Should India support Malaysian Indians?

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

I am from Pakistan, but i don't understand how can Some Malaysians ( who are treated badly) can be INDIAN COMMUNITY, when they born and brought up in Malaysia, when they call them self Malaysians, When they are asking their rights from the Malaysian Govt. how come they can be called Indian Community... they are Malaysian who were brought to Malaysia way back in history... the sooner u learn this the better it is....

But, oh, one of ur leader Once said, that muslims does not belong to India, they came from other lands so they should go back to their lands.. i don't know which leader may Bal Thakray, but this surely tells us Indian Mentality... when it comes to the right...

Question still exist, if so-called INDIAN COMMUNITY is so unhappy why don't they come back to India a start a happier life.? Why don't Indian govt. says to them, come home and we will treat you better?

The core is, one who live in glass house should not throw stones on others. If India want to be the champion of human rights, then please provide few of them to people of Assam, Kashmir and other places where the villages of LOWER CLASS peoples are burned ( lower hindu castes).. once India overcome this thing, then it have right to point out others..

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

you are confusing too much. UAE issue is a labour issue, they have a house to go back to India and India will accomodate them. Malaysia is different. They have been living there for centuries and are malay citizens. In UAE, rights as a citizen is not there in the first place. In malaysia they are citizens and should be given the right of a citizen just like other malay are given. Since the victims are of indian origin India mainly raised the concern to give it a a bit more weight it required (rightly so) to get that protest to be heard in the powers that is in Malaysia

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

Citizen rights in India does not discriminate between different race or religion. More over it gives preferential treatment to communities in need of help. Some rights are taken away in parts where there is insurgency. Nobody is waging a war in India because they are denied any rights. You are confusing riots and rights. Riots and citizen rights are mostly independent. The riots happen when extremist group in a society resort to killing each other when their dispute cannot be solved by peacefull means. India give all rights to its citizens. No Indian muslim will come here and say that they were denied to call for prayers, to practice sheria, to assemble and worship.
When such things are denied in Malaysia it is the right of every nation including India to question malaysian authorities.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

In US there is Indian Community, Chinese Community, Black Community, Jewish Community and many more - Still all are Americans.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

Since you exclude recent migrants, you will realize that the others moved from an undivided India?

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

True, and we know that, there is discrimination their as well... so if any one of them stages a demonstration, and any other country ( like INDIA though i know that india will never dare) will ask USA to keep indians happy (In case of Indians)...

The core which i have mentioned earlier and u have neglected due to Indian policies, i dont know if u are capable to have discussion on that or not..

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

True only he Indian and INDIA is screaming with the pain of those INDIANS... isn't it... :)

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

U need to talk to ur cable operator (or whom ever appropriate) to have a news channel install in ur house.. thats all is requried at this time... once u update urself with ground realities then we will talk

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

so on humanitarian grounds why dont, India accomadate them, is it becuase most of those INDIANS( Malaysians) are poor and lazy, so Indian govt. knows the fact that they will only be a burden to their economy...

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

is their any discrimination in job supported by goverment.Hell no

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

yes thats true, and 90% of them are Tamilians

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

not according to indians though. but shh, they don't know india is a third world backwards country.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

boss when you see a Desi guy in Immigration counter, you will feel very happy , but when you reach him and he asked you 200$ just to stamp on your passport, which is not a fee but a bribe, then what do you say they are not thiefs, if you goto police station you will see tamils in the lockups- if any Taxi Driver charge you more then the actual charge then its a tamil,

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

There is no Indian government policy which is against the minorities. There are many that favor them.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

No, but because they are Malasian citizens.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

We all know India is a poor country, but is developing fast.
And all Indian are fully aware of this fact.
Anyways this is not the discussion.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

yes, 100% of the Government policies are for Minority and 0% for Majority

In India the government works only for Minority,
because our PM is Minority and Last President is Minority and Latest Vice President is Minority
Andhra CM is Minority
Andhra Assembly Speaker Minority, Home Minister Minority, Education Minister is Minority
Kerala CM is Minority
TN CM is Minority (oops he don't have religion and he believes there is no Ram)
Arunachal CM is Minority
J&K CM Minority
Meghalaya,Manipur,Mizoram CM is Minority
the most populous state Uttar Pradesh CM is Minority

the list goes on.............I tired of writing
any where in the world do you see this, It Happens only in India

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

Hey watch it! I am a proud Indian too and we all know that. But I also realize why we are poor - because the Brits treated us as a supply colony for England. Before them the Moghuls were more interested in building palaces or mosques and did very little to industrialize.

We are now undoing the damage caused by almost a 1000 years of such misrule and guess what? we are well on our way.

So we may be poor but neither 'third' world nor backwards. That is why we are exporting civilization and culture to the rest of the world increasingly - Vedic knowledge, music, natural medicine - and the people who get it it are loving it.

Jai Hind!

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

StirCasey, If Moghuls only built mosques. Then I consider Taj Mahal a mosque too. Since you are not so keen on keeping it, let us shift It to Pakistan! It just a mosque anyway.

Re: Should India support Malaysian Indians?

^ of all the things you're interested just in Taj Mahal? Take it man if that will make you happy...Come to think of it, I cannot think of a better gesture to make the two countries together.

Now, what do we get in return?