"Go to your Room" in America?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by M: *
Ashti opinion may be based on islam, but the way hes explaining them is rather immature and stupid.
[/QUOTE]

Yaar I don’t like sugar coating my words, kisi ko karwey lagte hein to lagein, I just say things the way they are.

[quote]
I think rather than forcing segregation, parents would be better of explaining the reasons and benefits behind them. Cause otherwise as some people have said, the moment they turn their backs, the kids get upto stuff.
[/QUOTE]

It’s not supposed to be forced, from day one you are to teach your child sharm-o-hayaa and to behave a certain way, educating them together with segregation is the way.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Mamaof3: *
There isnt much that I disagree with on Mr Ashti's views with the exception of the extreme (as I see it) separation of the sexes. How could a woman ever function normally "out there" in a western society after being segregated all her life?? Its just not possible.
[/QUOTE]

It’s possible to grow up in a segregated environment and then upon necessity work in a mixed environment later on in life.

I know a few guys from back home in my segregated village who came here and settled down fine in the mixed environments, it takes some getting used to but it aint impossible.

By segregation I don’t mean keeping women locked up 24/7 that’s one extreme and the other is unnecessary intermixing at parties etc.

quit talking about sharm-o-hayaa, if you really had some, you would not have posted your picture. Your picture has corrupted the women and a few men on this board and they all are just waiting for a chance to pinch your butt.

To you it would be disgusting, a Hindu is a versatile, changes colours like a chameleon with no real values but we have a set of moral values, a code of honour, and a way of life, which never changes.

We don’t take the cowards way out like some people by adopting somebody else’s values and culture so that we don’t get ridiculed/abused/laughed at we stick to what we believe is right.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by a_bad_hair_cut: *
quit talking about sharm-o-hayaa, if you really had some, you would not have posted your picture. Your picture has corrupted the women and a few men on this board and they all are just waiting for a chance to pinch your butt.
[/QUOTE]

It was kind of freaky how all the girls and a few guys started sending me pm’s and I don’t even know them, that’s why I took it off. :D

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ashti: *

Shikra by ‘our girls’ I meant girls in our community in our English town, which originate from Chach and NWFP.

Still, "our" is not a proper word to use. Just because they are originally from your province, doesn't make them "YOUR" girls.

<<<>>>

You didn't get my point. The point was: Those girls do wear hijab and their parents do care about their daughters.

<<>>>

My point again. That IS what those girls are doing. They wear hijab so their parents think they are going to the library to study or going to a female friend's house but instead they are going in clubs, getting drunk, going to their boyfriends' houses to have sex.

<<>>

The situation you explained above happens only when parents have too many restrictions on their daughters. Yes ofcourse there are exceptions. But if you explain to the girl what's right and what's wrong, she'll use her own judgement and make right decisions. She will fear Allah. On the other hand if you force the girl to wear hijab, don't meet guys, and don't go out, she'll do it when you (parents) are there but won't do it when you (parents) are not there. She'll do all the good stuff out of the parents' fear, not Allah's fear. Get my point?

<<>>

Munney, we are having a discussion here, not a fight. QUIT using disrespecting words such as Bey-gharat, Maraasi, rann-mureed, and pet dogs etc and stop assuming facts. We are in 21st century. Even though you are from NWPF, you'll have to let this "I am the man and I have control over the house, my way or highway" attitude. It's for your own good. OK?

Like I’ve already mentioned the wedding night thread was purely for educational purposes.

Alright.

I’m not Tarsa Huwa, yes at my age any guys hormones are running allover like crazy at times but I know how to control mine and why would I be Tarsa Huwa? There’s enough brown arse pant shirt wearing, Urdu speaking girls at my school who lust after me, I’m a natural born heartthrob without the need to wear shiny polished shoes, fair & lovely, geeky suits and trying to act all modern in everything I say and do.

Wake up. The sun is shining. It's morning now. Good morning kiddo.

[/QUOTE]

It was kind of freaky how all the girls and a few guys started sending me pm’s and I don’t even know them, that’s why I took it off. :D <<<

people PMed you requesting you to take the pics off, no? If I am way off, can you summarize the contents of the PMs?

Ashti not even a single person has said anything about you or your people being backwards, yet you have brought it up more than once. Being so ghairatmand and khaandaani you shouldn't be using the disgusting language you have been using either.

Xara it's not about the way he lives or the way women of his family are made to live, but the fact that he feels so self-righteous about it and the disgusting langugae he uses for the rest. Just cos a girl is allowed to sit amongst her male relatives or has gone to a co-ed school or can leave the house without a 14 yr olds supervision doesn't mean she has inferior morals. Infact having chosen to do right and practise high morals is better than having been forced to do so.

awwwwwwwww :hehe: :kiss: ASHTI meri jaan u r so cute :hehe: :kiss: can i adopt u as a younger bro? :smiley: :slight_smile:

You know I have a very hard time explaining to my mom why I have almost no muslim friends at all.... thanks Ashti !

