Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

Society Religion & Philosophy
41

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism

It was also practiced by sahaba during the life of Prophet (saww) as we read it in tafseer books under the tafseer of:

[Shakir 5:67] O Messenger! Deliver what has been revealed to you from your Lord; and if you do it not, then you have not delivered His message, and Allah will protect you from the people; surely Allah will not guide the unbelieving people.

The Sunni scholars of Tafseer have confirmed that this verse descended for Hadhrath Ali (as) at Ghadir e Khum. Moreover Hadhrath Abdullah ibn e Mas’ud is reported to have said that:

"during the lifetime of the Holy Prophet (s) we used to recite this verse as:

یا ای ھ ا الرسول بلغ ما انزل الیک من ربک اًن علیا مولیٰ المومنین

1. Tafseer e Durre Manthur, volume 2, page 298, published in Egypt.
2. Tafseer e Fatah ul-Qadeer, volume 2, page 60, published in Egypt.
3. Tafseer e Fatah ul-BaYun, volume 3, page 89, published in Egypt.
*4. *Tafseer Mazhari, Volume 3 page 353 published by Daar ul Isha`t Karachi](http://www.answering-ansar.org/fiqh/kalima_adhan/tafseer_mazhari_v3_p353.jpg) (<= Link to Scanned page in urdu)

I dont know why the stopped it after the death of prophet.

Moreover Everyone shall be questioned about Wilayat of 'Ali (as) on the Day of Judgment.

Allama ibne Hajr Makki also states in Sawaiq al-Muhriqa (Urdu translation page 503) that on the day of judgment, the Wilayat e Ali (as) will also be questioned about, along with the belief in the Unity of Allah, the Prophethood, the revealed books and faith. He writes:

Hadhrath Abu Sa’eed Khidri narrates: “Holy Prophet (s) said that on the day of judgement Allah Almighty will say: Stop them for now, they will be questioned about Wilayat e Ali (as)”
Sawaiq al-Muhriqa, Page 503 (<= Link to Scanned page)

Mohib Tabari records the same Hadeeth in:
Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 116 (<= Link to Scanned page)

One of the Leaders of the Deobandi movement equally admired by the Wahabis Shah Ismail Shaheed echoes the same sentiments in, Mansab e Imamat, page 109-110, published in Lahore. Whilst discussing evidence Wilayat in the next world he says:

We read in Surah Azhab ‘The Prophet is aula (authority) to the believers’, and in the next world his Wilayat will remain in tact, as Allah (swt) says 'What will be the position when a witness will be summoned from each Ummah, and you shall be a witness over them [Surah Nisa]. Similarly the Imam has such authority in this world and the next, which is why the Prophet said 'Don’t I have more rights over the people than they have over themselves, to which the people replied ‘Yes’. The Prophet then said ‘Of whomsoever I am Maula, Ali is his Maula’.** This is why Allah says in the Qur’an that on the Day of Judgement you will be summoned with your Imam and questioned [Surah Safaath], and the Prophet said that we will asked about the Wilayat of Ali"**
Mansab e Imamat, Page 109 & 110 (<= Link to Scanned page in urdu)

42

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

texan dude - thanks man :k:

43

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

You claim you have read and listened to this tragic event many times yet you say…

Imam Hussain (a.s.) is not a prophet.

How was he not able to protect Islam from Yazeed? Considering the fact that you have read and listened many times the tradegy of Karbala, tell me where did you hear this from?

Of course he saved Islam!
Agar bayyat day daytay tou Yazid kay Islam rah jata, Mohammad (a.s.) ka nahin.
Ghar ko luta diya, Islam ko baja liya.

44

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

Little human do you want us to believe that there were no other good practising Muslims besides Hazrat Imam Hussain? There has to be at least one.....or the good Muslims are produced only in so called "syed" families?

[MERGED]~* Habby Birday 2 ~*Paki * Pride*~
45

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

And where did you jump to that conclusion… Yazeed asked for alligance to Imam Hussain A.S. and he didn’t give it… and apparently yazeed ordered to kill him… Had you bothered to read the incident of Kerbala… you would know there were some sahaba of Imam Husain who were killed also… But yeah Imam Husain stood up because he is Imam…

But yeah if you want to know why did Imam Husain didn’t give alligance..let me quote you what I said earlier..in case your ignorant eyes missed it.

