Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Even Authoritarian regimes are forced to give some concessions to Minorities weather religious or Ethnic...so its no big deal Indian have Muslim Personal law...
Muslim Personal Law does not interfere with working of state..its only different Family Law for muslims
it does not create any kind of problem for hindus?
Interfere or not, it has been granted to muslims in India by hindu majority, this should be the essence.
And plz dont try to convince me concessions of authoritarian regimes, this wont work here where we are talking of equal rights to each and every citizen irrespective of his religious belief. I clearly say, India scores ahead of others in this matter, being an Indian muslim U should agree with this, if U dont, for any reason, plz let me know, I will try to convince U.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Interfere or not, it has been granted to muslims in India by hindu majority, this should be the essence.
And plz dont try to convince me concessions of authoritarian regimes, this wont work here where we are talking of equal rights to each and every citizen irrespective of his religious belief. I clearly say, India scores ahead of others in this matter, being an Indian muslim U should agree with this, if U dont, for any reason, plz let me know, I will try to convince U.
Muslim personal law was in place from british era....it was not granted by hindus ....
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
For you killing of muslims by hindus in gujrat is just a killing, but burning of houses of chritians in pakistan is minorities victimization and that's the "reason" you are ready to welcome the minorities of pakistan. how funny....
Plz dont try to put ur words on me bro, I never said just a killing, but U did. I said killing is a killing, be it out of religious hatred or sectarian hatred. Its U who are trying to differentiate between sectarian and religious killing. not me.
Both incidents are examples of minority victimization.
We want to welcome oppressed minorities on the grounds that they are not given equal religious and political rights. And there is nothing funny in it for me, could be for U for obvious reasons.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Plz dont try to put ur words on me bro, I never said just a killing, but U did. I said killing is a killing, be it out of religious hatred or sectarian hatred. Its U who are trying to differentiate between sectarian and religious killing. not me.
Both incidents are examples of minority victimization.
We want to welcome oppressed minorities on the grounds that they are not given equal religious and political rights. And there is nothing funny in it for me, could be for U for obvious reasons.
Killers of hindus in Godhra are sentenced to death...give me a single verdict where killers of muslim in any riot was sentenced to death?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Muslim personal law was in place from british era....it was not granted by hindus ....
Whatever floats ur boat of dislike towards hindus. But it was upon hindus after partition to grant whatever status they wanted to their muslim bros in India, as it was upon muslims in Pakistan. But both nations worked according to their majority views, results are there for everyone to see and take lessons from, including both of us. NO?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Plz dont try to put ur words on me bro, I never said just a killing, but U did. I said killing is a killing, be it out of religious hatred or sectarian hatred. Its U who are trying to differentiate between sectarian and religious killing. not me.
Both incidents are examples of minority victimization.
We want to welcome oppressed minorities on the grounds that they are not given equal religious and political rights. And there is nothing funny in it for me, could be for U for obvious reasons.
if both incidents are examples of minority victimization, then how can you welcome miniotries of other countries where you own country is in same postion???
that was funny...
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Killers of hindus in Godhra are sentenced to death...give me a single verdict where killers of muslim in any riot was sentenced to death?
Not sentenced to death, but many high and mighty are rotting in jails for killing of muslims in India. And that too under Narendra Modi, its just like that a Sipah E SAhaba guy is chief minister of Sindh and killers of shias are sentenced to jail. amazing no?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
if both incidents are examples of minority victimization, then how can you welcome miniotries of other countries where you own country is in same postion???
that was funny...
Wrong statement bro. It was in 2002 that unfortunate incident of Gujrat happened. Minorities were victimized, but we were potent enough to ensure safety to our minorities and make sure that their rights and dignity remain intact. And we were successful too, because nothing of that kind happened in Gujrat in spite of repeated provocations and attacks on hindu temples. This is where we were successful.
So nothing was funny, it is only ur obvious misconception.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Wrong statement bro. It was in 2002 that unfortunate incident of Gujrat happened. Minorities were victimized, but we were potent enough to ensure safety to our minorities and make sure that their rights and dignity remain intact. And we were successful too, because nothing of that kind happened in Gujrat in spite of repeated provocations and attacks on hindu temples. This is where we were successful.
