Ya Ali Madad or A Shirk - Ask Allah (SWT) directly or it equates to shirk (merged)

[Ayeshaaaa]

@muslima84

salaam,

i agree with AMY. Allah (swt) says in the Quran that “call on me” and i will answer your prayer…he does NOT say CALL ON MY FRIEND AND I WILL ANSWER YOUR PRAYER!!

i dont understand why these people cant go and ask Allah (swt) directly. i always ask Allah (swt) for whatever i need, and alhamdulillah he gives it.

all you have to do is ask sincerely. if you do that, then you dont need any intercession of any sort.

there is a hadith which says (im sorry i cant remember the exact words but its something like this:
that that which is lawful is white and CLEAR; and that which is unlawful is black and CLEAR. but in between these two, there is a DOUBTFUL grey area, which should be avoided.

so…dont you think that asking for something through a dead person should be avoided? because you may be committing shirk.
if you can ask Allah (swt) directly, then i dont see why ANYONE feels the need to go to a dead person.

PS. i ask Allah to 4give me if i said anything wrong

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/smile.gif

[This message has been edited by muslima84 (edited June 10, 2001).]

lol who is more closer to Allah(swt) us humans who sin all the time or the prophet that he purified? if you or me being sinners asked Allah (swt) to help us indeed he would but if we asked Allah (swt) through his loved ones and through the ones that do not sin like us then surely allah would listen…
either way we are asking Allah, just the method is different . we do not ask the prophets for anything but through them we ask Allah…IT IS NOT SHIRK…get your facts rite
wa’salaam