Would you donate an organ?

Do you agree with it? Would you donate your kidney to save the life of a family member or friend? Would you donate any organ after death?
Why/why not?

This question is based on this inspirational story earlier this year.

Ray Coe: Teacher gives kidney to student Alya Ahmed Ali | Metro News

Hero teacher saves pupil’s life by donating his kidney

http://metrouk2.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/ad_131296861.jpg?w=650&h=974&crop=1#038;h=1000

Hero: Teacher Ray Coe (right) gave a kidney to Alya Ahmed Ali


A selfless teacher who saved the life of a seriously ill pupil by donating one of his kidneys has been hailed as a hero.****
Ray Coe said he knew it was ‘the right thing to do’ after being told Alya Ahmed Ali, 13, was undergoing kidney dialysis and needed a life-saving transplant.
The 53-year-old is a special educational needs coordinator at the Royal Docks Community School in Custom House, east London, where Alya is a pupil.
She suffers from a condition called hydrocephalus, a build-up of fluid in the brain, which has resulted in her having severe learning difficulties.
‘When we told Alya, she just gave me a big squeeze and her face lit up. It brings tears to my eyes whenever I think of that,’ he told the Newham Recorder.
‘For her parents, it’s not words that can express their gratitude. For them I have saved their daughter’s life. It’s like I am another family member now.’
The pair underwent a successful kidney transplant at Great Ormond Street Hospital in February and are both set to return to school after the Easter break.
Her father, Ahmed Ali, called Mr Coe a hero, adding he was ‘an amazing man’.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Allah SWT maa’uf karein, but I do not think I want to donate my organs.. Something which I am not too comfortable with.

whereas giving away a kidney when you can survive on only 1, never thought about it…insha-Allah,

Re: Would you donate an organ?

That’s fair enough honest answer. After death im not sure if i would want to donate my eyes or body parts. while alive i think for family/close friends/select GS members i could donate my kidney if i were a perfect match. Hard choice though.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

i haven’t consented to it on my driver’s license, but i intend to do so soon iA…i’m also not comfortable but i will do it because it saves lives and who knows, God forbid, i or any member of my family might need it.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Yes, I’d donate a Kidney without second thought if close family needed it.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

how about to an extended family member or to a stranger who really needs it?

Re: Would you donate an organ?

My first cousins, aunts , uncles , grandparents etc I’d donate readily.
A stranger or far off relatives maybe not.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

oh ok…fair enuf!

but, would you take an organ from a stranger if, God forbid, you needed one?

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Yes I would.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

if you need it you need it na. ZIndagi aur maut ka sawal hai.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Aur agar woh shaks Indian ho to? Kya aap ko lagega ki aap ki Pakistaniyat kam ho jayegi kyon ki aap ke andar kisi Indian ka organ hai?
Maine kahin padha ki koi logon ko aise lagta hai.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

:hehe:

Re: Would you donate an organ?

but, is it fair then? kisii aur kaa bhii to zindagii aur maut kaa sawaal hotaa hai. hai na?

i can’t accept that if you say that life is itself unfair at times. :smiley:

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Follow up question..since it is August. Would you feel less of a Pakistani if you required an organ and the only available match was that of an Indian person of unknown religion? What if you required blood transfusion and the only available blood is that of an Indian person? do you think it would dilute your Pakistaniyat/not be good enough? Would you rather wait for a Pakistani/non Indian option?

I read this somewhere but i don’t think it’s a common sentiment at all.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

sachi mein there was article jahan likha tha this young boy needed heart and only heart available was indian and some relatives tried to make the parents think against kahin uske paas Indian dil aa jaye. Aur jaise aap ko pata hoga hamare dil itne big nahi hote :stuck_out_tongue: lol jk :slight_smile:

Aap sach sach bataye. Jo bhi aap ko feel ho. I don’t mind either way. Aur aap ne patriotism ka bhi thread banaya na :slight_smile:

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Nopes, not fair. But I still wouldn’t change my stance on it.

Re: Would you donate an organ?

Hota hoga lekin uss person ne permission diya hoga organ dene ke liye to a stranger. So they would have known what that involves. Think of all the duas that person and their family will get.

I am interested to also know if people would accept Indian organ. It’s ok either way. Sab ka opinion alag ho sakta hai

Re: Would you donate an organ?

human organs, human blood and anything underneath the skin has NO religion, no race, no other color than it’s own universal color…under the skin everyone is the same…no one has a bigger heart!

Re: Would you donate an organ?

acha mera sawal ka bhi jawab dijiye :slight_smile:

Re: Would you donate an organ?

I would take the heart/blood/kidney etc which is readily available regardless of the race or religion of the person donating.