So nothing was funny, it is only ur obvious misconception.
do you followed what muslim faced after 2002 riots how bank denied them loans...how social boycott was implemented against muslims...
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Hindus are no way more tolerant than muslims...
they discriminated against Dalits for years with out any ideological difference....
I dare U to speak up and discus. If Uf have guts to stand by what U speak.
I often complain to U for not answering to my questions while regularly questioning me. If U are able to discus. I outright tell U that U are lying on this issue that hindus are more tolerant than muslims. If U disagree, than talk if U can.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
I dare U to speak up and discus. If Uf have guts to stand by what U speak.
I often complain to U for not answering to my questions while regularly questioning me. If U are able to discus. I outright tell U that U are lying on this issue that hindus are more tolerant than muslims. If U disagree, than talk if U can.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Come out of ur mentality bro, its responsible for bad condition of muslims in India.
56 hindus died in train burning which was not due to riots, and those culprits were as much responsible for killing of helpless muslims who perished in aftermath.
To name a few, write down names of Maya kodnani, a minister in Modi govt, and name of Munna Bajrangi, president of bajrang dal. they are rotting in jail.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Not sentenced to death, but many high and mighty are rotting in jails for killing of muslims in India. And that too under Narendra Modi, its just like that a Sipah E SAhaba guy is chief minister of Sindh and killers of shias are sentenced to jail. amazing no?
But, ethically, you must not assume superiority of India in this case as you already have accepted that minority victimization happens in Indian also.
Criminals are sentenced in Pakistan also. However it is all because of administration of Pakistan, they are neither serious to crack down shia abusing Sahaba(R.A), nor they are serious to stop violence against shia.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Come out of ur mentality bro, its responsible for bad condition of muslims in India.
56 hindus died in train burning which was not due to riots, and those culprits were as much responsible for killing of helpless muslims who perished in aftermath.
To name a few, write down names of Maya kodnani, a minister in Modi govt, and name of Munna Bajrangi, president of bajrang dal. they are rotting in jail.
Same logic can be applied to bombay riots and bombay bomb blasts?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Come out of ur mentality bro, its responsible for bad condition of muslims in India.
56 hindus died in train burning which was not due to riots, and those culprits were *as much responsible for killing of helpless muslims who perished in aftermath. *
To name a few, write down names of Maya kodnani, a minister in Modi govt, and name of Munna Bajrangi, president of bajrang dal. they are rotting in jail.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
come on these are facts..:D
May be facts, but unless I dont know how, I cant be convinced, even by ur rock-solid grin. I again dare U to tell me how muslims are more tolerant than hindus, if U can do this by words, and not by sweet grin.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
But, ethically, you must not assume superiority of India in this case as you already have accepted that minority victimization happens in Indian also.
Criminals are sentenced in Pakistan also. However it is all because of administration of Pakistan, they are neither serious to crack down shia abusing Sahaba(R.A), nor they are serious to stop violence against shia.
Minority victimization is often tried to be done in India too, this is a fact, but it happens less often as in case of Gujrat about 11 years ago.
Criminals are sentenced in Pakistan too, this is a fact, But not criminals who are religious goons, as in India, Maya kodnani (A minister) and Babu Bajrangi, (a muslim hater) are cooling their heels in Jail. U must have noticed the difference. So Paksitan is still a safe heaven for religious goons, and high and mighty unlike in India.
And we are not superior to anyone, leave alone Paksitan.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Same logic can be applied to bombay riots and bombay bomb blasts?
U can do anything U like, but facts are facts, and neither mumbai blasst accused, nor Gujrat riot accused, nor Godhra train accused, all are janwars in guise of humans, u can selectively choose ur friends out of them, but all are in same league for me, thas the big difference.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
U can do anything U like, but facts are facts, and neither mumbai blasst accused, nor Gujrat riot accused, nor Godhra train accused, all are janwars in guise of humans, u can selectively choose ur friends out of them, but all are in same league for me, thas the big difference.
they why blame gujrat riot on muslim culprits of godhra..?