You are the most screwed up, hateful chauvanistic, bigot I've met in ...umm since the last time I went to the local mosque!?

It's one thing to have such twisted views of everything but then to back it up with 'Islam'!?

It's so sad... esp when a lot of muslims I've come across are like this!?! How can any of you with half brain in your head believe his crap to be Islamically correct or even rationally fair or right in any way?

You seriously disgust me!

I've noticed the only 'aspects of Islam' idiots like you are so vocal and adamant about expressing and enforcing are hating absolutely everyone who does not live up to your own hypocritical standards and beating down women in every way possible!?

I love how something as simple and foolish as telling a girl to stay in her room when some guy is over is justified by the most extreme cases of ..'what could go wrong' if you don't!?

People like you would have been better off born a woman living under such harsh restrictions yourself in some place like Iran or Afghanistan... I wonder how just you would think such 'rules' for women were if you had to live by them yourself?

After going through all the posts in this thread… i am now more than ever grateful to Almighty Allah :swt: dat em born and grown up in a backward province of NWFP in a third world eastern country Pakistan, having so many (as per western views) conservative, extremest and fundamentalists around. Though things have become changed here over the years… but still i feel proud being backward,illiterate and ignorant of wats happening around in the west. I agree with most of the points and views expressed here by Aashti… but i admit that his way of conveying his thoughts was wrong… especially calling other families beghairat and bla bla. But em highly disappointed with the views of some female guppans here (though i dont know most of them… and em just assuming dat they are females coz of their nicks).
I have always been against moving to west as my parents and my relatives in the west tried their best to pull me up there… but now i feel more determined not to leave my country and janam bhoomi.

I am not here to argue with anybody… as i am not good in it as like Aashti… so please dont get panic if i have said anything wrong as per anybody’s views… thanks in advance.

My parents don't mind me associated with guys as long as there is a reason (like they are in my classes or something) or if they are kids of family friends and we are just talking, etc.

But Ami does tell me to stay upstairs if there are workers in the house or something.

NR: Please explain what you mean. Thanks.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by waqas72: *
You know I have a very hard time explaining to my mom why I have almost no muslim friends at all.... thanks Ashti !
[/QUOTE]

lollll..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ashti: *
Yaar I don’t like sugar coating my words, kisi ko karwey lagte hein to lagein, I just say things the way they are.
[/QUOTE]

Your still young, youll learn as you grow older that you cant always say what you think, you have to use some diplomacy.

Also in islam your meant to talk in a respectful manner without cursing people. How about folowing that part of islam too.

My stomach churns and I feel acute diarrhoea coming on. People are actually supporting ahsti's views of keeping women under house arrest coz as per our khandaani laRka here, women are weak and stupid and can't make it out there. They aren't headstrong enough to see through a guy whose intentions aren't anymore naek than aShti's when he enquired about the first night.

One mohtarma even wants to adopt Ashti as a younger brother, and from what I hear she has graduated from an elite uni in U.S which happens to be a co-ed!!!!!

I am truly S.H.O.C.K.E.D.

P.S: Ladies, am I the perfect catch or what! mail me at [email protected] or [email protected].

;-)

To Mr NR, I truly congratulate you. Your values are true to your culture and you are intelligent enough to know that if you want to adhere to the customs that go along with it, you should remain in NWFP, that it just wouldnt "fit" in the west. Nothing wrong with that and no reason to come down on you or insult you for that. I wonder about the women over there, I think it likely that most of them are unhappy being so sheltered but my PERSONAL view is that life is just lovely over there. Not many would agree and women today want more opportunity and less restriction. But that in no way makes them loose or "whores". Women ARE every bit as capable of earning a great living as men and they ARE capable of handling themselves with their values intact. That opportunity is not available to them over in NWFP I think but in America its almost expected. So for those who live here, extreme segregation is detrimental to the women. Over there, its the way of life and expected. So if you choose to raise a family in a culture that differs from your customs, you need to adapt a bit, like the posts where the girls are allowed to mix in regular activities but go to their rooms when workers are over. Keeping the women completely away from males while living in the west is wrong. Those women will not be able to function in the society that they're living in. If I had a daughter here, I would very much want her to be able to take care of herself and handle herself in the society that she lives in. Its an obligation of parenthood to teach your children that.

Shikra by ‘our girls’ I didn’t mean ‘our property’, its just coz they belong to our community, it’s just like a soccer team skipper saying ‘our lads’, what’s the big deal? It’s like saying ‘our community’, ‘our people’ etc.

