What GIDSA said. You may not believe in the concept of imamate which is your prerogative, but to turn around and say that Imam Ali, Imam Hasan and Imam Hussain A.S. and the other 9 imams were not related to the Prophet (saw), well I'd question what you've read.
in religion class this is great.......but this thread has a topic.......and i personally think tht is doesnt connect to tht.......
ppl call themselves educated but stil dont know about 12imams n dont believe them thats totally weird
sorry i said that bcuz m seriously sad after readinggg
What GIDSA said. You may not believe in the concept of imamate which is your prerogative, but to turn around and say that Imam Ali, Imam Hasan and Imam Hussain A.S. and the other 9 imams were not related to the Prophet (saw), well I'd question what you've read.
I can understand the link between the grandsons and the prophet, but there is just too much murky waters when you have twelvers splitting with ismaelis and both sides claim they have the true imams. People need to look past these imams (disappeared anyway unless ahmedinejad meant something last year ?) and focus on their deeds. The only thing that I found problematic is that many shiites I know have cursed people when they criticized them on something to the tune of curse on you for cursing ahle bayt (meaning them). SORRY but that is pushing it.
bro itz not a threat......i could really do tht.....hahaha......and im feeling offended.....and this topic isnt the same topic anymore......so thtz y.....
ppl call themselves educated but stil dont know about 12imams n dont believe them thats totally weird
sorry i said that bcuz m seriously sad after readinggg
Because you are forcing it on other people like all of muslims are shiites when you guys are small minority of all muslims. Anyway I am out to not make it some real big sect war.
ppl call themselves educated but stil dont know about 12imams n dont believe them thats totally weird
sorry i said that bcuz m seriously sad after readinggg
The discussion was about how Syeds are supposed to be superior (which we have established they are not). Why are you trying to bring 12 imams into this?