Astagfirullah… Do you have any idea what you just said… Nauzubillah Imam Hussan was unable to protect Islam from Yazeed… Do you have any idea what the incident of Kerbala is all about… You said such a big thing so easily… When asked by Imam Zain ul Abideen the son Of Imam Hussain A.S. if his father won and lost the battle of Kerbala, Imam asked him to go and pray two rakat in the mosque, after he came back from the prayers, Imam said till the time this prayers are alive its victory of Imam Hussain A.S.

To sumarize you in short Imam Husain didn’t just fight Yazeed for khilafat or what ever…from what I have learnt from Maulana in majlises and a small prespective I PERSONALLY developed…he raised voice against the system that had developed after Holy Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. After his death whoever came to the throne was regarded Amir ul Momineen irrespective of how did he become Khaleefa. Imam Husain Knew Yazeed was not at all the right person and if he will give alligance he could have introduced alot of bidats..but if Imam Husain would have defeated Yazeed in the battle history probably would have said it was a fight between two princes for the throne and true maqsad of Imam Husain A.S. would have never came forward, but Imam therefore sacrificed his own life and his family in Kerbala with three days of hunger and thirst… and what Yazeed did with the ladies of family of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H.. things like taking their hijab… taking them around the streets of Koofa and shaam… made a show out of them… was clear enough to open the eyes… that anyone who becomes khaleefa is not Amir ul Momineen..this is just my PERSONAL prespective along with several other intensions Imam might have had … Again I am no Alim or maulana to give a bigger or better picture… May Allah forgive me If i don’t do a good job explaining it… or some other issues…Ameen

By the way Asayb… I am still waiting on your answers… ???

Graham Ford to be India's next coach/Ford turned down the offer to coach India
46

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

Dude, I know about the incidence of Karbala...I am asking a simple question..Do you think that in the whole Islamic world of that time, there was not another soul who could be deemed a "good Muslim"? That is all. Spare me the long copy and paste.For the hundreth time, I dont have any beef with Hazrat Ali (r.a), bibi Fatima, Hazrat Imam Hussain or Hazrat Imam Hassan....so dont try to conevrt the converted. Focus on the issue....

47

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

that why he said read up, if you knew the events, you wudnae be askin such obvious questions. :halo:

there were 72 people that accompanied the Imam, so the answer to your simple minded question is a simple ‘No, Imam (as) wasnt the only pious soul’.

The rest of the islamic world were either with yazid, like they were with his father, stayed quiet out of fear, or were plain ignorant of the events going on at the time.

Some Mods are better than others
48

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

would this discussion do any better? Are muslims not being killed by muslims all over the world?Any one who recites kalma tayaba is a muslim. wether they are ahmadi or qadyani or jaffri, or agha khani or being called with any other name? . Would muslims ever correct themselves and would do comparative study, instead of any one kind of muslims blaming all other muslims to be ignorants and bad?

49

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

My question is still same from you all if Hazrat Husain was “Imam” protector of islam why he was unable to protect Islam from yazeed?

Texan_Dude
“Astagfirullah… Do you have any idea what you just said… Nauzubillah Imam Hussan was unable to protect Islam from Yazeed… Do you have any idea what the incident of Kerbala is all about… You said such a big thing so easily… When asked by Imam Zain ul Abideen the son Of Imam Hussain A.S. if his father won and lost the battle of Kerbala, Imam asked him to go and pray two rakat in the mosque, after he came back from the prayers, Imam said till the time this prayers are alive its victory of Imam Hussain A.S.”

Me or any one else are not aganist Hazrat Husain A.S. we are against what you have made him.

the things you have written in bold letters “Texan_Dude” does not justify Hazrat Husain as a protector of islam.

2nd thing its not islam which gets in trouble its muslims who gets in trouble.

and about Quran Texan_Dude
http://www.geocities.com/mamuskh/ZNquran.html
read this link may be it would help anyting for you.

other answars later…

50

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

[quote="asayb"] My question is still same from you all if Hazrat Husain was "Imam" protector of islam why he was unable to protect Islam from yazeed? [/quote] **5. And my qeustion is if Nauzubillah Imam Husain was not able to protect Islam why don't you guys called Yazeed Ameer ul Momineen...Nauzubillah...why don't you guyzz... as you guyzz have been calling his father who ever became khaleefa..no matter how did he become.. even if he chose to ignore the funeral services of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. for this greed.... Its amazing you guyz call any one who becomes khaleefa Ameer ul Momineen...but its strange... a person came and raged a war against Ameer ul Momineen Hazrat Ali A.S and still regarded as Ameer ul Momineen...... you guyzz are some lost soulss... May Allah SWT show you guyzz the right Path Ameen....**

