The veracity of the Quran cannot be questioned - those of Sahih Bukhari - Muslim - in my opinion can be - because Allah did not take the responsibility of ensuring their veracity for all time.
Since this is TRUE I think it is incorrect to base laws and punishments on the hadees. Especially taking the life of another person. The Quran is all that is needed. The Quran is a very lengthy book which has rules for humanity on many facets of life. The Quran does mention apostasy but DOES NOT mention a punishment. Hence it is my view that apostasy is NOT punishable in this life. “There is no compulsion in religion.”
I’m sure you’re right. However all that happened 1400 years ago. And from that time till now the only thing we have which is 100% true is the Quran. Everything else is possibly tainted, so what you might believe that the Prophet did according to hadees might not have actually happened.
How? Bukhari was a human being - Allah was not talking to him, while collecting hadees he collected many thousands and then threw away ones which he thought were not authentic - are you telling me that Bukhari could not have made a single mistake?
bro u shud know quran is also wat prophet told n sahaba memorized n wrote…u dint hear it from Allah directly.. if u doubt hadith u shud doubt quran
n wen u dont u shud not doubt hadiths
u know once i gues its about imam bukhari, travelled long way to narator of a hadith n he saw that man mistreating his donkey ..so imam did not accepted his hadith,saying that one whu mistreats his aminal is not trust worthy!
if it is about giving soft image of islam..u shud understand islam is strict wen it comes to punishments because
-these punishments r very imp to maintain dicipline n control shr..
-punishments r strict because in islamic state,Allah’s system facilitates us to refrain from sins and encourages good deeds,and the society is nurturing, pure and balanced
so in such a blessed environment wen u comit sin u deserve punishmnt
and as i said islamic punishments r implemented ONLY wen there is islamic state and islam can not be partially implemented
1 ummah - Allah has taken the responsibility of preserving the Quran - not the hadees - hence the hadees can be at best be true - potentially biased - and at worst completely false. We have no way of knowing for certain.
I have no problems with people reading the hadees as well as following them. I have a problem when we prescribe punishments according to the hadees which have no mention in the Quran, especially when we are talking about an extreme decision of ending another persons life.
Yes we would not know the way to offer salat if it was not for the hadees. However performing the salat improperly does not harm another person. Requiring that apostates should be killed based on Haddees when the punishment is not mentioned in the Quran is incorrect.
well u cannot say its incorrect but there is diference of opinion…so in that case it depends on head of islamic state,which opinion he applies and it can be changed with change of ruler
