would abortion be allowed if....

[sadiqhassan]

Re: would abortion be allowed if....

@Fraudz

Implantation occurs way way before a heartbeat genrally just a few days beyond fertilization. so if its a heartbeat that you consider as a cut off point than thats way after implantation, if its implantation, then we can already see that you and deedawar have diff perspectives, just like there are others around.

while your relatives may have prayed namaz e janaza for a 2 week embryo, other schools of thought place the need for namaz e janaza much much later. also the time when you have to actually give the child a name is when the child is born and can breath and make a sound according to some schools of thought.

in the end, all talk aside, the point remains that an abortion is allowed in a certan timeframe and that the timeframe varires between diff schools of thought so there is no consensus on it, and one can go ahead as long as its seems logical.

I agree completely.

As I said previously in this thread, people don't agree on what constitues dead / alive, abortion / not abortion. I was simply saying that according to my interpretation of sources I have looked at, Abortion of an implanted embryo is haraam.

WaSalaam