If you have guts answer my question don’t just go in circles… let me mark the above one is the fifth question for you… and I am still waiting on the answer for the 1-4… Oh lemme reword it..some baseless excuse that would still go in circles…

Its not us who made Imams its Allah SWT.. incase your ignorant eyes missed the ayats I quoted for you…let me reqoute..hope this time some thing gets in your head…“And We ASSIGNED from among them some Imams who GUIDE by Our authority since they were patient and believed firmly in Our Signs.” (Quran 32:24) On the other hand, if one becomes the Shia a tyrant or a wrong-doer, he shall meet with the fate of his leader. In fact, Quran indicates that on the day of Judgment people will come in groups, and each group has its leader in front of it. Allah, to whom belong Might and Majesty, said:One day We shall call every group of people by their respective Imams. (Quran 17:71) Now if you think Like Kaleem… thats is if you do think here Imam is Prophet tell me what does the ayat below mean…are there two kinds of Prophets…???

**In the day of judgment, the destiny of the “followers” of each group highly depends on the destiny of his Imam (provided that they really followed that Imam). Allah mentioned in Quran that there are two types of Imams. Some Imams are those who invite people to Hell fire. They are tyrannical leaders of each era (like Pharaoh, etc.):****And We made them (but) Imams inviting to the Fire; and on the Day of Judgment no help shall they find. In this world We continued to curse them; and on the Day of Judgment they will be among the hateful. (Quran 28:41-42). **

I agree Allah is the protector of islam… and one of the way he is protecting is by having Imams as his waseela, who are source of knowledge and defenders of Islam… Ever thought why of all the companions Hazrat Ali A.S. was the only word awarded sword Zulfiqar)…Had it not been Imam Hussain A.S sacrificing his family in the way of Allah SWT you all might have followed Yazeed as Khaleefa also… and God knows have introduced what other innovations in islam… Imam Hussain head was cut off while he was in Sajda…

**1. what a muslim would cut the throat of another muslim with 3 days of hunger **
and thirst…
2. What muslim would become khaleefa and take the hijab from the ladies of Prophet and made a show out of them…
3. What muslims would kill the grandson of Prophet and burry their own soldiers but leave the bodies of Imam Husain and his companions lying in the hot sand of Kerbala..but boy why am I not suprised… doesn’t it come from the sunnah of their first two khaleefa..to whom khilafat was more important than performing the funeral services of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H.

Had it not been Imam Hussain A.S … this ritual would have kept going… and you guyzz would keep taking every khaleefa as your Ameer ul Momineen no matter how many other muslims he had killed to become one… Its Imam Husain who unveiled the true colors of this greed of khilafat… and only his shadat and his family being taken as POW could have shown his true colors…Else you people would have kept taking everyone who succeeds to khilafat as Ameer ul Momineen and kept on with the bidah introduced by them… IF Imam hussain nauzubillah didn’t defend islam..why is yazeed not called Ameer ul Momineen today???

When someone asked Imam Zain ul Abideen A.S. (son of Imam Hussain) if his dad won or lost the war.. Imam asked him to go to mosque and pray to rakat namaz.. After he came back from namaaz Imam Zain ul Abideen A.S. told him till the time the namaz is alive.. Its victory for Imam Hussain A.S.

If Imam Hussain A.S. didn’t defend islam… tell me what was the whole incident of Kerbala about…??? I want to hear it from your mouth… and remember you’ll be answerable to Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. and Allah SWT for all the un referenced rumors you have been spreading to mis led others…

5. Tell me why don’t you guyzz call Yazeed your Ameer ul Momineen… he followed the sunnah of first two khaleefa… like they left the funeral services of our beloved Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. his army didn’t burry Imam Hussain either..whom they killed while he was doing sajda… His dad raged war against Ameer ul Momineen Hazrat Ali A.S and still regarded as nauzubillah Ameer ul Momineen …So what is it to you… Are you gonna say Nauzubillah Yazeed was Ameer ul Momineen… OR .. Did Imam Hussain defended islam???

Had you known the Alamdar of Imam Hussain army..you won’t be talking this stupid stuff today… Hazrat Abbas… son of Hazrat Ali A.S. he was so brave that when he came to battle in Siffin people confused him with Hazrat Ali A.S. and started yellin Al-Aman… its Ali A.S.

