I know this is going to be a very controversial thing and may not be appropriate for some audience but this is a very geniune case.A very close relative of mine just told me that some very practising muslim lady told her that we should not wear a bra as it enchances your body shape .We should be wearing a thick and loose clothing that wraps around your sattar and we should wear a big chaddar to cover your chest.
I am posting this thread in all views as it is an appropriate section to disscuss things.
So if we are wearing a chaadar anyway, why does it matter if we wear it. I just think it's common sense to wear it. Some people are too detailed for their own good!
So if we are wearing a chaadar anyway, why does it matter if we wear it. I just think it's common sense to wear it. Some people are too detailed for their own good!
But we don't need to go in detail about this issue just cover yourself and thats it. Why there is need of asking a question or delivering a fatwaa like not wearing a bra enhance your bodyshape.
I am sorry it was not my intention but I was looking for some discussion
oh no I did not mean it in that sense. I have seen other forums who have sections especially for women. It was just a suggestion for the forum admin/mod
Out of curiosity who delivered this opinion or fatwa?
oh no I did not mean it in that sense. I have seen other forums who have sections especially for women. It was just a suggestion for the forum admin/mod
Out of curiosity who delivered this opinion or fatwa?
Someone from tablighi jamaat and I know they are pious people but there are somethings that doesn't make sense.
Someone from tablighi jamaat and I know they are pious people but there are somethings that doesn't make sense.
Well it really depends on the context they said that in. I would ask for some references and not take it as a fatwa which is from a scholar and not something that every person can give no matter how pious or practising they are :)
^ yeah supermom, give TLK some more graphic details. A JPEG with push-up bra and one without will help him/her decide if this thread belongs in ALL or Life69.
Are you serious? Was this lady an A-cup? Cause in all seriousness B/C upwards and everyone needs it just for the support and to stop themselves looking behooda, regradless of the number of chadars you use.
I think thats all the discussion this thread needs.
I dont think the tabilgi jamaat ppl meant it in that sense. They probably mean ladies who wear bra's to make their breasts look big(push-up bras). But if they said it as an overall thing, then thats like ssaying a men shouldnt wear an underwear? so yea, its really up in the head. But ladies, do wear a bra no matter what. lol its not halal to see your ornaments wingling around either. :/
LOL - then that person might want to join the "burn the bra club"
Tell her - you just don't want membership in that club!
so funny.... the next thing someone will comeup with is - do we really need undies? The argument point being - we will ALL die one day and nothing will be left on us anyways!
GET A LIFE PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bras and undies are definitely a must!
Who can ever find out if you are wearing a push up bra or any other bra - unless you are FLAUTING your bra everywhere!
I have never seen anyone do that - at least no one from Muslim community. Shameful for the person to even suggest this.
