-HUMSAFAR-

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I agree.

The whole super jazbati Psycho lover klling him/herself at the end is pretty typical of B grade 'romance' novels. In my opinion, its been done so many times that it just looks pathetic now. Its not like we haven't seen enough of Sara's destructive behaviour, but even for one last final push, giving her a mental breakdown and putting her in a psychiatric institution would've delivered the mesage. I mean how many times did they try to glorify suicide attemps and self harming in this drama, and all of that through Sara? Its like jeez...come up with something new.

Its an idealistic thought but I was really hoping that they would give Sara's character a hopeful ending. Simply because in real world, there are more girls who could relate to Sara's obsessive love and heartache than Khirad's oh so dignifed silence. There are people in the real world who suffer much more, go through pure hell and endure serious heartache in life, yet they survive. Its such a shame how Pakistani media focus so much on being dramatic by using cheap shock tactics, instead of conevying good positive signals. In short, I wanted to see Sara recovering and learning to get on with her life than killing herself.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I'm annoyed thought it was last episode hence y I hate watching dramas they so long winded

I saw the episode wasn't impressed. I was expecting so much more. Today episode showed a lack of good direction. When I read the forums looks like others felt the same way. I hope and pray for a powerful ending. I think that the director of Maat hit the jackpot with yesterday's ending. It ended on such a strong note. Everybody who I talked was thrilled at the ending!

Fareeda's monologue about her feelings and how Asher just coincendentally hears everything is characteristic of a B class drama serial. True the production team didn't know of Humsafars popularity but i think they the audience a decent ending. I was disgusted with baber javed a ending OF Mzzb. It was poorly done for an outstanding drama. All I know was I was grinning after masts ending. A drama needs to start strongly and end strongly.

Next weeks promo about when Fareeda says Hareem is not Asher's daughter is beykar. There is DNA testing in this day and age and Ashwr is filthy rich. anyways kind of reminds of maat second last episode where I had no expectations from the ending.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

OMAAA!!!

They had to kill Sara, didn’t they??

F!

The ONLY good thing that came out of this episode was Fawad Khan’s acting when he read the letter. Bus!

I dont wanna watch the last episode anymore :grumpy:

re: -HUMSAFAR-

THANK YOU!

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I think it was a wonderfully done episode, as always. The fact that it seems a drag to some may be because Hum TV has a bad habit of giving away a lot of details in the promos. Other than that, I think all aspects of the episode, from Sara's suicide, to Asher/Khizer confrontation at his office were done just right. Asher didnt have to go postal on Khizer at the office, as that would have created a scene. Besides, he doesnt even want to see his face. Why would you expect him to prolong Khizer's presence?

Fareeda Aunty is doing it just right. Her facial expressions, though bland at times, reflect her situation very well. A very well directed play indeed.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I liked today's episode and seeing zareena see her daughter made me cry. Poor Sara was given so much hope that she had nothing to live for anymore I do think that suicide should not have been the answer but then there was no way that conversation would have taken place between zareena and fareeda (about meree hai lagey gee tum ko)....

It must've taken khirad a lot of guts to leave her daughter and it could only have been done while everyone was asleep. I wish though that Hum would not have given up the final words of Asher from the novel in the promo. A promo with some music would have been good.

ya true thatshe lost all feeling. when she finds out about sara death she is still only worried about ashar where he has gone
[/QUOTE]

If it is actually deliberate then is only worried about by outed by Khizt. She is now deathly afraid that what she did 4.5 will be discovered. She is so motive driven and worried about herself that she cannot comfort her sister. If Sarah is not alive then she is useless for Fareeda. We all know of these character type who only use people to achieve their goals. Sarah discovered this in the episode where Fareeda takes rishta for Khizr.

What problems was Atiqa Odho having when shooting started for this serial ? WHy was she the fist woman to be moi soi or whatever.....what does that mean? can anyone shed light on that? It was so vague...

re: -HUMSAFAR-

this is what wikipedia says

On June 5, 2011, Odho was caught at Islamabad Airport for possessing two bottles of imported liquor. She was scheduled to travel to Karachi from Islamabad by PK-319 flight.[SUP][7]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-6)[/SUP][SUP][8]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-7)[/SUP] Odho told ASF officials that she had previously been taking champagne but none stopped her before.[SUP][9]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-8)[/SUP] She was allowed to go by the officials without taking any action apparently due to influence used by her.[SUP][10]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-9)[/SUP]
Subsequently, she tendered her resignation from party’s basic membership following the instructions of APML’s senior leaders.[SUP][11]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-10)[/SUP]
Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry took suo moto notice of the incident and the case was taken up for hearing on 8 June 2011. Sources said the FIR had been lodged on behalf of an Assistant Collector Pakistan Customs in the Airport Police Station. She has been booked on the charges of carrying two bottles of imported wine.[SUP][12]](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/#cite_note-11)[/SUP]

re: -HUMSAFAR-

Those reviews are quit good on the website link you provided. That author also wrote the tea trolly ad review which caused such a hungama here … Hehehe

re: -HUMSAFAR-

i think 1st scene was played very well when fareeda is sitting with harem but on her phone not talkin to her and when shes gone doesnt even say bye shows how insensitive and selfish she is and becoming

re: -HUMSAFAR-

Anyone knows what happened to the Atiqa ohdo liquor case? Supreme court took Suo motu and then what was the result? Was she arrested and convicted?

