yvonne Ridley's views on suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

My God, what a terrorist apologist.

To those people trying to paint this as an attempt to provide journalistic balance, have you guys spent even a moderate amount of time reading American right wing sites, sites like say nationalreview or cato etc. You realise, most propaganda, isnt Yippiee, lets have more Iraqies standing naked on a bucket while we pose next to them or Yay we killed 20 rag-heads today! it mostly goes along the lines "while all loss of life is completely reprehensible.. but".. or "while nobody enjoyed seeing pictures from Abu Ghraib, we should keep in perspective...".

Lets see, in this article Yvonne bibi compared those who distanced themselves from Zarqawi to willing slaves (implication, a certain someone was an unwilling slave, a rather heroic image to have).

Yvonne further went to on to say while she didnt like lots of dead people on her TV (God only knows what her feelings might be if her TV had been off at the time) but those people were in a wedding at a hotel where alcohol can be served. Alcohol bad. Bad alcohol. Bombs bad too.. but u know... BAD alcohol. People, in a wedding, at a hotel that serves ALCOHOL. bomb yes. but u know.. alcohol. its a reaction, ofcourse! maybe they overdid it. shooting spree, MAYBE. bomb is over the top. but still, keep in mind, place does serve alcohol.

atleast one place I see "terrorist". not that im saying thats wrong. while she condemns terrorism, and feels bad when she sees 61 dead people on tv, humanitarian that she is, she feels compelled to add quotes around terrorist, possibly again to show that its only a reaction.

Yvonne bibi would rather have a "brother" like Zarqavi instead of a traitor or slave dad like X, Y, Z. Why no colourful characterization of said brother? While ofcourse she condemns the loss of lives. no doubt. she feels terrible about it. who wouldnt?

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

^ I think she is showing both faces of the coin. Perhaps she is neither siding with "terrorism" nor with the "established" norms of the current "muslim" states. That is how I feel personally as well so maybe I am reading into it incorrectly, but again, I could be right.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

hey anyone could be right, and there is the distinctly unlikely possibility that those quotations around terrorist could just be a word decoration tradition where she hails from.

it is interesting for me how frequently, for ideologues on both sides of the WOT business, the only tyrants are in places where their guys are fighting or want to fight. Where are Yvonne bibi's scholarly insights on the wrongs of Muslim rulers in Turkemenistan or Sudan or Timbuktu? The exclusive presence of this commentary on the "esablishment" merely in places where the "reaction" is happening (see how Im using quotes here? no, where I come from quotes are not used around nouns for decoration reasons) might show shes only interested in it for the sake of the "reaction". Especially when you go through the list of the "reaction"s crimes, and say "but they serve alcohol there". Who the **** is she to rationalize a bombing of a wedding as an Alcohol Prevention Programme? Even if we accept the plausible premise that everyone who steps inside a place where you can get alcohol does drink alcohol, was she a teetotaller before she reverted, and if not, does she feel she should have been bombed a little bit at the time by brother Zarqavi?

If you want to condemn the Establishment, please go ahead, condemn it. But dont at the same time contrast it with the "terrorist" who's terrorism you dont like on TV. it might give some of us an inkling of your motives.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Hey I hope you are not pointing to me in your last sentence lol... however, your point about her right (lack thereof) to rationalize the bombing is definitely noted.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

[edited]

Tameez se baat karain, please !

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Salam,

:k: yes you are right.

I dont get why we have to be so hush hush , when it comes to defending the truth. If this article was only about condeming terrorist bombings, instead of getting into the mindset and extracting out their rationale, perhaps it would have been more appealing.

But when an a journalist expresses her view by utilizing the facts at hand, its starts an uproar, because now the story is harder to chew than before.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

such a simplistic worldview Crescent_.

nobody is saying be hush hush. or dont defend the truth. if she was merely wrong, i wouldnt get pissed off. the criticism on her is on her credibility, because she writes emotive, disingenuous propaganda, not the "truth" you guys tout it as. As Muslims, isnt intellectual honesty part of the whole being upright and truthful thing?

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Salam,

Whats to say that you have not given it just thought?
Her credibility has been a critical aspect in her article, due to her insight knowledge on the subject. She might not know everything, but I believe she has the intellectual authority, the insight, the inquisitive mind.

What else would she be doing to go into afghanistan, to defame the Talibinistc movement ? only to inquire and seek truth, and she found it, Allah guided her, and she is here with us today.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Walekum assalam

We're talking about different things if I criticize her for what she says, and you implicitly believe her because of who she is.