I know what sort of Hijaabi girls you are talking about but again these sort of pseudo-religious girls are usually from open minded families, their parents might tell them to wear a Hijaab but they wont take the other necessary precautions. By you mentioning girls using the library and the female friends house excuse you’ve just backed up my point, I don’t think I need to argue this any further…

The situation I described about the girl and the 40yr old happens when girls are given ridiculous amount of freedom and/or maybe sometimes when restrictions are suddenly imposed upon the girl and they are too much for her and she feels frustrated, I agree it shouldn’t be forced parents should Islamically educate their kids and bring them up this way from the cradle, so that when they are older it doesn’t feel like oppression which it clearly isn’t, their mindset has to be made that way from a young age. In my village in Pakistan we have segregation and the women are happier than any woman I have come across in England or Pak cities, professional women here suffer from depression, stress, anorexia and other problems but in my village the housewives are happy and always laughing taking each day as it comes without any worries because the men take care of everything, everything runs smoothly, the men have a world of their own with their own social circles and the women their own, the opposite genders which they interact with are their direct relatives and their own spouses and that’s the way it should be, they are happy because they have been bought up this way and that’s what Muslim parents should do here.

Yaar I’m not fighting I’m just using the proper words to describe these people the only objectionable word I used was “pet dog”.

I am not from NWFP, my district was originally part of NWFP but the British gave it to Punjab.

21st century or 15th century, time will not have any effect on what I stand for.

a_bad_hair_cut people telling me to take it off??? Yeah right, more like they were saving it on their hard drives and printing out copies to go on their bedroom wall. After all I’m a chick magnet (sorry I can’t help it). Wheatish complexioned, muscular, tall guys like me are very rare to find amongst Desis, most of them look like dark lamas, with their “short back and sides blade naught” and long brown necks sticking out, all look the same, I too have a “short back and sides blade naught” but mines is cool coz I’m stocky like a military person.

irem lol yeah of course :hug:

Femme Fatale maybe no person has said it in this thread but I know how they think of us, the lies I here about how we oppress and our women are unhappy and our society is messed up but that all couldn’t be further from the truth, we have to put up with the posh Pakistanis in the media coming out with rubbish and lies about us so why does a few posts talking the truth about posh Pakis is hurting you so much?

you are making assumptions, I didn’t say girls from these sort of backgrounds always turn out like that there’s exceptions but they are in the minority. Self-righteous, I don’t know I just feel our way is right otherwise I wouldn’t have felt so strongly about it, now if I say that I’m right but so is someone who does the opposite of what I do that wouldn’t make any sense.

waqas72, ahh another coconut, you’re a school teacher aren’t you? You sound like two teachers I’ve had in the past, are you called Mr Sideeqi or Mr Daud by any chance? Maybe it’s just that all British Desi teachers are all the same, coconuts.

What sort of Islam do you follow anyway? I’ve seen with your likes an Aayat or Hadees will clearly state something but you’ll prefer some twisted beyond comprehension explanation for it and derive the most absurd meanings in order to be moderate.

Before you talk of Afghanistan, do you even know what it was like over there? I’ve had first hand experience and trust me mate it wasn’t no where near as bad you make it out to be, there was poverty but that was all thanks to the west, if you want to know women are treated in Afghanistan go read about that Christian missionary aid worker who has reverted to Islam after coming back from Afghanistan and what she had to say about how she was treated. Some people are just to blind to see beyond fake video footages and what Bush baaba says.

M, diplomacy? I don’t like compromising my views just to get people to agree with me because that is kind of pointless. I’m not saying what I think I’m saying what I know; the result and outcome of what I am against are all around us.

a_bad_hair_cut why re you jealous? Shows who the hunk is. Trust people like you to make something true/normal sound-like the worst insult ever with your language skills.

This topic is boring me now I’m going to go play football with my mates’ b4 it starts pissing it down again. :p

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Ashti: *

In fact just yesterday I saw a Hijaabi girl from this sort of background meet up with a 40yish year old man during lunch break in a neighbouring town at McDonalds, they met there and then drove of in his car and my buddy asked her afterwards who the guy was and she told us about how they met online and the explicit details of what they did, he asked her for a blowjob and she said “why don’t you ask your wife?” and he replied “if she gave me one why’d I be here with you?” and she ended up giving him one.

[/QUOTE]

I have heard that story before. Its often used whenever someone wants to support your school of thought. So either you are making it up, or your friend took advantage of your strong thoughts and just used this age old story to cement your thoughts.

Ashti -- I think what M meant by diplomacy is that you are probably too immature and inexperienced to know what you're talking about. At least don't go around spouting your offensive perspective. Have you no shame or sense of decency?

"Better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool
than to open it and remove all doubt."