re: -HUMSAFAR-

yea clearly people here dont agree with a lot of stuff on that website, as you can see everyone loved the episode there and mostly everyone didn't like it here! Lol.
i dk why but i think the episode was a great one, thats why i suggested you guys go read those reviews and comments, might shed light to some of the queries here =)

also, they do a pretty good job reviewing other dramas as well. :)

re: -HUMSAFAR-

it got adjourned to 4th of feb. Prosecutor side lawyers needed more time or something , thats what I heard on Ary,
I think the case is still going on .

it got adjourned to 4th of feb. Prosecutor side lawyers needed more time or something , thats what I heard on Ary,
I think the case is still going on .
[/QUOTE]

Interesting. Bringing in imported liquor wow.....I suppose we shouldnt judge our actors.....just on their acting.

Personally I think Hina Bidayat- Sara's mom in Humsafar was awesome. She did an amazing job. Atiqa odhos acting pales in comparison. She definitely is good looking and looks like she could be Asher's mom but her acting is not consistent. Perhaps her legal troubles and personal turmoil account for this.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I watched episodes 21 and 22 back to back.

I didn't think episode 22 dragged, it's a good transition episode to the finale. Khirad leaves for hyderabad without telling her daughter or Ashar. I was thinking she'd at least mentally prepare Hareem that she'll be leaving, but she doesn't. I don't think it would've been easier on Hareem either way, and perhaps she's expecting Hareem to understand when she's a bit older. Sometimes a clean separation is better than an emotionally dragged out one. She had already told Ashar she'd be leaving, and didn't feel it necessary to inform him just when...she probably should've not that he's her husband, but rather the father of her daughter which she's leaving behind, and he'd need to handle Hareem appropriately. The scene when she's crying while Hareem was sleeping was so wondefully done, was very heartfelt. I *almost *cried.

Ashar - Khizar confrontation was in line with Ashar's character which is to act first and think later. He's done that time and time again in this drama, so really not out of character for him to shove Khizar out the door without listening to him. J*ithay di khoti othay aan khaloti.*

Sara and Zareena scenes were so well done. Naveen was brilliant. When she says "mama mein sona chahti hoon" & when she comes back to hug her mom after getting up, you know it's a last goodbye to her mother. She's gone to place of no return. I'm an optimist, and would've really liked to see her in london, pulling herself together slowly, or even getting some psychiatric help would've been nice. Psychiatric disorders are under recognized and under treated in Pakistan, and this just proves that. Sara always had the psychotic/obsessive tendencies, and one attempt of suicide, so her death wasn't completely out of place...it's believable. I for one am glad they did not show her last thoughts before suicide, there's too many gullible people out there, not to mention young kids that watch this play.

Hina Bayat was really good! The post suicide scenes were really well done by her, you really felt for her.

The rain scene, and Ashar reminiscing about his better days with QB's voice and background score!!!! Wah wah. Then he goes searching for the pictures and finally finds that fateful letter which he had conveniently thrown away in the junk (act first think later)....

Fareeda aunty is beginning to go crazy, she's talking aloud to herself to keep herself sane, as no one's really there for her anymore to listen to her, not even her son. You can sense Ashar's strained relation with his mother, after she goes on a rant about Khizar and Khirad and divorce...he doesn't say much. Anyway, her way of announcing Sara's death as "Sara marr gayee hai", yes it could've been a little more tactfully, but given her mindset, she's really falling over the cliff. She's desperately trying to locate her "shandaar" beta, and can't and knows she's about to lose the closest thing to her so her dialogues are a reflection of that. Anyone else agree that Atiqa Odho's facial expressions are a lot more effective than her dialogue delivery? Though I think her dialogue delivery is many times better towards the end of the play than the beginning, and I'm finally appreciating her as the evil selfish heartless MIL. Glad they didn't use Saba Hameed, she's done that role way too many times.

Ashar, the realization, his baybasi, his heartache. Brilliant. He finally cried in a way that seemed real.

Please for the love of God, let the next episode be the final one. I will miss watching this :( I really hope they release it on DVD soon after it's over.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

i catched episode of kalajado thought saba hameed should have been fareeda then ( i haD hardly seen any of her dramas anyway) and my mom said the same that she has done this typeof role too much it would not feel special lol

re: -HUMSAFAR-

I frankly believe that everyone here is expert at 'over-analyzing'. And some people here just call every episode a drag, just because they are dying to know what happens in the end. That's not fair. Last episode was done beautifully, but the self-proclaimed critics of GS have the same old refrain.

re: -HUMSAFAR-

Hey everyone has an opinion -- and the right to air it. I can totally see why people like this serial (great acting, production values, lots of eye candy, relatable situations and characters, tons of emotions sans the melodrama) and the way past episodes have been received the expectations are somewhat unrealistic for a spectacular finale given the people who made this were just making another serial. It needed more work in a lot of areas. I've never been a huge fan but that's okay, Sara and Fawad's acting (with A/Odho) made this totally worth it.