Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
[quote]
what RIGHT does India have to interfere in Malaysian business.
[/quote]
By the same analogy why are the muslims across the world protesting against the Israeli atrocities against the palestenians.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
By the same analogy why are the muslims across the world protesting against the Israeli atrocities against the palestenians.
Gr8, so now Hindus are understood the sentiments of Muslims, and now they should acknowledge the fact that, Muslims Govts. ( not only Pakistan) reserve the right to interfere when ever muslims Masscares and any other violation of Muslim rights by any power group or state ( which happens to oftens) take place in India.
Henceforth, Muslims States can take those issue to UNO or any other International forum, and;
you hereby acknowledge that Pakistan isright when it comes to take a stand for Muslims in Kashmir
Please now comment on above.
and if you still think that by any mean Muslims States does not have this right or such act by Muslim Govts is direct inteference in internal issues of India then either it is hypocracy or it is something i cannot say in this forum
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
You guys criticising India here are simply bereft of facts. All you are interested in blabbering something is wrong with India, without any basis.When as much as 60 to 70% of seats in schools and jobs are reserved for what you call lower caste if you still come here and blabber about discrimination, all it shows is you are jealous of our progress and having no other way to show it come and say this nonsense here.
It is not as if you guys don't discriminate. In fact it is worse. Look at how many divisions there are amongst so called muslims and how each is killing the other!
It is shameless of you people to then come here and speak ill of India!
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Stircasey, have a read:
I don’t have more to say on this. Topic is sensitiv and we already are way too offtopic. Whats happening in Pak is off-topic here, since we are discussing about “racial discrimination” of Tamils and not Pakistani Pathans.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
I don't have more to say on this. Topic is sensitiv and we already are way too offtopic. Whats happening in Pak is off-topic here, since we are discussing about "racial discrimination" of Tamils and not Pakistani Pathans.
But somehow the clowns here talking about lower castes is on topic?
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
But somehow the clowns here talking about lower castes is on topic?
Is that off topic? Let me see...
Excerption:
Indiansaccuse Malasiyans of discrimination.
Malasiya tells India not **to intefere*.
**Hindu activists* create the scene.
Other "sort" of discrimination in India **given **as example.
"Solve discrimination matters in India first", say Pak Guppies.
Indians GS Members blame Pak GS Members of derailing.
Hmmm...
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
i think this is another term invented by non-muslims, when they don't find any logical answer for any event they label muslims as bias.. my question to you is.
what RIGHT does India have to interfere in Malaysian business.
The same right that the world has to denounce Tianamen Square incident, to denounce Burmese incident, to denounce Emergency in Pakistan or any injustice that happens in the anywhere in the world.
Why are you so supportive of Malasian governments attrocities. Is it because it is against Hindus? I am not trying to lable muslims as bias, because there are a lot of muslims who think it is wrong.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Gr8, so now Hindus are understood the sentiments of Muslims, and now they should acknowledge the fact that, Muslims Govts. ( not only Pakistan) reserve the right to interfere when ever muslims Masscares and any other violation of Muslim rights by any power group or state ( which happens to oftens) take place in India.
Henceforth, Muslims States can take those issue to UNO or any other International forum, and;
you hereby acknowledge that Pakistan isright when it comes to take a stand for Muslims in Kashmir
Please now comment on above.
and if you still think that by any mean Muslims States does not have this right or such act by Muslim Govts is direct inteference in internal issues of India then either it is hypocracy or it is something i cannot say in this forum
The Indian community in Malasia are not blowing up bombs in buses and cars. They are not asking for seperate country for them. They are asking for same right as any other citizen. India gives that right to its minorities and more...
Analogy does not stand....
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Is that off topic? Let me see... Excerption:
Indiansaccuse Malasiyans of discrimination. Malasiya tells India not **to intefere*. **Hindu activists* create the scene. Other "sort" of discrimination in India **given **as example. "Solve discrimination matters in India first", say Pak Guppies.
Indians GS Members blame Pak GS Members of derailing.
