Bruv they are already made few areas of karachi as their new FATA region - try visting Shershah , Orangi , Suhrab GoTh and all other illegal encroachments , they are living at ..
They have their establishments at each corner of the city ... whether it south , east , west or north ... During riots they all come at Superhighway and cut the city in two pieces , so if you work in city and live at Gulshan -e-maymar , you had no choice but to stay some where in city on such occasions .
Your right these illiterate animals need to be told this is not FATA so don't bring your gun loving culture here. All Afghani refugees need to be kicked out of Karachi asap. All their illegal slums that they have made need to be destroyed. Massive flow of migrants to Karachi needs to be stopped. Im fearing that Southern and central Karachi will be turned into FATA soon. Worst thing about these people is they are trying to enforce their views on karachiites. Just the other day I heard about a spat between some new migrant from FATA and how he told 3 women near a bus stop to wear a burqa or face lashes. A liberal and vibrant city like Karachi has no room for these backward animals.
Notice how I don't use Pashtuns because these people have probably killed more Pashtuns then anyone else.
I would say make Karachi a separate province. Problems arise because of the control of Karachi by Sindhi speaking people, who are as much foreigners in Karachi as someone from Lahore or Quetta. They only use Karachi to fill up their pockets but don't care at all about its problems. In this last budget Karachi was allocated 2 billion rupees, which is the same amount allocated to little places like Nawabshah and Larkana.
Those in Sindh government don't even want to acknowledge the true population of Karachi. To them the city still has 7 million people when actually it is close to 20 million.
So if population is more than double than official estimates then the resources they give to the city are bound to be very short of the requirement. And this will create friction and resentment among people.
And that's what's happening.
To save Karachi, the city needs to get out of the hold of PPP Sindh. Karachi needs to be a province.
wow ... amazing kia solution hai .. Karachi is part of Sindh and will always remain so!!
and dude you just made me laugh .. sindhi are foreingers?? karachi kia ... urdu speaking loogon ki jaidaad hai??? y do u aways bring sindhi and urdu speaking thing in every mqm discussion??
Karachi seb ka sheher hai ..nake sirf ik ethnic group ka! its funny whn you guys say tht .. K
karachi is one city where you will find ppl from every ethnic group .. yet we hear this urdu speakin/sindhi speakin blah blah nonsense!!
i really hope someday you stop seeing non urdu speakin ppl as racist!! just cuz of few ignorants you cant generalize!
To save Karachi, the city needs to get out of the hold of PPP Sindh. Karachi needs to be a province.
I agree with you,
Kaeachi was a federal administrated area till 1969.
The drunk Yahya and his tools did this all.
I remember J.I.. Bhutto and Pir Pagara were opposing this but they did it .
While I can sympathize with Karachi, I do not think it should be a separate province. Karachi is a part of Sindh, demographic changes which have now led to it being a mohajir majority city does not mean that it is no longer part of Sindh.
I'm not a Sindhi.
Sindh can be partitioned into two provinces - northern and southern so that MQM has a greater say in southern Sindh, just like Punjab and Balochistan should also be partitioned.
While I can sympathize with Karachi, I do not think it should be a separate province. Karachi is a part of Sindh, demographic changes which have now led to it being a mohajir majority city does not mean that it is no longer part of Sindh.
Sindh can be partitioned into two provinces - northern and southern so that MQM has a greater say in southern Sindh, just like Punjab and Balochistan should also be partitioned.
It is ok if division is in northern and southern Sindh.
I don't know if Urdu speaking people are majority in Karachi. But either way, the case for a separate province is not based on mohajir majority but based on proper allocation of resources.
If there are proper resources available then there won't be friction between different people in the city.
wow ... amazing kia solution hai .. Karachi is part of Sindh and will always remain so!!
and dude you just made me laugh .. sindhi are foreingers??
Yes. Sindhis from Nawabshah and Larkana are as much foreigners in Karachi as Punjabis from Lahore and Balochs from Qalat.
[quote]
urdu speaking loogon ki jaidaad hai???
