And 8 weeks later. Same question. Please show me where it states that the Nations of India and Pakistan must do so.
You see the problem is that the paragraphs speaks of the United Nations Representative and not the Nation states.
And only the Nation states can implement any resolution.
In other words you can't read and you are simply posting this because you know you are wrong. You have no come back and instead of accepting you are wrong you are merely posting the same stuff which I have proven is incorrect.
Yeah i know how good your understanding of the english language is ... here is will break it down for you
Requests the United Nations Representative for India and Pakistan to make any recommendations to the parties for further appropriate action with a view to making progress towards the implementation of the resolutions of the U.N.C.I.P of 13 August 1948 and 5 January and towards a peaceful settlement ;
UNSC requests the UN respresentative (i think it was Dr. Graham) at that time .....* to do what* .... to make any recommendations to the parties (That is India and Pakistan) ..... for what .... to take further appropiate action with a view to makinig progress towards the** implementation **of the resolutions of UNCIP.
If you get time ... have a look at the constitution of Azad Jammu & Kashmir of 1974 ... you will get some more insight.
This questions was brough to UNSC under Chapter 6 (thanks for realizing your earlier mistake !!!!!). I will post an outline of what UNSC's role is in this dispute ....
Article 37
Should the parties to a dispute of the nature referred to in Article 33 fail to settle it by the means indicated in that Article, they shall refer it to the Security Council.
If the Security Council deems that the continuance of the dispute is in fact likely to endanger the maintenance of international peace and security, it shall decide whether to take action under Article 36 or to recommend such terms of settlement as it may consider appropriate.
Article 38
Without prejudice to the provisions of Articles 33 to 37, the Security Council may, if all the parties to any dispute so request, make recommendations to the parties with a view to a pacific settlement of the dispute.
So the role of UNSC is to make recommendations .... action is to be taken by the parties !!!!!!
For years I have been told that NOT PROBLEM can be solved without addressing the ROOT CAUSE which India was (and is) not willing to solve from last 60 years.
You can keep cutting the branches to get rid of the tree but unless you take the root out, there is no way you can get rid of the tree. What India is saying that we will not take out the root of the tree but its pakistan's duty to not allow branches to grow.
First and very minor and mandatory step towards solving a problem is that you acknowledge that problem exists and India is not even willing to do that let alone solving it. So much for atoot ang for 60 years!
Please show me when India has not been willing to address any issue ...... i for one will take you up on this one. This is the misinformation that has been going on in Pakistan. The issue of J&K has always featured in all the talks between India and Pakistan.
Even the Lahore declaration made by Indian and Pakistani PM had mentioned that we will settle the dispute. but then to settle you need a partner. The ink of the agrement was not even dry when Pakistani forces (not some rag tag militants) violated the LOC and crossed into Kargil ..... WHY????? If India has agreed to talks to settle why this agression. I mean in the last 60 years if anything Pakistan should have realized that it is not capable of taking Kashmir by force !!! Now some people in Pakistan want to play this "kabbadi" ... sure they are benefitting from it .... bit what about rest of the ergion. They are endagering teh region just for their petty benefits !!!!
Free Kashmir the problem starts there. It will make the sangaparivar theory corret that Muslims cannot co exist with other groups. Utill they gets majority they wil obey the state rule. Once they gets majority starts revolution asking for freedom.
Look ladies. Its a simple point. No UN representative can implement a UNSC resolution. Only nation states can. The fact is that the paragraph you quote refers onlyto the UN representative.
No mention of any actions to be taken by the nation states.
Ask your own government of this if you do not agree
Its a simple point. No UN representative can implement a UNSC resolution. Only nation states can. The fact is that the paragraph you quote refers onlyto the UN representative.
No mention of any actions to be taken by the nation states.
So then as per UNSC how is Kashmir problem going to be solved :D
Ask your own government of this if you do not agree
The Indian governments stand is what UNSC has been saying for a long time ..... India and Pakistan have to solve all their problems, including Kahsmir, through dialougue.
You are the one who brought up the plebisicte issue ....... i just wanted you to see what steps need to be taken for holding a plebisicte. And as is the case in UNCIP resolutions, Pakistan is to vacate the territory held by it in Kashmir. Again this is in plain simple english :D
Free Kashmir and most of Indian problems are solved. Even sanitary problem of: no toilet no bride.
Well India wants to settle this dispute through dialogue .... but if it comes to that ... Indian will try its best endevour to free Kashmir .... the recent steps taken by Pakistan government in Northern areas is the first step for giving the people of that area their rights that had been denied to them since '47 :D
Well India wants to settle this dispute through dialogue .... but if it comes to that ... Indian will try its best endevour to free Kashmir .... the recent steps taken by Pakistan government in Northern areas is the first step for giving the people of that area their rights that had been denied to them since '47 :D
India is totally not willing to settle the Kashmir issue do u not know what is Indian policy?
