^ Agrees with Chip-Kali
And i repeat to all the people who are telling D.A to call it off immidietly pls think more maturely.
In islam we are always adviced to try to save a relation/marriage if we can than destroy it.
We are thinking maturely. Whereas you are thinking in a love-struck emotional manner. Islam advises to save MARRIAGE**. We are advised to repair the marriage and divorce is used as a last resort. BUT, this girl is NOT MARRIED. She has not had Nikkah. It is only an engagement. Put the pathos to the side and use the logos. Use your logic. If the majority of the people are advising the girl to call it off............then why don't you think about why they are giving this advice............instead of becoming the minority. Also, why don't you look at some of DA's posts........she has said in a post that sometimes she hates him. She has no desire to communicate with him when he hurls profanities at her. She, herself, is beginning to realize that marrying such a guy is not practical.
**Im sure she has common sense & is bright, if she wanted to break-up she wud have done it by now.
Look, many times the things we want in our life are not good for us. If a person has a problem with drinking and has been driking alcohol for 5 years on a daily basis and is destroying his health and family...............EVERYONE will tell him to STAY AWAY FROM THE ALCOHOL. No intelligent person is going to say "If he has common sense and is bright, if he wanted to break-up with the alcohol, he wud have done it by now" (that is senseless reasoning).
One other idea...if his mum is sooo that rude...maybe u shud try calling and record her voice one-day...hehe..get a a proper conversation going......record it all..and show it to finance...
Maybe you good slyly ask things that you know 'tick-her' off.
And one other thing to be mind-ful of; maybe the MIL doesnt want u to marry her son, so is acting in a deliberate way to break off the engagement?
-She acts rudely infront of u in a way so u cant stand her
^then rings the fone to her son, and masoomly tells him that he shud tell u that MIL and DIL shud live together after marriage.
WHaT A Politiccal MIL!
**No matter HOW BAD a guy's mom is..................the guy is 27 years gold and has his own AQAL. Just because my mom doesnt' like someone doesn't mean that I am going to treat that person with disrespect and shower them with gaaliyan.
Even if his mom doesn't like her...................he did not have to use such bad language toward her. He did not have to call her the F-word. Even if your parents don't like someone.............YOU as an ADULT should have control over your own words and actions.
His email suggest that he has a controlling psychology and also that he has anger management issues. He has said that he doesn't forgive or forget mistakes. And that is a dangerous mentality to have in a husband. A woman's life becomes miserable if she lives with a man who has to remind and curse at her for every mistake she made.
Amir_Pindi.................this is a young and impressionable girl who is 20 years old. She hasn't even completed her education. She has the next few years ahead of her to find a good rishta. YOU are making one big mistake by urging this girl to try and fix this rishta which is not even a marriage. You are giving this young girl hope. And now she's going to fall 6 step backwards. Pehlay do kadam barhai thay seedi direction main..........ab woh chay kadam peechay gir paray gi.
A guy like this had demonstrated over and over again he's not normal. There is nothing to be fixed in this relationship. Regardless of how bad his mom is, he did not have to call her such dirty words. You can tell a man's character by the way he treats women.
My advice to you would be to consider editing your post and removing the part of "trying to make it work". She has BEEN Trying to fix this relationship since the first day that she opened this thread. She has even tried protecting his reputation from her parents. Now, he doesn't deserve any more chances. Don't encourage the girl to give this guy a second chance. Everybody knows that there are some things and situations in life that don't deserve another chance after many chances have already been given.**