Re: Taliban are Kharijites?
[quote]
Btw dude have you been out there. Socialist Capitalism has come very close to Islamic welfare state concept. There is affordable and equitable justice system, care of those too old or too young or too sick or helpless to themselves. A guaranteed food and health care for all regardless of caste, creed or color.
I believe given the choice between an honest and fair, cost effective and quick justice system along with safety nets for the vulnerable against a state that provides none of this but chops off hands and mandates niqaab and hijaab and beards, my choice will be clear. What would you choose, is the question?
P.S. mark my words and ask Allah on the day of judgement of what is the preferable of the two. You just may be surprised if you have chosen the latter
[/quote]
firstly dude u are missing the whole point
u think people are defending EACH AND EVERY thing that taliban do .....thats not the case
secondly the socialist capitalism u describe is the ideal form of govt in an islamic state
and thats what I endorse as well.....
but this should also be accompanied by the strict moral regulations as enforced by islamic state without this the society will degenerate ....
so why not a society with the socialist economy AND the beards/hijab/no music dancing wine etc kinda like what was established during the pious caliphate
although i do agree with one thing u hinted at ...afgahan "mujahideen" funded by pak army /CIA and saudis were essentially bandit armies of warlords and one of the main reasons they turned against soviets was because of the land reforms that they introduced. this includes the pashtuns/tajiks/hazaras ]