Sajda.....

Re: Sajda.....

That's your personal view. Doesn't make it "civilized" or correct. It's just your view. Sorry to burst your bubble. It would be nice if people didn't judge others for their love for God.

Re: Sajda.....

This appears to be a nice fall bake strategy of right wing fundamentalists. Throwing around " grow up" to those that have a different opinion. About an hour ago same pair of words was used in another thread.

This is a forum with folks having diverse opinions. IMO best to make ones case with logic than to toss around phrases such as grow up to anyone that disagrees!
Cheers.

Re: Sajda.....

There's nothing to disagree on when there's no issue. It's just OP's bias towards religious folks and religion.

Re: Sajda.....

Practise what you preach Southie jee and quit labelling everyone who disagrees with you a fundamentalist. About an hour ago, you also used the same words for another member, and now for Janjua. It would be nice if you could have a discussion without labelling others biased and extremists. Cheers to you too.

Re: Sajda.....

You will be relieved to know there was no bubble burst. We all have our opinions. I knew that.

No one judged anyone for their love of God. Some of us just have a DIFFERENT opinion re: repeated and excessive public display of religiosity.

I am not smart enough to claim my view is correct or the only correct one.

Re: Sajda.....

Humaji I absolutely do not describe anyone who disagrees with me as a fundamental extreme right. The person wrote a sentence re liberals. I used the same sentence and replaced with fundamental right wing. Post 47 in that thread will verify what I am saying. You are welcome to visit that thread and state your position on the context within which I used fundamentalist.

Januj I brileve also took a poke at liberals. So please do not be selective here. Cheers!!

And by the way a fundamentalist is on the opposite end of a liberal. I see you don't appear to have problems with Aceones and Januja using such words. Aceones was putting down progressive Muslims in the other thread.

Since you have requested me to be consistent I would respectfully request you to be so too.

Re: Sajda.....

PD do you have same views towards guys making cross after scoring goal in soccer and other games?...just asking

Religion is a personal issue. Who they pray to, who they thank to and how they thank should be left to them as long as its not effecting others.

and on second point that on one hand they are cheating and on the other hand they are doing sajda, who are we to decide who is allowed and who is not allowed to do their religious rituals. Allah has never said that if you do X gunnah, do not come back to me so how about we leave it b/w them and God as long as its not effecting us?

I'll have a problem if someone want to do Zuhar Namaz on the pitch while game is going one because it will effect everyone else but 10 seconds sajda does not effect me and rest of the 21 players.

Re: Sajda.....

In post 39 Januja used the word biased. So what gives Huma jee?

And are you picking and choosing here? Both Januja and Aceones used " grow up" to the " liberals".

The Aceones related thread was about unity and tolerance. His opinions went 180 deg opp of spirit of that thread. At the least I would have expected you to provide positive input in that thread abt unity and tolerance. Rather than quote me out of context from that thread.

I am glad we are having this civil discourse in a transparent and public manner. Both of us can learn and grow. Win win don't you think?

Huma
Just realized Januja used the bias word TWICE in this thread post 39 and 43. Look forward to your being consistent and decrying his use of this word. And that goes for you too Hadeel. Cheers

Re: Sajda.....

Loving this noak jhoank. :)

I am like "you are right" and "you are right too". :)

Re: Sajda.....

difference of opinion is good. One should welcome it - not get threatened by it.

Re: Sajda.....

^

Okay maybe it's just me but why every other thread has to be bombarded by you with so-called lectures and rants about difference of opinion?

Janjua did say it was your personal view (just like the rest of have ours). He admitted it. Then why the unnecessary argument?

Re: Sajda.....

Dear Southie, in every other thread you come across as uptight, trying to prove a point and putting down others who hold totally opposite views. If you do it all with sarcasm, I'm all for it but I don't think such is the case.

I'm not the least threatened by your opinion, you have the right to hold it but just don't come here and say what others are doing is in "poor taste".

Re: Sajda.....

