Nothing wrong with what Mirza said, he only stated the truth...did the mahajreen came loaded with jewels and other bounties...And I am a urdu speaker from Karachi...
^ Agreed. Bad things should be condemned and should call for apology. Having said all this, will you ppl condemn AH for his statement against partition of Indo-Pak. Had your Quaid apologized for talking against a cause for which hundreds of thousand lives were scarified.
All I have seen clips, never the full context of the speach. If he said what you say he said, then I will say it was an unfortunate comment.
Most of these lives lost were those from minority provinces.
All I have seen clips, never the full context of the speach. If he said what you say he said, then I will say it was an unfortunate comment.
Most of these lives lost were those from minority provinces.
The context is very much there in the clips i.e. victim card of MQM.
It doesn't matter 'lives of whom', minority or majority province. The point is ppl had given sacrifices to make this country and calling that a 'blunder' should call for an apology from all the nation.
An emotional statement. This forum is full of threads attacking Urdu speakers. You started most of them. Give a single example of a single post of mine which is anti-Punjabi. None. I said most lives lost were people from minority provinces, not all. Obviously, it is a historic fact that people were also killed in East Punjab, a Muslim minority region. Your Muhajir hatred sickens me, and its shame that you continue to peddle untruths about partition.
An emotional statement. This forum is full of threads attacking Urdu speakers. You started most of them. Give a single example of a single post of mine which is anti-Punjabi. None. I said most lives lost were people from minority provinces, not all. Obviously, it is a historic fact that people were also killed in East Punjab, a Muslim minority region. Your Muhajir hatred sickens me, and its shame that you continue to peddle untruths about partition.
Don't deviate from the point by referring to sacrifices of minority / majority province.
We want to know whether or not Mr Altaf Hussain's statement was condemnable and needs apology by AH from the nation. This is bcoz you have challenged someone for condemning a statement from Zulfiqar Mirza. How do you support Mr AH for calling partition of Indo- Pak a blunder ? For your convenience, I've posted a video link in the relevant thread, where AH is saying something about his statement.
Don't deviate from the point by referring to sacrifices of minority / majority province.
We want to know whether or not Mr Altaf Hussain's statement was condemnable and needs apology by AH from the nation. This is bcoz you have challenged someone for condemning a statement from Zulfiqar Mirza. How do you support Mr AH for calling partition of Indo- Pak a blunder ? For your convenience, I've posted a video link in the relevant thread, where AH is saying something about his statement.
If you care to read my post, I said that I needed to know the context. I'm hoping to be in London in a few weeks time. I will put it straight to them to get their story.
^I’m providing link for AH’s justification on the statement.
As far as context is concerned, that racist Mirza statement also had a context and background i.e. wall chalking for Muhajir Sooba and he was talking about those persons who have demanded for separate sooba through wall chalking. His statement was not targeted at all Urdu speaking ppl, he was angry at ppl demanding separate sooba and was reminding some facts (which he considered fact and you ppl consider as myth). BTW, its time for MQM to issue a clear statement for / against separate sooba. If I’ve missed that statement, do post here.
lo karlo gal. jiton di khoti utay aan khaloti. Khoji and Diwana what you have to say about this kalabaazi. Killing of eighteen innocent people and burning of properties for no reason at all. Is ko kahtay hain “Gunah-e-be lazzat”.
**KARACHI: Muttahida Qaumi Movement chief Altaf Hussain has directed Dr Ishratul Ibad Khan to take charge as governor of Sindh, DawnNews reported.
Hussain had asked Ibad to work in harmony with the federal and provincial governments under the guidance President Asif Ali Zardari.
Meanwhile, the president welcomed the statement of the MQM chief asking Ibad to resume work as Governor Sindh.
The president termed it a good omen for harmony and reconciliation.
Presidential spokesperson Farhatullah Babar said that the president welcomed Ibad, who will immediately return to the country.
Khoji and Diwana what you have to say about this kalabaazi. Killing of eighteen innocent people and burning of properties for no reason at all. Is ko kahtay hain "Gunah-e-be lazzat".