Hmmm...
same thing if would have happened to muslims in a non-muslim land then see your reaction. you'll be jumping all over the forum.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Strange. Just replace the words Malaysia with Dubai or KSA, and Tamil with Pakistani, and watch the angry Pakistanis start posting about how these Arab countries don't even consider us equal, and don't even give residency to hard working Pakistanis. Just search, and you will find this sentiment all over gs.
Yet, since this involves Indians and Tamils (who are actually Malay citizens), our Pakistani brothers on this forum are opposed to even hearing the issue.
And why is Malaysia trying to shove religion down everyone's throat? I thought Malaysia was that "Modern" Muslim country?
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Is that off topic? Let me see... Excerption:
Indiansaccuse Malasiyans of discrimination. Malasiya tells India not **to intefere*. **Hindu activists* create the scene. Other "sort" of discrimination in India **given **as example. "Solve discrimination matters in India first", say Pak Guppies.
Indians GS Members blame Pak GS Members of derailing.
Hmmm...
does goverment of india do any discrimination??? we have reservations for minorties. do not act like headless chicken!!
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
same thing if would have happened to muslims in a non-muslim land then see your reaction. you'll be jumping all over the forum.
THe way things have been lately, Islam and Muslims are suffering a lot.
So where should I start....
@ your second post: Have a read on the link I posted above!
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Yeah Muslims discriminate on caste that is why a lot of dalits and shudras actually converted to Islam!
Our authoritarian general may be all that but he is facing demonstrations from the people. We are not taking it sitting down. The general has had to doff the uniform and if he does not listen to the people he will have to go as well.
You may be a democracy but that does not ameliorate the repression that minorities have had to endure. I think members from every single religious minority and lower castes has been set on fire (Mybe Tibetan buddhists are an exception). Gujerat, Babri Masjid, Golden Temple, even christians including Graham Staines and his two boys aged 7 and 9 sleeping in their jeep.
they will not convert to muslim son, if you know what i mean. It was a backward hindu if I use the term, that went after the innocent muslims in Gujarat. Now u get the drift. The most stingent hindutva brigade are made up of hindus from BCs or OBCs. Besides it may be out of topic,but I cannot help bringing this up, are muslims one entity? No. They kill each other. Should I elaborate. What is going on with shia sunni massacres. Arent their exist a divide, discrimination and mistrust.
Being a democracy it has its problems. All democracies face it. If you know Indian democracy intricately you will not say what you said. Dalits play a huge role in states like UP and Tamil Nadu. The party of Tamil Nadu anti aryan anti brahmin party is the foremost in demanding action against Malyasia and insist on Indian govt take it up with them. But you will not recognize all this , because for you India is 80% hindus and anything happening in India is because of Hindus and because of their religion.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Gr8, so now Hindus are understood the sentiments of Muslims, and now they should acknowledge the fact that, Muslims Govts. ( not only Pakistan) reserve the right to interfere when ever muslims Masscares and any other violation of Muslim rights by any power group or state ( which happens to oftens) take place in India.
Henceforth, Muslims States can take those issue to UNO or any other International forum, and;
you hereby acknowledge that Pakistan isright when it comes to take a stand for Muslims in Kashmir
Please now comment on above.
and if you still think that by any mean Muslims States does not have this right or such act by Muslim Govts is direct inteference in internal issues of India then either it is hypocracy or it is something i cannot say in this forum
Pakistan never took a stand or are u too young to realize that
u guys are always getting involved in everything pertaining to muslim world. Danish cartoons, isreal-palestine, etc etc. If something happens in some part part of the world you blow urself up.
Here they were protesting peacefully. And in India too the protest was at this point peacefull. There were not many rallies or blockade of malaysian embassy unlike other proest in Islamic world.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
The Indian community in Malasia are not blowing up bombs in buses and cars. They are not asking for seperate country for them. They are asking for same right as any other citizen. *India gives that right to its minorities and more... * Analogy does not stand....
YES, we have seen the prime example of THOSE RIGHTS in Gujrat-RIOTS, and iam sure that in next few years another will pop-up( keeping Indian RIOT history in mind). The reason those Malaysians have not blown them selves becuase they knew Malaysian Govt. will notice their peacefull protests, whereas Muslims in India don't get that kind of response, Army/State Authorities and/or state led goon parties burn them alive, rape their women and slaughter their children. Tell have this happend in Malaysia???