Staying with cricket:

Well Mathew Hayden (Australia) used to make the cross after achieving a milestone ..... Mohammad Yousaf aka Yousaf Youhana (Pakistan) did it quite regularly ..... Dilhara Fernando (Sri Lanka) does so even though he plays rarely these days, a few other SL players ..... i remember AB de Villiers giving a passage/verse of the Bible during the post match presentation (talking about belief) after they chased a mammoth 414 against Aussies at the WACA in 2008 i think ..... Darren Sammy is another example who every now and then takes a reference to Bible or Jesus AS ..... Sachin Tendulkar looks/points up to the sky and says a few words when he reaches a milestone which could be interpreted as a religious gesture

These r just a few

On the other Hand one may ask him/herself for what is the SAJDA when at the same time u cheating ur nation

Re: Sajda.....

Hadeel - if you have a specific difference of opinion on any of my posts please go to that thread and if you want to, make your case.

As for unnecessary argument - an exchange of views is just that. I am not sure I have engaged Januja since. In fact I have not respoonded to his last reply to me - post 43. I could be wrong.

Re: Sajda.....

Ok I will respond to this. You take the poor taste out of context. I stated those who repeatedly and overly exhibit their religiosity - in my opinion - do so in poor taste. I did NOT refer to posters here as having poor taste!

As for being uptight or not - that is indeed your opinion. And I respect it. Cheers!!

And talking of putting other people down who disagree with me - if you are going to refer to my past posts. It is fair I bring up one of your posts in the lessons to Pakistani Muslims thread in PA forum.

For context the OP spoke about Sikhs allowing Muslims to use their facility for prayers. It was a good gesture. One forum member indicated he would be happy to return the favor. Here was your response. People can decide for themselves if your response to those you disagree with was uptight or significantly worse. So I would suggest sticking to topic at hand and not lecturing on how to treat others who one disagrees with.

Thanks

E=Janjua39;9066837]He didn't allow idol worshipers nor people who bowed down to a book. Sikhs let Muslims pray in their gurdwara, up to those Muslims who prayed to decide what was the right choice. But to expect Muslims to have idol worshiping in the house of Allah, shame on you.

Re: Sajda.....

[quote="Zero_one, post:114, topic:268753"]

Staying with cricket:

Well Mathew Hayden (Australia) used to make the cross after achieving a milestone ..... Mohammad Yousaf aka Yousaf Youhana (Pakistan) did it quite regularly ..... Dilhara Fernando (Sri Lanka) does so even though he plays rarely these days, a few other SL players ..... i remember AB de Villiers giving a passage/verse of the Bible during the post match presentation (talking about belief) after they chased a mammoth 414 against Aussies at the WACA in 2008 i think ..... Darren Sammy is another example who every now and then takes a reference to Bible or Jesus AS ..... Sachin Tendulkar looks/points up to the sky and says a few words when he reaches a milestone which could be interpreted as a religious gesture ]

Re: Sajda.....

[quote="Zero_one, post:114, topic:268753"]

Staying with cricket:

Well Mathew Hayden (Australia) used to make the cross after achieving a milestone ..... Mohammad Yousaf aka Yousaf Youhana (Pakistan) did it quite regularly ..... Dilhara Fernando (Sri Lanka) does so even though he plays rarely these days, a few other SL players ..... i remember AB de Villiers giving a passage/verse of the Bible during the post match presentation (talking about belief) after they chased a mammoth 414 against Aussies at the WACA in 2008 i think ..... Darren Sammy is another example who every now and then takes a reference to Bible or Jesus AS ..... Sachin Tendulkar looks/points up to the sky and says a few words when he reaches a milestone which could be interpreted as a religious gesture]

and i can come up with 100 more similar examples but they don't make any difference to the discussion...these are isolated examples of few individuals .. mohsin khan did sajda when he scored 200 in Lords...and it was awesome....... no one has a problem with that. ..but there was no policy issue or an agenda.

*I am making a different point altogether....give me one single example of a national team who represents its country and yet exhibits religiosity on a collective basis to drive an agenda. *

And that is exactly what Pakistani team is doing for last 7 years. Waqar did that, inzi did that..yoyo did that, misbah did that, afridi did that, and now hafeez is doing it...so obviously it is not a coincidence. It is a policy issue not an individual act...and yes every playing eleven from Pakistan did that since early 2002 ... by peer pressure or by choice, who knows.