Imam Hussain never let him fight because he knew if he would send this brave to the battle field the whole map of the battle would have changed and his maqsad might not have full filled… and thats why he asked him to go and get some water for kids from Nehar-e-Furad but he asked him not to fight… and when he came to the battle field no body had guts to face him… he went to nehar without any fight from sword… Imam Hussain A.S. keh Azeem qurbani pur shak karney walo… Ever thought why did Prophet Mohammad gave such a big hadith to which I posted references in sunni book in my earlier post…

“Husain is from me and I am from Husain.”
What did Imam Hussain do as such or was gonna do???

Look at the following hadith with references from your books…
The Messenger of Allah said: “Al-Hasan and al-Husain are the chiefs of the youth of Paradise and Fatimah is the chief of their women.”

Sunni references:

  1. Sahih al-Tirmidhi, v5, p660, on the authority of Abu Sa’id and Hudhayfa
  2. Sunan Ibn Majah, Introduction 8
  3. Al-Tabarani, on the authorities of: Umar, Ali, Jabir, Abu Hurayrah, Usamah Ibn Zaid, al-Baraa, Ibn 'Adi, and Ibn Masud.
  4. Al-Kubra, by al-Nisa’i
  5. Musnad Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, v1, pp 62,82, v3, pp 3,64, v5, p391
  6. Fada’il al-Sahaba, by Ahmad Hanbal, v2, p771, Tradition (7) al-Mustadrak, by al-Hakim, v3, pp 166,167
  7. Hilyatul Awliyaa, by Abu Nu’aym, v5, p71
  8. Majma’ al-Zawa’id, by al-Haythami, v9, p187
  9. Tuhfatul Ashraf, by Lumzi, v3, p31
  10. Ibn Habban, as mentioned in al-Mawarid, pp 551,553
  11. al-Sawa’iq al-Muhriqah, by Ibn Hajar Haythami, Ch. 11, section 3, p290
  12. Mishkat al-Masabih, by Khatib al-Tabrizi, English Version, Tdadition

Now let me guess you would say a hadith narrated in so many books of your own is going to be dhaeef…

You can view more hadith’s on Imam Hussain with references from your own books at the following website
http://www.shianews.com/hi/articles/islam/0000070.php

Dude you the guru of making an argument going in circles… how about answering my question for once… I never said Allah is not the protector of Quran… I said not one but serveral times..PLEASE READ IT WITH YOUR OPEN EYES.. Allah is the protector of Quran and thats why there is only one version that exist unlike Bible… Its you who have been using unreferenced sources to accuse shias…

Now let me ask you the same question again… HOPING THIS TIME YOU WON’T PLAY YOUR USUAL GAME OF IGNORANCE…

Let me write it again for you… Please answer the question asked… I don’t have time to play games…
1. Aren’t you the one who said not believing the quran is in correct sequence is like doubting on Allah SWT as the protector even though I kinda made it clear no shia doubts in Allah SWT as the protector and therefore there aren’t any other versions of Quran out there like bible but asked you if Quran is in the sequence why is the ayat indicated below is not towards the End

“Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favour upon you, and I was satisfied that Islam be your religion.” (Qur’an 5:3)

Now if this ayat is in Chapter 5, Is only the ayats upto chapter 5 significant for you..since Islam was complete… or rather than us its you doubting the authenticity of Quran… Rather than answering my question you keep accusing us… I asked you for reference about the thing you said that shia believes some ayats on Imam Mahdi being removed… We don’t believe any ayat in the Quran is removed and I made it clear but rather than answering my question you went out saying if you guys doubt the ayat are missing we about doubting Allah… care to give references of where did you learn that from… and if there was any such thing its got to be dhaef because it contradicts the ayat… so please give me references before you make such a claim… or is it one of those other rumors you have been spreading on your agenda to slader shias without any references… if it is so… May Allah give you ajjar for it. if you think its a good deed .. Ameen..because you are trying to mislead other fellow guppies with rumors you yourself never gave references too ..

And also the questions below…

2. You said Islam doesnot care who married who… Based on the light of the argument… Are the wives of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. Ummul Momineen… since Like YOU (NOT SHIAS) said Islam doesnot care who married who.

4. Just for the sake of getting a better understanding so please don’t use it against me to spread rumors…but I have a question…
Like you said Imam is the person who leads namaaz… Imam Shafai, Imam Malaiki and Imam Hanafi are no better than the maulvi at mosque or are they???

