Re: Isa (AS) dead or alive. In the light of Quran and Hadith.
I suggest you keep your post to the point and not address anyone else but me. Keep your posts short and directly related to the topic. Do not bring my beliefs in it. Lets talk about Isa (AS)'s based on Quran.
Again, when did the conversation took place between Allah and Isa (AS) ?
Answer : This conversation took place when Isa (AS) was alive. If it had taken place after His bodily ascension the verse would have been something like " I have cause thee to die" but the fact that it says "will cause thee to die" explains He AS at that time still was alive. You will then say that it means He AS still is alive ? Well, the 4 promises made by Allah out of which 3 have been fulfilled, the first one should have been fulfilled too.
Also, keep in mind the pattern in which Allah promised Isa (AS). He will first give him death and then fulfill all the other promises ( exalting,freeing from wrong charges, giving superiority to those who believed him etc. ). For all the other 3 promises to be fulfilled, Allah must have to give him death.
Quote me specifically where you dont understand. If everything is fine, then quote me from the first page of this thread where i mentioned a couple of verses proving His (AS) death. If you have something to add to them, quote me and ill reply.
If you want i can quote myself and can wait for your replies on it?