Would you donate an organ?

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@shaasavera

Hota hoga lekin uss person ne permission diya hoga organ dene ke liye to a stranger. So they would have known what that involves. Think of all the duas that person and their family will get.

I am interested to also know if people would accept Indian organ. It’s ok either way. Sab ka opinion alag ho sakta hai

it’s not about permission…in Canada, you can NOT name a recipient of your organ, it’s need and urgency based.

i was talking about is it fair to be willing to receive an organ donation from a stranger and not be willing to donate your own organ to a stranger?

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

Nopes, not fair. But I still wouldn’t change my stance on it.

ok then why would you expect a stranger to give you a gift of life? what if he/she is like you?

[Shamraz_Khan]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Yes. I have singed up to donate my organs in case of my death.

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

human organs, human blood and anything underneath the skin has NO religion, no race, no other color than it’s own universal color…under the skin everyone is the same…no one has a bigger heart!

That is true but for some people they make association between person and organ. some people like Jehovah’s witnesses they are not even allowed to accept blood transfusion. Organ has no race, nationality and religion but still maybe some people may not want to get organ from certain people. That’s their choice as well. Maybe in the beginning they don’t want to get it from that person but then later they change their mind when situation is life/death

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

I would take the heart/blood/kidney etc which is readily available regardless of the race or religion of the person donating.

Matlab yes agar Indian ho aap ko farak nahi padega would you think you have new bond with this person whose blood/kidney you’ve taken or would you not want to know person if of course person is alive?

[LP]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

ok then why would you expect a stranger to give you a gift of life? what if he/she is like you?

I wouldn’t expect a stranger to donate an organ. If they do, my luck. If not, again, my luck

[LP]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@Shamraz_Khan

Yes. I have singed up to donate my organs in case of my death.

:k:
I wish I had the heart to do that.

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

I wouldn’t expect a stranger to donate an organ. If they do, my luck. If not, again, my luck

no, not really…it doesn’t work that way…in most western countries, you can NOT pick the recipient. once you sign on the dotted line, you basically give your right away…your organ can go to anyone in need.

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

it’s not about permission…in Canada, you can NOT name a recipient of your organ, it’s need and urgency based.

i was talking about is it fair to be willing to receive an organ donation from a stranger and not be willing to donate your own organ to a stranger?

Ok but if you are willing to donate you must know that you cannot decide who it will go to so obviously it can go to someone who is not willing to donate to stranger.
If person is alive and they are donating kidney or something then they can make that choice.
It might not be fair but when someone gives gift of donating organ or blood they don’t always think that person should also donate to me or someone else. People do it from the goodness of their heart.

Maybe that person like the guy in this article wants to break barriers, boundaries and change views. Maybe they would want to donate to someone who doesn’t have to donate back to them. I mean maybe like the guy in the article perhaps an Indian may want to consciously donate to a Pakistani because by that one action they can change lot of views.

Maybe also vice versa. It’s literally impossible to hate someone who has given you or your family gift of life or given part of themselves to help you. Especially if they are not relative, or of same race, nationality or religion. Just like the somali family in the story.

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@shaasavera

That is true but for some people they make association between person and organ. some people like Jehovah’s witnesses they are not even allowed to accept blood transfusion. Organ has no race, nationality and religion but still maybe some people may not want to get organ from certain people. That’s their choice as well. Maybe in the beginning they don’t want to get it from that person but then later they change their mind when situation is life/death

the followers of Jehovah’s witness are against blood transfusion…period! it’s not about who the donor is…i’m sure if the transfusion was allowed in their religion, they wouldn’t discriminate against race, skin color, nationality etc.

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@Shaamsavera

organ donation kicks in only after death.

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

the followers of Jehovah’s witness are against blood transfusion…period! it’s not about who the donor is…i’m sure if the transfusion was allowed in their religion, they wouldn’t discriminate against race, skin color, nationality etc.

True about tht..some might even change their mind if maut is at the door.

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

@**Shaam**savera

organ donation kicks in only after death.

Unless you donate your kidney uske liye u dont have to be dead if someone wanted to they could consciously donate their kidney to someone. Do you think if someone donates an organ to another and both are alive they have this lifelong bond?

[LP]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

no, not really…it doesn’t work that way…in most western countries, you can NOT pick the recipient. once you sign on the dotted line, you basically give your right away…your organ can go to anyone in need.

Not everyone lives in the west.
I don’t know about other organs , but while donating kidney you can pick the recipient here

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@shaasavera

True about tht..some might even change their mind if maut is at the door.

some do and some don’t…there was a case in the US where a child died because the parents refused blood transfusion…the parents were charged with murder but later acquitted on the grounds of religious beliefs.

[KKF]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

Not everyone lives in the west.
I don’t know about other organs , but while donating kidney you can pick the recipient here

while you are living, you can choose your recipient but after death you can’t.

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

Not everyone lives in the west.
I don’t know about other organs , but while donating kidney you can pick the recipient here

Aap kahan rehti hain? only if you want to tell

[shaasavera]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@KKF

some do and some don’t…there was a case in the US where a child died because the parents refused blood transfusion…the parents were charged with murder but later acquitted on the grounds of religious beliefs.

That is wrong on multiple levels. I thought parents can’t choose harmful outcome for children. They should get charged for this.

[Shamraz_Khan]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

@LP

:k:
I wish I had the heart to do that.

I’m claustrophobic & have fear of being buried alive. So I wanna to make sure I’m really dead when they put me 6ft under.

[Deeba1234]

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Yeah, I’d donate an organ if asked.. I have one of those donor cards already mentioned for after death but of course they’re a bit different..