition. Even all the idolatrous religions still believe ultimately in oneness of the Creator.

So whosoever worshipped ONE TRUE GOD without any intermediaries was in fact worshipping TRUE DEITY.

Islam is the last Message from the Creator; and the Creator chose Prophet Muhammad (saw) for this mission. (It makes no difference if you accept it or not – if you reject it, you are doing so at your peril.). The medium of this Message was Arabic; and Allah is the name of the Creator in Arabic language.

So please read the following again, this time don’t just skim over.

[QUOTE]
Islam does not get its name from its laws, orders, or prohibitions, nor from the efforts of the body and soul it claims, but from something that encompasses and surmounts all that: from a moment of cognition, from the strength of the soul to face the times, from the readiness to endure everything that an existence can offer, from the truth of submission to God.

Submission to God, thy name is Islam!
[/QUOTE]