Eid milad un nabi is biddat - Saudi mufti

[vroom]

Re: Eid milad un nabi is biddat - Saudi mufti

@Moonstar201

I believe even Ulema who dont follow Eid melad , will not have problem if some boundries are drawn about how to make Milad. In case if there is are seerat conferences and Naat competition ( not in the songs tune ) and Qiraat competition No one shud have any problem. But not to make resembles of KAABA and MASJID NAbVI and other rituals which has nothing do to with islam.

The rejecters of Mawlid have different deviances. They actually reject ALL forms of Mawlid. So your belief about them is incorrect.
Also there has been a big propaganda drive against Mawlid, in the tune of the above total rejection of Mawlid. They not only have a problem with it but their problem reaches deeper then that.
Mawlid Shareef are not the same as seerat conferences, but the ruling on them with regards to innovation[bidah] would be similar

Muharamaat [prohibited] acts during Mawlid Shareef gatherings are not allowed by any one. If an individual does prohibited acts its just his own wrong deed.
I am not aware of resembles of Kaaba and Masjid Nabvi being part of any particular Mawlid, heretical acts can be done with them but picture/model making of Kaaba or Masjid Nabvi is not outright prohibited, to the best of my Knowledge

To perfect Mawlid, and to make all Mawlid gatherings/celebrations a perfect example of following Shariah would be a praiseworthy effort, but what you will find is that acts of jahiliya by individuals are used as part of the argument to prohibit Mawlid completely! As we have seen on this thread, its been attempted.