You say she found the truth, and Allah guided her to Taliban. Why? Because of your worldview. We live in a big world though, and many journalists have converted to many ideologies, many abhorrent to you. Let us not take a caucasian journalist of no particular repute's conversion to a particular form of Islam as patent proof that her worldview, or her writing is divinely guided.

You have no means of ascertaining who guided her, you cannot speak for Allah.

Now, I have no personal grudges against anyone. Seeing her writing however, I find the structure you will find in articles defending or rationalizing american atrocities, the same selective presentation of reality and presentation of mitigating circumstances.

Please be under no illusion though that this causes a huge ruckus or she spoke the truth and the whole world came running after her. she, unfortunately has had more or less the same success in her journalism endeavours after her reversion as she had before. and that was never much. and im glad about that, i would prefer prominent Muslim voices to be honest, towards everyone, especially ourselves.

i spent many, many hours on this site and others railing against american right wing propaganda. how can we honestly then accept similar fare coming from ourselves? it is instinctive when under attack to cling to the first voice that supports you. not particularly worthy though.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

We are fools...We can only see what is placed before our eyes and we forget what happened in the past and what is happening behind what has been placed before our eyes...And when someone shows us what is happening behind what has been placed before us, we call them fools...Because what we see and hear is the truth...Whatever happened, happened...

When Hitler was waging war on innocent men, women and children and destroying others, the Germans all supported him...Because all they saw was propaganda placed before their eyes...And they shouted with Nazis, marched with Nazis and killed with Nazis...Because they couldn't see what was happening behind what was placed before their eyes...Then someone must have come and said to the Nazis, 'Look, you are doing wrong...Wel will oppose you', but the propaganda was strong, and all the Germans said, 'no, we are right...We are bringing peace to the world, and education and enlightenment with our bombs and our genocide...This is the only way to achieve peace...Don't you follow the news? Don't you read the papers? Our war is against the oppression in the world...Our war is against the other systems in the world which oppress people...So we fight other people...'

And so, the Germans marched on and killed many millions of people believing that what they were doing was right...They puffed their chests and supported the Nazis and waved banners and flags and flowers for the soldiers who marched on and killed more millions...

The Germans then started to hate and oppose those who stood in the way of their 'good fight'...They hanged those who opposed their views, tortured those who saw the reality behind the viciousness and looked down and spit upon those who differed with their views...

But technology was limited in those days...In those days the propaganda could only be fed to those that the Nazis could reach, namely the German people...If they could reach the world, they too would find people who would believe in their cause...

But today, the media is everywhere...In newspapers, on TV, on radio e.t.c., and people once again fall victim to propaganda...As every Iraqi dies, we say, 'it's for democracy', as every child gets blown up, we say, 'it's collateral damage', as every bomb goes off, we automatically shout, 'I must be the Jihadis', as every Sunni dies, we say 'It must be the Shias' and vice versa...Propaganda has taught us what to think every situation without looking into the past...

And we come to hate people like Yvonne Ridley who sees what's behind what has been placed before us, and like the Germans before us, we hate her for opposing views that have been taught to us...

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

let me ask you this Lajawab (im still not used to the hyperactive moniker, doesnt suit you). how do you know you're not the who has been propagandized into believing what he believes?

it is such a presumptuous position to take, to suggest that us lesser mortals see propaganda and buy it, except for the chosen few such as Ridley, yourself and Crescent_. sorry to break it to you, but a lot more than just those sharing your views struggle with religion, and the myriad crises of today, many others may honestly question propaganda, and still come up opposed to dishonest propagandists like Yvonne Ridley. While you make feel a sense of calm and ease believing its all propaganda... its all propaganda.. you're only indulging in semi-conscious denial.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Hyperactive is Lajjo. Great to know who I'm dealing with, then.

I don't get this! WHY is there such a "pity me pity me, I am the victim" mentality???

Face it, we muslims are NOT doing enough. 1/5 of this world is muslim - do you know that? Don't tell me its so easy to victimize muslims. Its not. If every muslim peed at once, we'd drown the world.

Muslims are up against people who are educated, well-mannered, well-spoken, people who can justify their arguments and get away with human rights atrocities because of that.

How hard is it for muslims to do the same?