You think it was all loss and no gain? Actually, anytime MQM has returned it has always gained something from PPP. so, aage aage dekhiye hota he kya. Especially to Racist Sindhis.
Just ask how that Mirza topi thinks about MQM governor coming back in power again. Sindhi racists and their leader have been completely shut off. So much so that MQM agreed for the governor to return.
BTW, killing people is PPP wadera-Sindh specialty. As much as you hate Altaf, he actually appealed to stop that killing. If killing is what MQM wanted then Altaf would not have refrained his workers to stop agitation.
MQM still has not decided to return to the government. This means that it is looking for MORE powers.
^ Agreed. Bad things should be condemned and should call for apology. Having said all this, will you ppl condemn AH for his statement against partition of Indo-Pak. Had your Quaid apologized for talking against a cause for which hundreds of thousand lives were scarified.
I think there is no reason to condemn Altaf's statement. It is enough to disagree with it. After all, he didn't call for elimination of Pakistan. This is in contrast to Sindhi racist Mirza's statement, where he said that he had made up his mind to actually start working against Pakistan.
Now THAT is clearly condemnatory.
Are you trying to say that ordinary urdu speakers are such racist pigheads that they killed 18 people bcoz of a political statement? I guiess you will be fine if Sindhis killed 18 urdu speakers if outraged by wall chalkings.
And who said it about ALL ordinary Urdu speakers? There are such people everywhere. And the need is to punish all of them regardless of ethnicity.
The writings on walls was actually something that should be done. And if it results in killing of people then such pigheads must be punished.
Its nothing in this thread to take 192 posts and go on!! what it made to long that just few dont wana digest that Zulfi statement is condemable and start bashing on other stuff. whats wrong if we accept that Wrong is Wrong!! and what AH did or doing bla bla bla is a way of escaping from real mater.
You obviously have some comprehension problems, racists here suggested that killings were not doen by MQM but by ordinary urdu speakers, it was response that lie.
"Ulta chor kotwal ko dante" or "khasiani billi khamba nochay" Show me one post where you consider it be racist.
Now this is pure racism but you will not condemn this racist because you are one of them
Just ask how that Mirza topi thinks about MQM governor coming back in power again. Sindhi racists and their leader have been completely shut off. So much so that MQM agreed for the governor to return.
BTW, killing people is PPP wadera-Sindh specialty. As much as you hate Altaf, he actually appealed to stop that killing. If killing is what MQM wanted then Altaf would not have refrained his workers to stop agitation.
You obviously have some comprehension problems, racists here suggested that killings were not doen by MQM but by ordinary urdu speakers, it was response that lie.
Again, the choice of words was bad.
"Ulta chor kotwal ko dante" or "khasiani billi khamba nochay" Show me one post where you consider it be racist.
Now this is pure racism but you will not condemn this racist because you are one of them
I said focus on MQM all you want. You posted pictures before which do not mean anything. I can give you a long drawn answer with more arguments which would make you realize why I think your posts smell of racism but I feel it would be a waste.
Still the fact remains, Muhajirs gave a lot to Pakistan and this is the bitter truth which racists cannot swallow.
The idiot Mirza sparked unnecessary event and the reaction was also out of proportion. Hence I started the thread which I hope gave you answer to your concern.
Nothing wrong with what Mirza said, he only stated the truth...did the mahajreen came loaded with jewels and other bounties...And I am a urdu speaker from Karachi...
My family didn't come from bihar like some so please don't generalize.
Anyway, mirza is zardari's bull dog who barks at his orders. But, seriously what can you expect from a chotay level ka chapraasi like zardari except miracles?
My family didn't come from bihar like some so please don't generalize.
Anyway, mirza is zardari's bull dog who barks at his orders. But, seriously what can you expect from a chotay level ka chapraasi like zardari except miracles?
Sorry didnt' know you were the fifth grandson of Nizam of Daccan and sailed on his personal 400 foot yatch, laden with gold, jewels and cash, towards Karachi...