For once stop waisting by time and answer the question asked rather than going in circles by coming up unreferences stuff to accuse us or answer questions that I never asked…

51

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

look im not playing games with you i am just giving my opinions and objection if you dint like them just dont answar them.
insted answaring this question for this Ayat i will ask you a question. ok this ayat is not at the end of Quran so what is your point?
its you who is asking me why this ayat is (Qur'an 5:3) is here?

(Quran 32:24)

if you read ayat before that and read this ayat care fully "Imamas" as you said and "leaders" here means "Prophets" not Imams as you claim (Protector of islam) what its syas next is "giving guidance under Our command" only prophets are been given guidance by Allah not any one else.

(Quran 17:71) (Quran 28:41-42)

here imams mean leaders of of the time like Prassident or prime minister.
1. if Imam is a protector of islam then how come Imam invite people to the fire of hell.

  1. After Hazrat Husain almost 1400 years has past how many imam had came for the guidenes of people?

"Al-Hasan and al-Husain are the chiefs of the youth of Paradise and Fatimah is the chief of their women"

Question here is do we need any chief in heaven, as far as i know there wont be any people of groups of diffrent thougths that they will argu or fight with each other or nor there will be countries so why we need chiefs. i read some where (which i will give you the refernce later) that in heaven every one will be the same age around 30 there will be no youth nor elder or very old person so i dont know which youth in heaven you are talking about.

"You said Islam doesnot care who married who.... Based on the light of the argument... Are the wives of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. Ummul Momineen... since Like YOU (NOT SHIAS) said Islam doesnot care who married who."

i am talking about regard of faith if any of Prophit Muhmmad(SAWW)'s wife does not follow islam do you think she could enter heaven.

"Just for the sake of getting a better understanding so please don't use it against me to spread rumors...but I have a question...
Like you said Imam is the person who leads namaaz.... Imam Shafai, Imam Malaiki and Imam Hanafi are no better than the maulvi at mosque or are they?????"

for me they are scholers you can call them maulvi also and i have no dought that they did imamet in Masjids.

52

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

No masterofall240 I don’t rely on lies just to score points.

You have narrations in your own books narrating directly from ‘infallible’ imams regarding the banning of muta marriages.

The narration was reported by at-Tusi in his book al-Istibsaar, volume 3, p. 202 (Dar al-Adhwaa’ 1413/1992 edition) chapters of Mut’ah, Ch. 92 on permissibility of Mut’ah, narration 5/511:

5/511: As for what was narrated by Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya, from Abul-Jawzaa, from al-Hussain bin 'Alwaan, from Amr bin Khalid from Imam Zaid bin Ali[as] from his forefathers [as] saying: The Messenger [saw] forbade the flesh of domestic donkeys and Mut’ah marriage.

At-Tusi disqualified the above narrations of the Imams saying: We ought to base this narration on Taqiyyah because it is in an agreement with beliefs of the public (AhluSunnah).

I think the opinion of Al-Tusi will carry more weight with you than that of the holy Imams.

We too have similar narration from Hz.Ali ibn Talib (ra) on banning on Muta marriages.

Narrated 'Ali: Allah’s Apostle prohibited Al-Mut’a marriage and the eating of donkey’s meat in the year of the Khaibar battle. Volume 7, Book 67, Number 432

53

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

^ Already been refuted here In this very same post. Check thread No #39 or Click Here

54

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

and back to the asayb games of circle… dude aren’t you the one who said if one says quran is not in the order it was revealed he is doubting Allah as protector… I asked you tell me if quran is organized in the order it was revealed it was perfected in ayat 5:3… Care to tell me what does rest of quran means to you…If it was completed in 5:3… you ACCUSED us on doubting Allah has protector… even though I said he is the protector aand thats why athere aren’t any other versions out there… but Oh NO YOU THINK IF ITS NOT IN THE ORDERR ITS REVEALED ITS DOUBTING ALLAH AS PROTECTOR NOW TELL ME IF I ACCEPT LIKE YOU THINK QURAN IS IN THE ORDER IT IS REVEALED..WHAT DOES REST OF THE QURAN MEAN TO YOU…NOW FOR GOD SAKE STOP PLAYING CIRCLE AND ANSWER THE QUESTION… ???

nain....
55

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

[quote=“asayb”]

i am talking about regard of faith if any of Prophit Muhmmad(SAWW)'s wife does not follow islam do you think she could enter heaven.