Its better that you first contact your Indian government and ask them what is their Kashmir policy and then come here and talk.
U make sure there are free and fair ellections in Indian Occupied Kashmir, solve your own mess and problems then look at us because there is no weight in what you say if you only point fingers to others whilst your own country is denying millions of Kashmiris their right of self determination.
India is totally not willing to settle the Kashmir issue do u not know what is Indian policy?
Its better that you first contact your Indian government and ask them what is their Kashmir policy and then come here and talk. .
I know what is Indian government policy that is why i am saying this. As i have mentioned it time and again, India has always stressed talks to settle Kashmir problem. Perhaps you should try to find out what Pakistani government has signed with India before you comment again.
U make sure there are free and fair ellections in Indian Occupied Kashmir, solve your own mess and problems then look at us because there is no weight in what you say if you only point fingers to others whilst your own country is denying millions of Kashmiris their right of self determination.
There have been free & fair elections in Jammu & Kashmir and that has been welcomed by rest of the world :D It is time, as a number of people have asked and EU report had stressed, that Pakistan provide more freedom to people in Northern Areas as it has started doing after almost 60 years !!!!
I know what is Indian government policy that is why i am saying this. As i have mentioned it time and again, India has always stressed talks to settle Kashmir problem. Perhaps you should try to find out what Pakistani government has signed with India before you comment again.
There have been free & fair elections in Jammu & Kashmir and that has been welcomed by rest of the world :D It is time, as a number of people have asked and EU report had stressed, that Pakistan provide more freedom to people in Northern Areas as it has started doing after almost 60 years !!!!
Well you can keep on smiling and telling lies but not a word u rapped about massgraves
Freedom of Indian Occupied Kashmir and raping of innocent Kashmir women.
Of course when u say nothing against it you endorse all that i understand but its sickening i must say.
Well you can keep on smiling and telling lies but not a word u rapped about massgraves
Freedom of Indian Occupied Kashmir and raping of innocent Kashmir women.
Of course when u say nothing against it you endorse all that i understand but its sickening i must say.
Mass graves and rapes are happening becuase of the war like situation created in Kashmir thanks to Pakistan !!!! Why there were no such incidents before 1989 ..... and you can see the reduction in levels of voilence after 20002 when Pakistan was forced, much against its wishes, to turn around and stop supporting terror groups in Kashmir. Infact these same terrorists have now turned on Pakistan .....
Mass graves and rapes are happening becuase of the war like situation created in Kashmir thanks to Pakistan !!!! Why there were no such incidents before 1989 ..... and you can see the reduction in levels of voilence after 20002 when Pakistan was forced, much against its wishes, to turn around and stop supporting terror groups in Kashmir. Infact these same terrorists have now turned on Pakistan .....
I did not expect anything else from you but to endorse human rights violations :)
I can't discuss with someone who has views like you have.
I do not endorse any violence in whatever form unlike you.
I did not expect anything else from you but to endorse human rights violations :)
I can't discuss with someone who has views like you have.
I do not endorse any violence in whatever form unlike you.
Half the time you spend on this site endorsing violence .... but when confronted with a dialogue, like most here, decide to skip it.
Prove it to me when i did endorse violence if you cannot then just keep ur mouth shut please and stop spreading lies.
I am waiting for you to prove it to me when i did endorse violence. :)
Again you are trying to wriggle out of a situation ... here is what i said .... respond to that .....
Mass graves and rapes are happening becuase of the war like situation created in Kashmir thanks to Pakistan !!!! Why there were no such incidents before 1989 ..... and you can see the reduction in levels of voilence after 20002 when Pakistan was forced, much against its wishes, to turn around and stop supporting terror groups in Kashmir. Infact these same terrorists have now turned on Pakistan .....
Again you are trying to wriggle out of a situation ... here is what i said .... respond to that .....
Mass graves and rapes are happening becuase of the war like situation created in Kashmir thanks to Pakistan !!!! Why there were no such incidents before 1989 ..... and you can see the reduction in levels of voilence after 20002 when Pakistan was forced, much against its wishes, to turn around and stop supporting terror groups in Kashmir. Infact these same terrorists have now turned on Pakistan .....
Are u really sane?
What has mass graves of innocent people got to do with War?
I think you are not even understanding what you are writing. :)
Indian sissy soldiers should fight Freedom Fighters they should not kill thousands of innocent Kashmiris who are not carrying any guns or who are not resisting.
Only worst sort of cowards do that. And you are one of those people who is endorsing mass crimes against humanity by saying that its ok that there are mass graves.
In the EU report Indian government is pushed to investigate the mass graves found in Kashmir. So what do you know about mass graves and how can you blame Pakistan? You are really acting childishly because whenever you don't have any anwser the easiest way is to blame Pakistan.
