I will try to get my hands on the shujra of baloch which only the family of khan of kalat has jo unko hazrat noah se connect karta hai will post it here pir meri confusion khatam hogi then give me ur opinions
Balochs in Sindh are considered Sindhi in our society. They speak Sindhi, follow Sindhi traditions. Its not correct to say that 40% of Sindhis are of Baloch origins. Recent reserach shows that many Sindhi castes have been categorised as Balochs. Dr Nabi Bux Khan has been criticised by new researchers to tag everything in Sindh as Baloch.
Apart from all that Blaoch tribes like Chandia, Jamali and Jatoi are known as Ba-roch (Not Baloch) and their language is different than Balochi spoken in Balochistan. An other point that Sindhi researchers are now raising that 13 districts of Balochistan got Sindhi majority population and their langauge is Sindhi. These include Las-bela, and Sibbi. There are books on Sibbi dialects of Sindhi language. A sizable portion of ‘Shah jo Risalo’ is written in the diction of Sindhi spoken in areas forming part of Balochistan.
As far as import of culture is concerned a major theory developed in recent years is about Karo-Kari. It is said that typical Sindhi society didn’t have these honor killing concepts and these customs only developed due to tribal migration in Sindh.
original Sindhi castes include Solangi (Maachi / Malah), Chaaran, Memon, Samma, Soomra, AbRa, Panhwar, Laakha, etc
Famous non-Baloch Sindhis in media are : Humera Channa, mehtab Akbar Rashidi (Mehtab Channa), Salah u din Tuniyo (father of Fahad Mustfa), Abida Parveen (her husband was Shaikh), Sanam Marvi, Sakina Sammo, Sultana Siddiqui (Chairperson Hum TV Networks), Anwar Solangi (late), etc
can’t say anything with surety. But ruins of MehrgaRh tells us that Balochistan’s civilisation (7000 BC) is one of oldest civilisations in the world and was inhibited way before people / nations started migrating from regions mentioned in Abrahamic religions.
brahui speaking people are baloch me peechay is ka reference b de chuka hun or discuss b karchuka hun han albatha Ghilzai kharoto hotaki are turkish not pathan
Let people express their views. If you got opposite views, just present that with reference. This will help people learn more about your race and its history. Otherwise, no one will be interested to share his views.
Just expressing an opposite view on a historical topic is not anti-race or traitor. This attitude of considering your views as fragile only suits to dictators. You know history didn’t get one version. Raja Dahir may be hero for some groups in Sindh, but he has been portrayed as ultimate villain in popular history of Pakistan. If tomorrow I open a thread on Sindh and Sindh’s history and any member come up with popular version of history regarding Raja Dahir, I don’t think I got right to call him / her anti-Sindhi. Try accommodating different and opposing views, research further for your views. This will help increase your knowledge and also will help you in other fields of life.