Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
[quote=“usmanshahid”]
for the state of argument , i say i agree with you
now tell me didn’t the beard was in practice at that time or not
if yes then why Ghamdi doesn’t have that
isn’t that clear cut rejection of Sunnah
i don’t want to listen that sahaba and muslim didn’t understand Hazoor PBUH but Ghamdi did etc etc etc
i don’t want to listen thoes lame excuses again and again
answer in YES OR NO\QUOTE]
Usman! you need to stop your imagination here. Why you are accusing others for which others don’t say? For your information, beard was also kept by Abu Jahl, Abu Lahb and all the enemies of the prophet. Qur’an only talks about beard once, and that is of Faroah (Fir’oun). It is a purely cultural thing. Prophet Muhammad never made it explicitly part of the religion and all the Fiqh books before 3rd century doesn’t even consider it a Sunnah. I don’t know why you believe that traditionalists are correct:confused:
[quote=“usmanshahid”]
do i have said that they were prophets
do i
do i said they didn’t mistake
go and study my previous post
pure a lame excuse to defend your imaginar god Ghamidi \QUOTE]
You didn’t try to understand the Ahadith which I quoted before. I gave you examples from prophet’s life about pollination of date trees and Battle of Badr. In Ahadith, he said explicitly that he is fallible in worldy affairs and in the other stories, he proved in his act, Aml. What more proof do you need? Your explanation for these hadith is purely fictional and beyond the scope of the words of ahadith. Read the hadith again. Please!
I am also a human being. When I direct you about something which relates to your religion, take it from me and when I express my own opinion [about something which is outside this sphere] then my status in this regard is nothing more than that of a human being … I had conjectured about something.1 Do not hold me accountable for such things which are based on opinion and conjecture. However, if I say something on behalf of God, take it because I will never forge a lie on God … You very well know about your worldly affairs. (Muslim, Nos: 2263, 2361, 3262)
The prophet always says true about religion and in religion, he is definitely infallible authority. But in medicine, I will not follow what he was following 1400 years ago, rather I’d go to medical practicitioners of today. As prophet never declared himself authority in every faculty of life. Instead of asking others, you should see your interpretation of hadith while keeping the overall structure of religion.