No other national team does that in any other sports. Please don’t give individual examples...is dhoni doing it as an indian skipper or are other indian players doing it in every match for last 10 years? Are Aussies doing it? is every aussie skipper doing it for last 10 years? Come on...don’t deviate from the real point.

And not sure how many times I have to repeat this...the moment you put the Pakistani uniform on, you have only one obligation and that is to your country. It is not personal anymore.... and it becomes far far more important when you do it on a collective basis ....you are representing your country and as a team you have decided to follow a certain religious path...how come it is personal? I*t has consequence to team’s harmony and pakistan’s brand.*..it is not personal...we have minorities in Pakistan.....what message are you giving to them? what message are you giving to minority players in the team?

So please don’t tell me what a certain player did in NFL or elsewhere...give me an example when the USA team did this on a regular basis and on a collective basis... let me know when a saudi team did that or a Bangladeshi team did that....on a collective basis...for years! So no more individual examples please.....

and let me be clear...it does not matter if they are moral or amoral... absolutely does not matter...even if they are angles, i will still have the same point. They are using Pakistan platform to drive an agenda and give a certain label to my country's brand and disturb team's harmony....it will absolutely disturb team's dressing room....

I mentioned their character just to indicate hypocrisy. But that point has no impact on this discussion. I cannot judge them anyway and stand corrected on that point.

Re: Sajda.....

of course it is not about interrupting the game... please dont mix issues...

and of course it is impacting other people...more than anything, it is impacting my country's brand....what if dhoni and 10 other hindu players were doing it for 5 years in a row? *and that too in every match....do you have any idea how aggressively pakistani press and masses would have reacted....they would have called indian team and india racist..what makes you think that people are not making same assumptions about the Pakistani team and Pakistan?
*

the issue is fundamentally about using a PAKISTANI Platform and promoting a certain religious practice and thus labeling my country in a certain way....

**and the question that I have is simple: who has given authority to these players to use a Pakistani platform to promote religion?

c**an anyone on this forum say with full confidence that 100% of Pakistani population wants our players to do this?...and if answer is that 1% does not want this practice to be continued... or in principal even if one person has problem with it, well then these players cannot do it....this is not their personal platform. They were selected to represent Pakistan to play cricket not to promote religion. Yes absolutely fine when someone does it upon achieving certain milestones once in a while but it is a different issue when the whole team does it as a policy for 10 years.

When people from other countries watch Pakistani team doing this on a regular basis for years and subsequently develop a certain image about Pakistan because of this practice , then I have a right to protest that my team stop doing it because it is impacting my country's brand in today's world. It is not an individual act. It has been in practice for 10 years by every captain of Pakistani team and by every playing elven...

I **ask what if we had 30% minorities in Pakistan? you think Pakistani team could do that? i am sure answer is NO WaY...

but you can do it now because we have only 3% minorities....awesome!!!**

Re: Sajda…

When Muhammad Yousuf was Yousuf Youhana, he used to make cross and last time I checked Christians are in minority in Pakistan. So no, it has nothing to do with being in majority or minority.

I am not sure why you are taking it as “promoting religion”. You are just trying to set unreasonable standards here. This really is a slippery slope. Whats next? Players cant say “Thank God I took his wicket” because some atheist might get offended and our “brand will be damaged” ?

Why are you so “offended” if people from other “countries” develop “certain image” of our team? Do you get offended at same level when you see Ganguly wearing red thread on his wrist? or some Australian wearing Cross? or when you see pictures of SriLankan meeting some budhist preacher (or whatever they call him) before leaving for a cricket our to get blessings?

We should not be ashamed of whatever religion we follow. I am not offended seeing these pictures of SL and no their “brand” is not damaged.


Restored attachments:

I like the sajdah ritual. I havent followed cricket on a regulat basis in a long time but from what I remember it was usually a couple of players on the team that would do a sajdah and that too when they won a final or someone made a century.

As far as the thanking Almighty Allah (havent heard anyone say Bismillah yet) in the beginning of EVERY post match interview - yes that is getting a bit tiresome. If you want to mention God in your interviews by all means do so...but maybe it should come naturally and not seem so rehearsed. The whole "first of all I would like to thank Almighty Allah" in response to a very specific question just seems odd. How about answer the questions and add a "Thank you God, teammates, mom and fans! peace sign