alright hanibal, lets try it again.. you said so many times i havent answered your questions that you raised.. (like as if you have answered every questions i asked you..but anyhow).
Really, i guess this is not the case, if yes, then please highlight those questions, i may have missed them and i can always try to answer them.
Agreed. But then again, what is that thing that Dr. Israr sahib really has fun telling? the one eye monster?.. something that will eat fire?? etc? correct me if im wrong but isnt that dajjal?
I think we are not discussing Dr. Israar Ahmed and you may have to back your claim with some evidence, like i said earlier, he may have been quoted out of context or he may have this believe. I am no way going to defend some one's believe neither i am answerable on some bodys comment.
What do you want me to comment here?.. Frankly speaking, I dont even know which sect of people here am i really talking to?.. People like aramis comes and tell me heaven and hell is physical place.. (dont know which school of thought shes from)...if i quote tahir ul qadri or israr ahmad or zakir naik.. you tell me that they can believe whatever they like.. please let me know who really is the ullama from whom you are getting this false interpretation of Quran from? How about moududi? will it be ok for me to quote him sometimes in my posts?
I would like you to take the comments/questions/querries/discusion with open and neutral mind, once you do that, frankly speaking you will see that i have not asked any question, i only had three questions, which were clearly mentioned, and were clearly ignored by you. now i have reposted the questions again and highlighted them in post # 599 of this thread.
again, there is no point me saying same thing over and over. My father was a non-ahmadi muslim and i very well know the beliefs sunni people hold. I also tell you the same to not follow anything blindly either.
Indeed by words you are free to say whatever you like. Calling ahmadis with names is more than enough for someone to show hatred towards them. Why would you want to invite us to the true religion when we already are believer of Muhammad Mustafa PBUH and the religion of Allah .. Islam. ? I have repeatedly said.. our belief is the same, only problem is the recognition of the person. I really want to know what would u be called by other Muslims ( who wont accept imam Mahdi ..whoever it may be for u .. ) if you accept imam mahdi and other muslims dont? would you differentiate yourself from Islam? Put yourself in my shoe and answer.
Christains believed in Jesus (AS) thus, were no longer acceptable by Jews, , Muslims Believed in Prophet Mohammad (SAAW), thus, were no longer acceptable by Christains and Jews. all the time it was matter of one Prophet only. Nor muslims call themselves Christain or Jews, neither a jew or christain call them selve muslim. Yet We all believe in Moses (AS), in Jesus (AS)...
Other Muslims, will not call me anything but muslm, as having faith in Imam Mehdi is nor proven from Quran neither from Hadees, in fact both says, that it is a duty of Muslim to follow anyone, who calls you towards the Quran and Sunnah. May it be Salahuddin Ayoubi, Mehmood Ghaznavi or Sultan Bebris...
You see what your problem is now right?.. We accept each and every hadith provided by ur side.. when we do the same.. you come up something like the hadith is consider da'eef and classing it fabricated. Same is done when we provide you with the prophecy of lunar and solar eclipse. "it is fabricated"...Very well sir. Take that very hadith and reconcile it with another hadith when Muhammad PBUH says (not exact words..will provide exact words upon requesting), that how would it be when Esa AS will be amongst you and your Imam will be amongst you? This shows that the person Hazoor PBUH is referring to is one and the same. He AS is to be given the title of Esa AS but He AS has to be from the ummah of Muhammad PBUH.
The problem from ur side is, u believe each and every word which goes into ur favour and dislike very thing which opposes you or does not suits your belief/desires. The Above hadees was not refuted by me, but by the scholars of Science of Hadees and Science of Men ( Ilm-e-Hadees & Ilm-ur-Rijal) and that is 100s of yer before Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadyani made his cliam. Now, my job was to bring the authenticity of the hadees in front of you, these scholars had nothing against Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadyani, nor does they knew that there will be someone claiming to be a Prophet... they did their analysis and declared the hadees as Fabricated/Daéef.. now u r free to build ur religion on this fabricated/Daeé'f hadees.
Dont believe in the word of jews. It is against Islam to call books sent by Allah as being fabricated. I know, you are now going to quote me for saying that. I also believe they were being fabricated. But to how much extent? you and me are not here to judge that. Theres also some possibility that the word of God you might be referring to as being fabricated MAY HAVE some verses saved.. again, its not for us to judge that. Jews 'rejected' Hazrat Yahya AS to have come as Elijah AS. Forget about what else they have to say. They rejected Hazrat Yahya AS, and hence for that reason they would not be lying. They were indeed waiting for Elijah AS to come. Theres no question in that. Jesus AS pointing Hazrat Yahya AS to be Elijah AS leaves no room of doubt that Jews at that time were not waiting for Elijah's appearance before Jesus AS himself.
but u believing them and to me the only reason u r believing them, is , it makes ur case stronger, despite the fact that these books/testament are declared null and void, u and others are referring to them to make ur point.
Another thing u are banking on, that there MAY have some verses saved, but how would u know!!! Allah All mighty have nullified the books as a whole, and when any cotract or book is declared void, then there is nothing valid or good, the whole thing is gone... but again being an Ahmadi/Qadyani you are free to refer to these books which have been nullified by Allah All mighty and develop a belief for yourself. It will not be a muslim belief though.
