[quote]
In islam you are allowed to vote for a candidate this is called the bayah oath of allegiance. This was one of the 6 methods of selecting a khilafh during the khilafah rashida.
[/quote]
Good, sounds wonderful.
[quote]
Democracy is man made how you even compare it to islam.
[/quote]
Man is made by Allah (SWT) and gave man the brains and guidance. Called man ‘ashraf-ul-makhlooqat” and sent thousands of messengers upon them.
[quote]
In Democracy alcohol is allowed, Riba is allowed, even prostitution is allowed in some of these democratic countries. And you saying this is same as islam aoozibillah.
[/quote]
This is a not a true statement. Democracy is what people choose it should be (with some basic guidelines of right and wrong), so if a country’s people choose not to have Alcohol, Riba, and Prostitution per democratic system these things will be banned in that state. You can take democratic system and establish Islamic law as the basis of the democratic system. Customize it per your need and Islam being the foundation. Call it Islamic Governance System or some other fancy name, does not really matter. What matters is people choose who their leader is and what rules/laws they want keeping Islam as the foundation. Islam is strict and clear in some areas and flexible and open for interpretations in some areas.
Also keep in mind that the sins that you mention here used to happen and have been happening in all times and in all societies.
[quote]
One day democracy says ok drugs are illegal tommorow they will vote and say it is legal.
[/quote]
Again if you establish something as illegal that people can’t vote on that will be the end of it. Like people can’t vote in any democratic system that murder should be legalized.
[quote]
In islam everything is fixed no messing about you know where you stand with islam.
[/quote]
Broad generalization and u make it seem like Islam is very rigid in “all” things. Yes, there are some basic things that you cannot “mess around” with but Islam also left a lot of stuff open for humans to interpret and apply logic and reasoning and using guidelines provided by Allah (SWT).
[quote]
Democracy is the product of the human mind and not from Allah (swt). It does not rely on the divine revelation, nor has it any connection to any religion revealed by Allah to His Messengers.
[/quote]
Well take a democratic system and make Islam its foundation.
[quote]
Democracy is kufr any muslim should know this because you accepting that man makes the laws. Allah(swt) says in koran “Whatever the Messenger brought to you take it, and whatever he forbade you, leave it.”[TMQ: Al-Hashr: 7]
[/quote]
Absolutely true, but I read it differently. I don’t see anywhere here that man made governing system is Haram.
[quote]
"The only deen Allah accepts is Islam…" (TMQ Aali Imran, 3: 19)
[/quote]
Bayshak, but this ayat has no relevance in this discussion.
[quote]
Allah(swt) has very harsh words for those that wish to implment ideas like democracy or communism and other non islamic concepts Allah (swt) says: “And whoso does not judge by whatever Allah has revealed, they are disbelievers” [Surah Al Mai'dah (5): 44].
[/quote]
Again, you are reading something completely different from what I am reading. I am reading here if you disobey His commands and His rules you are a disbeliever. No where in this ayat He says that democracy is kufur or man cannot make his own governing system based on His revelations.
[quote]
If these evidence is not enough for you brother to show democracy as a kufr system which should be rejected than all i can say is may allah(swt) guide you.
[/quote]
May Allah (SWT) guide us all. aameen