Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Brother Shak ...

If the person is not religious then they will end up living for this world ... If the person wants to make the marriage work then they can make this world bearable by becoming religious and focusing on the Hereafter ... It is a simple recipe ...

Imagine if you are given the offer of two houses ... One is a huge mansion and it is told to you that you will get to live in for as long as you like, the other is a tiny house and you are told it might be there tomorrow it might not ... which one will you put the down payment for?

Mindset is very important ...

The woman who struggles and lives a hard life in the home - is seen from the worldly POV as a slave or animal ... But from the POV of the Hereafter she is seen as a mujahidah ... I'm not making this stuff up ...

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

This is just your experience, when my parents fought I wished they would split up because I couldn't bare to see their unhappiness- it cut like a knife. No child would prefer their parents to split up, but there are some instances where it can seem like the better solution. There was no abuse or anything, just a lot of personality and compatibility clashes which caused anger, misunderstanding, bitterness, resentment, etc. My parents stayed together, they made the decision that worked for them but for every fight they had, or when I knew they were unhappy, it's literally imprinted in my mind. So for those of you wondering about the effects of splitting up on a child, remember that in a negative environment, not splitting up can have a huge effect too. At 23 I had a nervous breakdown when I couldn't see them fighting. And like I said my parents marriage wasn't even that bad as in there was no cheating or lying or abuse etc, they did love each other.

As an adult I had a really hard time with all relationships, I carried a lot of dysfunction into my own marriage and it 's taken me years to realise and understand my behaviour.

Everyone has a different tolerance level; some women can tolerate abuse, many others have come in here complaining about their husbands completely cutting them off from the financial running of the household i.e. not telling them their salaries, giving an allowance, etc. How much one tolerates is an individual's choice, I don't judge anyone for what they put up with but then I don't expect to be judged because I wouldn't put up with such things.

What I want in my marriage is trust, respect and equality. At the end of the day the decision I have to make is whether I would rather be in a marriage without these or on my own. And I know for me, I would be happier on my own. But like I said this is an INDIVIDUAL'S choice, one they should be free to make without being villified for doing what they thought was best for them.

And NO i am not pro-divorce, I believe it should be avoided, but not at the cost of one's happiness. And happiness to me doesn't mean that you have to be skipping in lala land all day long, but that you get more good out of the relationship than bad, there should be a balance of highs and lows and one person carrying the majority of the burden of making sacrifices in the marriage just doesn't cut it for me, regardless of which spouse or gender is making those sacrifices.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

oh yessir you are. divorce is permissible. has nothing to do with hereafter and all that

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

What people write about and the reality of a situation - is very different ... This is not my place to vent ... others may be doing that - but not me. What is tantamount to evil however is how people believe they can become a wedge between two individuals who they hardly know.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

So now I am a liar? No life as a mujahid wife?
I will not even try to defend myself ... google it.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

I don't even know why I'm bothering - what does this have to do with the discussion going on here? Is anyone doing this or advocating doing this? No need to reply because you'll most likely bring in more random comments.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

The key to happiness is to let go ... have no expectation from others ... There was another thread on this forum ... The moment we hold others to an expectation they will fail and we will fail ...

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

That's okay ... One random comment deserved another ...

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

the challenge to put up with unfairness with the promise of ample repayment in here-after... this is like the nigerian scam of send me 50 dollars so i can mail you 50 million. where is your self-respect? there is no need to put up with injustice and abuse in this world when you have genuine recourse available at hand.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Except this one is not a scam … and it’s more than 50 Million :grumpy: … that is nothing compared to the Hereafter … Look if you are going to use an analogy please make it comparable …

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

well if that's what works for you then great, but if i can't live my life without having any expectations from my life partner, then there's nothing wrong with that either.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

The last para doesn't make much sense (to me). Of course in an IDEAL situation, divorce won't happen. But how does one come up with the aftereffects WITHOUT knowing reasons for divorce.

The after effects DEPEND ON why the couple got divorced in the first place. You can't simply address the after effects without taking reasons for divorce into consideration. (Only read OP - am sure others have mentioned this. But my 2 cents very important to me).

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Here is the reference to the Hadith , which echo's what Psyah has just said :

Jabir reported that Allah's Messenger (صلى الله عليه و سلم) said: Iblis places his throne upon water; he then sends detachments (for creating dissension); the nearer to him in tank are those who are most notorious in creating dissension. One of them comes and says: I did so and so. And he says: You have done nothing. Then one amongst them comes and says: I did not spare so and so until I sowed the seed of discord between a husband and a wife. The Satan goes near him and says: 'You have done well. A'mash said: He then embraces him. Sahih Muslim: Hadith Number 2813]

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Didn't Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) himself even suggest divorce in certain situations??

I can post the references for that as well if needed..

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Single mothers with sons... its harder for them to keep their sons on the right path, when their 12-18. Its not everyone, but alot of mom's have difficulty with sons, it helps when there is a male figure like a uncle or cousin to help them out.

Also kids can be cruel, I had a new a little girl who's dad wasnt around. Her cousins used to like thow it in her face, "our dad takes us to the park, our dad this/that". At 3 or 5 its hard, that girl used to wonder about her dad, and would try to get close to other male figures, i remember she came to my house, I called my dad for something and she was like DAD! and ran towards him. But it was more because her cousins like mentally abused her about her not having a dad.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Divorce is not Haraam, but it is one of the most hated things that God has made permissible. Its not allowed for catholics.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Also,** a woman came to the Prophet Muhammad seeking the dissolution of her marriage, she told the Prophet that she did not have any complaints against her husband’s character or manners. Her only problem was that she honestly did not like him to the extent of not being able to live with him any longer. The Prophet asked her: “Would you give him his garden (the marriage gift he had given her) back?” she said: “Yes”. The Prophet then instructed the man to take back his garden and accept the dissolution of the marriage (Bukhari)**.

Source: IslamiCity - The Global Muslim eCommunity

Our culture attaches more issues and stigma to divorce than Islam does.. The ‘discord’ between husband and wife mentioned by CB sounds to me more like marital problems in general caused by Iblees, rather than just divorce..

If you read up on the early days of Islam divorce was actually quite common amongst the sahaba and it wasn’t seen as a massively negative thing..

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

That hadith is not about divorce entirely...its got more to it and I don't know why people use it to condemn divorce.

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

You know what's funny?

I distinctly remember wondering if I could everrrrr go through with a divorce at one point in my life...it was terrible. I had zero courage to take a step like that against society, eyebrows that would raise against me, people that would give me tanay and questions about husband. The amount of unsolicited advice I got from people who were not even remotely able to understand me...it was crazy.

But what was better? Living like that or living the way I want to live? Who says I have to spend my life according to rules made by others? And if I had kids...I'd think the same way.

I think women tend to underestimate themselves and their kids. I've learned so much from all of this and one thing I always remember is...I own the outcome of everything I do. That is a fact of life that is harder to understand because its easier to lay blame on society, others, the ex husband, the school the kids are in, public schooling versus homeschooling, etc etc etc. We love playing the blame game. I blamed others for a lot of what happened with me in the past but in reality I was responsible for all of it. I let it happen. Then I realized I had the power to change it so I did.

There is no cookie cutter answer here...the effects of a broken relationship on kids will be exactly what we work towards and want them to be. The question is though at the end...are you strong enough to put what other people think to the side and work on your priorities?

Re: Effects of a broken relationship on children.

Sometimes the end of a miserable marriage is good for the kids.