\QUOTE]
I asked you a SIMPLE question… You said Islam doesnot care who married who… ON THE LIGHT OF THAT ARE THE WIVES OF PROPHET MOHAMMAD P.B.U.H. UMMUL MOMINEEN…YES OR NO??? how hard is it to answer that… stop twisiting arguments… its a simple question ..give me a siimple answer?

Naan Kabab
56

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

The most idiotic thing I ever heard… Incase you didn’t read the ayat let me quote it for you again
One day We shall call every group of people by their respective Imams. (Quran 17:71)
Are you saying we all will be called with the current President and Prime Ministers… What if you have seen plenty of them..will you go with all of them…Subhallah … apkey aqal koh daad dena pareh gah… Rasol Allah koh, Imam koh shoar kar hum apney president aur prime minisister keh saath jaey gey… Dude you go with President Musharraf and Shawkat Aziz… Inshallah us shia will go with our 12 Imams and Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H…Ameen

I am sorry for calling idiotic… I just couldnt find any better words… didn’t mean to offend you… and thats why I said… Had it not been Imam Hussain.. you people would have called yazeed your Ameer ul Momineen and probably followed the bidats he would have introduced… . So how does your logic exactly works..what if the king..primeminister or wat so ever if he is cruel..will Allah SWT call pious people with such KINGS…

Waisey a bit of advice here buddy.. next time if you wanna ignore the truth.. atleast come up with some stuff that makes sense or a normail mind can buy…

57

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

"In the day of judgment, the destiny of the "followers" of each group highly depends on the destiny of his Imam (provided that they really followed that Imam). Allah mentioned in Quran that there are two types of Imams. Some Imams are those who invite people to Hell fire. They are tyrannical leaders of each era (like Pharaoh, etc.):
And We made them (but) Imams inviting to the Fire; and on the Day of Judgment no help shall they find. In this world We continued to curse them; and on the Day of Judgment they will be among the hateful. (Quran 28:41-42). "

you said "Inshallah us shia will go with our 12 Imams and Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H....Ameen" how many of these 12 "IMAMS" of your had invited there people to hell????

"What if you have seen plenty of them..will you go with all of them...Subhallah ... apkey aqal koh daad dena pareh gah..... Rasol Allah koh, Imam koh shoar kar hum apney president aur prime minisister keh saath jaey gey... Dude you go with President Musharraf and Shawkat Aziz... "

after that your saying your self "Inshallah us shia will go with our 12 Imams and Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H....Ameen"

58

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

"I asked you a SIMPLE question... You said Islam doesnot care who married who... ON THE LIGHT OF THAT ARE THE WIVES OF PROPHET MOHAMMAD P.B.U.H. UMMUL MOMINEEN.....YES OR NO??? how hard is it to answer that.... stop twisiting arguments... its a simple question ..give me a siimple answer?"

yes

Naan Kabab
59

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

"3. Forbidden to you is that which dies of itself, and blood, and flesh of swine, and that on which any other name than that of Allah has been invoked, and the strangled (animal) and that beaten to death, and that killed by a fall and that killed by being smitten with the horn, and that which wild beasts have eaten, except what you slaughter, and what is sacrificed on stones set up (for idols) and that you divide by the arrows; that is a transgression. This day have those who disbelieve despaired of your religion, so fear them not, and fear Me. This day have I perfected for you your religion and completed My favor on you and chosen for you Islam as a religion; but whoever is compelled by hunger, not inclining willfully to sin, then surely Allah is Forgiving, Merciful."(Quran 5:3)

Texan_Dude this is full ayat and read this ayat carefully its a question asked its not said that Quran and islam is completed. and i dont have to say what i am trying to prove here. you are the one who is trying to twist Qurani ayat and mislead people.

60

Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)

on my question
"if Hazrat Husain was "Imam" protector of islam why he was unable to protect Islam from yazeed"
you said

"Astagfirullah... Do you have any idea what you just said... Nauzubillah Imam Hussan was unable to protect Islam from Yazeed... Do you have any idea what the incident of Kerbala is all about... You said such a big thing so easily.... When asked by Imam Zain ul Abideen the son Of Imam Hussain A.S. if his father won and lost the battle of Kerbala, Imam asked him to go and pray two rakat in the mosque, after he came back from the prayers, Imam said till the time this prayers are alive its victory of Imam Hussain A.S."

question here is again what was the conflict between Hazrat Husain and yazeed is it Namaz or leadrer ship?
and what were those aspects of islam which Hazrat Husain as a protector of islam was trying to protect?