Ya Ali Madad or A Shirk - Ask Allah (SWT) directly or it equates to shirk (merged)

[my21098]

Re: Ya Ali Madad or A Shirk

@Y2K_Zaid

Yes, Muhammad e Mustafa :saw: is not dead if for a minute we suppose that he is not alive then I don’t find a good reason to calling his name in Azan & Aqamat. In Azan & Aqamat every single Muslim of this world call Prophet :saw: name.

Ash-hadu anna Muhammadur rasūlullāh :saw:

Bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of God.

If he is not alive then why Muslim bear witness that Muhammad :saw: IS the Messenger of God
NOT
Muhammad WAS the Messenger of God.

If anyone of you think that he is not alive then first change the Azan and bear witness that he was the Messenger of Allah otherwise accept it HE (:saw:) is alive

If I say that Muhammad Ali Jinnah is the founder of Pakistan, does that mean he is alive?