Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

Hangout GupShup Cafe
1

Hello folks,

This is part of a project I am going to be involved in soon so be honest and expressive at the same time.

Suppose, you were to travel back in time and meet our national poet Allama Iqbal (reason for picking him up is because of April 21st around the corner).

If you had a job to do and were supposed to take the interview of Allama Iqbal, what questions would you ask that may generate productive answers - questions that may raise the issues which our nation is confused or miss-informed about; questions that are controversial to history or to the role of Iqbal specially in the movement of Pakistan.

Open up and throw as many questions you want… I need the questions for now - my research will be on his own works to answer the questions later…

-AQ

.

2

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

Q: salam; How you will compare the life and life after death? Did you see any difference in your thoughts and the reality after death?

3

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

ummm good question ATA.. but answer to such question would not be found in his works.... so when asking questions, just keep that in mind...

and wait for my PM too :)

4

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

yeah I figured, ok, jaldi...

5

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

Did you really base your shaheen or banda a momin on **Nietzsche's **superhuman ?

Was Your two nation theory for creation of more than one Muslim states or Just one Pakistan ?

why did you choose Shaheen to represent a super human , why not a lion or tiger ?

6

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

Awesome questions Mirch :)

7

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

whats the actual definition of ' falsa'fa'ay KHUDEE' ?

8

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

how do you think faiz tramslated some of your concerns from Jawab e shikwa in his poem yeh galion kay awara baykaar kuttay.

9

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

iman

10

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

is it true Iqbal uses too many analogies to explain his point?

11

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!


umm zobia actually there is an ayah of Quran that Iqbal himself says is the source of his falsafa-e-khudi where Allah talks about those who forget Allah and Allah makes them forget themselves....

12

Re: Ask a question - ? – Aap bhee poochiye …!

i guess i cant think now :clown:

ps. can anyone post the poem?

13

Re: Ask a question - ? – Aap bhee poochiye …!

that means I interpreted it right…:hooray:

have you ever
14

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

Muslime state

sure

lion cant fly, and to feel the height you must know how to fly.
tiger is considered stupid animal.

15

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

why you said this?

Jiss khait say dehkhan ko muyassar na ho roti
Uss khait kay har khosha-e-gandumm ko jala do

why you didn't say to work real hard to make that land able to grow gandum?

16

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

i didnt say it.
next question....

17

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

while he did use in his sher animals for bravery other than Shaheen for example :)

MillaY gaaaa Manzil-e-Maqsooood kaaa ussi ko suraaaaagh
Andheri sha'b maiN hai cheetaY kee aaNkh jiskaa charaagh

18

Re: Ask a question - ? – Aap bhee poochiye …!

because it is a revolutionary appeal … dehqaan is already growing gandum but if he is not getting ROTI, then, there is no need of such a khait :snooty:

UTho meri duniya kaY ghareeboN ko jagaadau
kaakh-e-Um’ara kaY dar-o-deewaar hilaaadau :slight_smile:

19

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

cheetay ki ankh kaha hai...cheeta nahi kaha :p

Dedicate a song OR share a song with special meaning to you
20

Re: Ask a question - ? -- Aap bhee poochiye ...!

now that will require me to go really find parrallels in the two :)