Re: Challenge for Hadeeth Rejectors
PCG, aisha (ra) is reported to scold abu huraira (ra) in just one hadith....
do u dump the thousands of ahadith by abu huraira (ra) to keep one by aisha (ra) or otherwise????
take this scenario....
a person, like many on this board, who finds ahadith coming in the way of his worldly pleasures, wants to induce doubt in the minds of the ppl so they start rejecting ahadith...
so the best way wud be to denounce the chief narrator of the ahadith i.e. abu huraira (ra)....
but to denounce him, he needs someone more important, so he thinks of aisha (ra), so he makes up a controversial hadith about huraira (ra) through aisha (ra)....
and many fools take his word and call abu huraira (ra) a liar....
why do u think the sahaba did not take any action against abu huraira (ra) if he (as u think ) was spreading lies and fabricated ahadith....
those ppl were very strict on these matters....
(whether u believe it or not) when the sahaba used to tell a hadith, they used to start sweating and shivering because of the fear of reporting something in words that the Prophet (saw) did not use (i.e. use similar meaning words) and hence face the punishment of fabricating the words of the Prophet (saw), which he warned against and told of severe punishment for anyone who does this....
hence u will find many ahadith saying the Prophet (saw) said something which meant like this, or saying "maybe he used this word or maybe this"....
they did not want to report anything even slightly wrong....
and u think that one of them was busy telling false ahadith....
or that they'd let one among them attribute false to the prophet (saw) and not take any action to stop such a thing....
do u really not even think of what u r talking about????
and just follow the foolish hadith rejectors without using ur own brain....