Any way ur comment started as "... Indian Community...", if Indian Community is unhappy with their state of life in Malaysia and/or they feel that they are mis-treated their why don't those INDIAN COMMUNITY members goes back to India and pursue a better life?
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Pakistan never took a stand or are u too young to realize that u guys are always getting involved in everything pertaining to muslim world. Danish cartoons, isreal-palestine, etc etc. If something happens in some part part of the world you blow urself up. Here they were protesting peacefully. And in India too the protest was at this point peacefull. There were not many rallies or blockade of malaysian embassy unlike other proest in Islamic world.
Ur statement make me laugh, pardon me, but i think u r a comedian, are aware of what ur a typing? i guess not, drink a glass of cold water and then read ur reply in conext of the text u have quoted...
But u haven't justified the RIGHT of indian govt. to intefere in Malaysian Affairs? if yes, please let me know where u did that..
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Ur statement make me laugh, pardon me, but i think u r a comedian, are aware of what ur a typing? i guess not, drink a glass of cold water and then read ur reply in conext of the text u have quoted...
But u haven't justified the RIGHT of indian govt. to intefere in Malaysian Affairs? if yes, please let me know where u did that..
Oh I think I troubled you sorry!!
It is useless to talk to a kid. You mock somebody when u cant match him with reason.
I dont have to give a reason for the involvement as it is already been given a thousand times (may be not by me but many posters here). But for a blind man with a strong racial and religious intolerance it will seem all bakwas.
Its on humanitarian grounds and the involved groups have close relationship with India. it is indias right to raise concern over what happened in Malaysia.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
YES, we have seen the prime example of THOSE RIGHTS in Gujrat-RIOTS, and iam sure that in next few years another will pop-up( keeping Indian RIOT history in mind). The reason those Malaysians have not blown them selves becuase they knew Malaysian Govt. will notice their peacefull protests, whereas Muslims in India don't get that kind of response, Army/State Authorities and/or state led goon parties burn them alive, rape their women and slaughter their children. Tell have this happend in Malaysia???
Any way ur comment started as "... Indian Community...", if Indian Community is unhappy with their state of life in Malaysia and/or they feel that they are mis-treated their why don't those INDIAN COMMUNITY members goes back to India and pursue a better life?
Where do u live.!! in Pakistan.:). If not then I dont understand how you can be so unreasonable in your second para.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
YES, we have seen the prime example of THOSE RIGHTS in Gujrat-RIOTS, and iam sure that in next few years another will pop-up( keeping Indian RIOT history in mind). The reason those Malaysians have not blown them selves becuase they knew Malaysian Govt. will notice their peacefull protests, whereas Muslims in India don't get that kind of response, Army/State Authorities and/or state led goon parties burn them alive, rape their women and slaughter their children. Tell have this happend in Malaysia???
Any way ur comment started as "... Indian Community...", if Indian Community is unhappy with their state of life in Malaysia and/or they feel that they are mis-treated their why don't those INDIAN COMMUNITY members goes back to India and pursue a better life?
So u mean malaysia require an LTTE kind of organisation (may be more tuned to Hindutva), just like you have jeish and other stuff. Well now I am pretty sure that you are blind.
Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?
Oh I think I troubled you sorry!! It is useless to talk to a kid. You mock somebody when u cant match him with reason. I dont have to give a reason for the involvement as it is already been given a thousand times (may be not by me but many posters here). But for a blind man with a strong racial and religious intolerance it will seem all bakwas. Its on humanitarian grounds and the involved groups have close relationship with India. it is indias right to raise concern over what happened in Malaysia.
Yes it is bakwas it comes to show a mirror to India, or ask what right India have!!! but it is fair when India intefere in others affairs is that what u are saying, or ur saying that INDIANS in malaysia is in trouble thats why Indian govt is feeling the pain... so far other than a draging issue here and there ( typical indian behaviour) u r not able to justify the grounds on which India is entitled to intefere in other Countries domestic issue.
Any way have India conveyed same kind of message to UAE govt. where thousands of Indian Employees ( others were there too, but indians were in big number) where beaten and then deported.. now don't say that is not humanitarian issue...