[/quote]
Read my posts again. Such a province will belong to ALL Karachiites, including Sindhis, Balochs, Pashtuns and Punjabis. The division should not be based on ethnicity.
Yes. Sindhis from Nawabshah and Larkana are as much foreigners in Karachi as Punjabis from Lahore and Balochs from Qalat.
Read my posts again. Such a province will belong to ALL Karachiites, including Sindhis, Balochs, Pashtuns and Punjabis. The division should not be based on ethnicity.
If you say Karachi belongs to all ppl, then why are you blaming sindhis only. Did Muhajirs & Pashtuns never possess administrative rights for Karachi.
Plz don't create another ethnic bias by calling sindhis as foreigners in Karachi. PPP politician became sindhi when they have to use Sindh card. How many development projects they have started in Sindh (Larkana & Nawabshah, etc) during their tenure. They are just money minded bull****s. Nothing to do with humanity.
Notice how I don't use Pashtuns because these people have probably killed more Pashtuns then anyone else.
That is true. These people first destroyed their own province then they moved to Karachi for labor. But instead of learning from their mistakes they want to inflict the same thing on Karachi and destroy it the same way.
If you say Karachi belongs to all ppl, then why are you blaming sindhis only. Did Muhajirs & Pashtuns never possess administrative rights for Karachi.
Most control of the city is in the hands of provincial government. It does not matter who has administrative rights in the city.
For example, the budget comes from provincial government and it controls police too.
[quote]
Plz don't create another ethnic bias by calling sindhis as foreigners in Karachi.
[/quote]
Why is it ethnic bias?
Karachi is NOT a Sindhi city at all. MQM should stop trying to be Sindhi by wearing ajrak and topi. This is hypocrisy.
Most control of the city is in the hands of provincial government. It does not matter who has administrative rights in the city.
For example, the budget comes from provincial government and it controls police too.
Why is it ethnic bias?
As Rangoli said, impression of giving Karachi as 'Jaidaad' to one group and calling the 'other' foreigners is basis for bias. Why Sindhis are foreigners against the other migrated ppl of Karachi. I don't like the word foreigner for any of group, if you say the city belongs to all. I feel (I may be wrong) that you have generlised corrupt PPP politician with all Sindhi ppl (by calling them foreigners and referring to their origins Larkana & Nawabshah).
Karachi is NOT a Sindhi city at all. MQM should stop trying to be Sindhi by wearing ajrak and topi. This is hypocrisy.
Yes Karachi is a metropolitan city and its belong to all Sindhi, Punjabi, Pashtun, Urdu spearking, etc ppl. No one is FOREIGNER here. To hell with all political parties!!!
Karachi is a city of Pakistan and will remain a city of Pakistan. Anyone who thinks that Sindhis or PUnjabis or Patahns are foreibners in Karachi is a traitor. And it will never become a province get over it.
Karachi was allocated 54 billion Rs in 2010 nearly as much as Balochistan used to get in Mush era and MQM supporters claim it was 2 billion! ! ! but then lying is the religion of MQM supporters.
Why is it ethnic bias?
Karachi is NOT a Sindhi city at all. MQM should stop trying to be Sindhi by wearing ajrak and topi. This is hypocrisy.
Last I checked Karachi was still part of Sindh, when did it change? Did I miss something big like this?
I would say make Karachi a separate province. Problems arise because of the control of Karachi by Sindhi speaking people, who are as much foreigners in Karachi as someone from Lahore or Quetta.
This is something new for me! Mohajers are the owners of Karachi, and Sindhis/baloch are alien to it now?
Khawarij of Karachi are the ones who have declared jihad against Urdu speaking people. This term has religious connotations.
bus, foran nangay ho kar personal attacks par utar aaye?
Karachi was allocated 2 billion for development in the Sindh budget of 2011-12. That’s what I read. And it is not a lie.
You can disagree with me but you have no right to call me a liar.
Last I checked Karachi was still part of Sindh, when did it change? Did I miss something big like this?
Karachi being a part of Sindh does not make it a Sindhi city. Similar to Quetta being a part of Balochistan does not make it a Baloch city. It is a Pashtun city.