Yes being a Muslim, we need to believe in the fact that Zaboor, Toraít and Anjeel were the books of Allah, and same Allah all mighty, tells us that these books have been fabricated, Although, Christains and Jews do not believe that these books have been fabricated. Ahmadies/Qadyanies can join them in believing so.
You say, i didnt answer you? Look at your question. Does it need an answer really?.. When I ask you question, dont put another question on top of it.. rather clear it first and then u have the right to question me. ( nothing against this post of yours tho..but countless times i have asked u question earlier which went unanswered... i thought i'd point that out to you too..)
I have summarized the questions for u in post # 599, as it is seems that you ( for some reason) are not able to pick the questions.
OK. Tell me which school of thought u are coming from? or that if you are with aramis on the issue of death/raised up alive of Jesus AS? So according to you, Jesus AS ( who according to Miss Aramis09 will "NOT NOT NOT" be a nabi ) will come and christians will believe him?.. Very senseless belief. Jesus AS were sent for those people. Them accepting Him AS again make no sense. You will now say that He'll preach Islam. Again, if He AS will NOT be a nabi, how will He AS really understand Islam? What is the need of Allah sending down previous Prophet to preach religion which was revealed to Muhammad PBUH after Him AS? His only mission will be to convert Christians to Islam? When Prophet Muhammad PBUH couldnt do it.. how can a person who is not even a Nabi ,according to aramis09, can accomplish such huge success? I'm amazed how you just randomly thought the last reply i gave you was irrelevent. According to you, all christians will convert to Islam.. what if some dont? will you point a finger then to him being truthful? It is Allah's choice whosoever Allah want to show guidance.. Allah says if i want I can make every single human a believer..its not a problem for him. Why leave this just on Jesus AS arrival? why letting christians die without embracing Islam? Care to explain?
Why my school of thought matter? i have said that earlier in this very thread that i believe in Quran and Sunnah thats all, and i do not believe anything against the teaching of these books nor does i follow anyone blindly, as Taqleed will not be an excuse on the DAY, you may can refer to Sura-e-wawaya in Quran.
Now once u answer me, i'll explain in detail for the rest.
again, you didnt make your point clear.. sure he will not bring new shariyah.. but will He AS be still a nabi? There has never been a nabi of Allah whose purpose is to kill people who dont believe him. Sorry, but this is hard to digest. A prophet whose purpose is to solely kill people who dont believe him. Allah has never given any prophet this right. Why then Jesus AS? (Infact, if you see, He AS will be killing his own people (jews)..) Prophets just fortell that theres going to be disaster if you dont believe him. Killing them, my friend can not be the prophet from Allah.
I don't think so u r right there? Prophet Mohammad (SAAW) went for wars against the Christains and Mushrikeen of Arab and Ajm, the wars ended up killings of many. Allah All mighty have sent Azaab to many nations, the example of Aad and Samood is there in Quran. In the end, when a person insist to no to follow the divine guidance, he is subject to be killed. The Same will happen to those Jews, who will openly stand in front of Muslim Army, with the intentions to kill, so the Quran says, Kill those who kills you and carry on against them untill the Fitna is concluded.. So the same shall be served, unless and otherwise, u have some sympathies with Jews ( i guess Qadyanies and Beha'ies are the one who have mosque in Israel).
It is not easy to say that someone is sent by God. You think anyone can claim to be imam mahdi? Show me a person like Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS whose claims were like Him AS and whose jamaat is like jamaat e Ahmadiyya? You have more danger from Christianity but caring less about Hindus, Sikhs , Zoroastrians etc..?
Actually there are example, Hasan Bin Sabah, Qaramaties, Beha'ies, Ismailies and many more are there.. you need to do some research.
This Riaz Gohar Shahi, have some audiences in Pakistan, i think they are called Anjuman-e-Sarfaroshan-e-Islam (ASI)... so they are there and are growing in number...
Hindus, Sikhs, Zoroastrians they are there and i beilieve in some big number, does that mean they are no right path/religion.. if number define the truth of religion then Christianity is the biggest religion in the world.. ever thought of that!!!
Anyway.. you said Muslims were slaves at the time of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS? u sure? the government of Britain gave Muslims the right to say adhaan out loud when Sikhs stopped Muslims from saying it. Muslims other than that were living peacefully and in harmony .. when were they slaves? even if they were according to you, care to explain who the war should have started against?
Hind maiN mulla ko ju hay sajday key ijazat
nadaaN yeh samjhta hay kay Islam hay Azaad
Jesus AS miracle is limited to Him. No other prophet of Allah can have His miracles.. his miraculous birth etc is for Him. Esa IBN Maryam is dead, but the mission of Esa AS that is said to be that He AS is to bring people to Islam, Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS did exactly the same.
What Exactly he did, that was my question???
You said this so many times. Have you realized that? Reason why i brought Miraaj in the discussion is to make my point clear about death of Jesus son of Mary AS. But you're too much into your own childish questions.
Which BTW you cannot answer!!!
I'll see ur comments on above and summarize this part of the discussion!!!