Oh HOLD ON! I totally forgot! Haha! We keep our populations undereducated. We deny them basic human rights: food, clothing, shelter. Its IRONIC to me when I go with my family to visit the dargha in karachi that right outside the dargha there are little naked, yes, naked babies walking in muddy dirt that's infested with YOUR fecal matter. Yes, the poop you throw into the sewage when you visit Pakistan and which the city government hasn't been able to keep away from the roads and the drinking water. These naked babies look up at the dargha and affluent to middle class people visiting the dargha are content to say their prayers, get back in their cars, and go straight bag home, not giving the naked babe a second glance.

THIS is your muslim population. Start taking responsibility.

Do you know, that in our area where we live there are a reported 50,000 Pakistanis (reported in the newspaper, although I think the number is higher if you count illegals and unreported). This doesn't include muslims of all ethnicities. 50,000 Pakistanis and do you know when we did our scholarship dinner for students with high academic achievements - do you know how many people there were? 10 families. 50,000 people, and 10 families were able to produce offspring that actually did good things in high school. There are less than 5 muslim charity/outreach organizations and this is a BIG CITY where I live. You want to talk about how its more important to pay attention to the deen than the material world? FINE. Do you know how many people come to my mosque to pray when its NOT a Friday? Just take a wild guess. Do you know how many people I know of in this area who are studying Islam professionally at the graduate level? 1. And she had to go to another city to study it; there are no reputed programs in the area, as there is very sparse faculty that is muslim and can explain Islam to students. Not one student in the area currently is studying Islam as a major for undergraduate education. We have to call in random people who have never been Imams to be Imams in our mosque - there's just not many qualified people out there to do the job. Our current Imam is a engineer by profession, and hasn't taken more than basic Islam courses in grade school from a country abroad.

So, cry all you want about how victimized muslims are. Muslims have been digging holes for centuries now and burying themselves in it.

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Salam,

Honestly woman, read your history, some claims you make are coming out from god knows where.

G'day!

Salam,

Good post. What I dont get is, that people are willingly jumping on the bandwagon of the opressors, and their propaganda. Yet give no heed to the objectivity of a reporter, who has taken the sides to present the views and it's circumstances.

Is this what Surah Baqarah goes in detail of? The part about the munafiqoon, lost in the confusion of their allegiance.

Ready to give up their lives to justify the thirsty agendas of the world's largest terrorist criminal inhumane organizations (US, Israel, Britain). ?

What justice is this.

And when reporters who bring up valid points, are brought down, because people need to express the subjectivity.

The issue here is not that she is a convert, for she was speaking the same BEFORE accepting Islam. And neither does she have the world against her, quite the opposite infact. She had been a respected journalist in Britain, look up her on google.

yvonne promotes suicide bombing because she is going indepth to explain the condition of the oppressed world?
WHAT would hte prophet pbuh say? Was he wrong too, by taking this framework in to account?

Its not about muslims being victims, its about muslims taking the biggest HITS in the world, DUE to the propaganda, the agendas, the doctrines of those in power, mostly in the western world.

If you cannot recognize that, and want to justify them, go ahead.
You can pray for their victory, pray for the opressors.

And Allah will have the final decision for all.

Wsalam, Take care.

Re: yvonne Ridley's views on suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Quite a lame piece of writing and frankly in-effective propoganda.

I believe, Our own Lajawab can write better and far more convincing propoganda than this.

Re: yvonne Ridley's views on suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Peace All

A special acknowledgment to ravage ... yes it clear that her article is spun to sympathise with the 'other point of view' it is no reason to accuse of her of being a terrorist sympathiser. And all of us sitting here do not have the experience or first hand knowledge that she has.

Yvonne Ridley is a lover of Islam and wishes for it to prevail and us Muslims should support one another in our good acts and intentions and she has this.

There is one thing that no one can refute in her message ...

FEAR NO ONE EXCEPT ALLAH (SWT)

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

And peace be unto you sister!

Re: yvonne Ridley's views on suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Peace Bro. Code_Red

Religion forum moderator ... I get it you are here to make religion moderate - ed !!!

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

Do you know its an obligation on a muslim to answer salaam?

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

she should meet many members of my family who were oppressed by the taliban. i don’t see her expressing horror over what my people went through under the rule of those filthy dogs.

but she wont because she probably views us as traitors, as many muslims do from my experience :rolleyes:

Re: yvonne Ridley praises suicide bombings and al-Qaeda

what is this nonsense you are saying? cant you ever make sense without sounding like a fool? seriously i had a headache reading from this miserable rant of yours.