Re: Women who "choose to" wear Hijab - Do they have no future?
Have you observed any such instance in your locality/neighborhood? Why, those women who "choose to" wear Hijab, are looked down upon (by her other female counter-parts and by the society)? Why the roots of our culture are being torn with every passing day?
Actually, in my experiences, it's the other way around. In college, the Muslims generally hung out together. But the hijabis made it hellish for the non-hijabis. Many, but not all, hijabis were belligerent and condescending towards the girls who didn't wear it. There was a lot of polarization based on a small piece of cloth, and it was ridiculous.
People look down upon certain hijabis because of hypocritical actions by them. On one hand, some are constantly preaching about hijab, hinting what good little Muslims they are; on the other, they are the very same ones with boyfriends, which they like to justify by saying that they are looking for husbands. In Islam, any relationship between a non-mahram man and woman is forbidden. If it is truly about marriage, a person shouldn't have a boyfriend for so many years (during which time they are away from the eyes of their parents). As long as you are consenting adults, Islam wants you to get married sooner rather than later. I find it extremely hard to believe that a couple can be together for so many years without transgressing limits. If you claim to be extra religious, you can certainly find a husband without resorting to questionable behavior. It becomes a case of the pot calling the kettle black.
Don't take me wrong, I admire girls who do wear hijab. But the venomous, preachy ones could at least have the courtesy to admire their sisters in Islam who adhere to other rulings more strictly than they do. My best friends in college did not wear hijab, but they were so shareef. Never had boyfriends, never went on dates or to clubs. Everyone is excels in something and everyone is deficient in something. Girls who are deficient in the visible act of wearing a hijab aren't given credit for the noble and honorable niyyah of their hearts.
Contrast that with many of the hijabis I knew.
Certain incidents remain ingrained in my mind. At one MSA function, two girls got into a water fight with each other and pushed each other into a pool in the name of good fun. It was a mixed party, and the rest of us girls cringed as they got out of the pool in their wet t-shirts. The boys obviously enjoyed the sight to the fullest. Who were the culprits? Girls who wore hijab.
Another MSA function. A group of boys and girls are speaking to one another, joking around. A hijabi girl who's an officer of the MSA loudly makes an announcement that it's unIslamic for the genders to be so frank with one another. Ironically, it was well known this same girl also had a boyfriend for six years before he finally married her.
One girl I knew was always lecturing everyone about how we were defying Islam by not wearing hijab. That's all she would talk about at parties or gatherings. One day, a gori friend of mine tells me that she saw this girl in the bedroom with a Muslim guy and they definitely looked like a a couple. (This gori friend's boyfriend shared an apartment with this particular Muslim guy).
Another hijabi I know was caught making out with a Muslim guy on campus.
My own hijabi cousin was "with" an Arab guy on campus. He was a player, and told everyone that she was easy.
One of my friends worked at the health office at college, and she passingly made a comment that quite a few "girls with scarves on their head" come in for free birth control devices.
One on hand you're supposed to cover your beauty, on the other hand, hijabis wear the same amount of makeup, if not more, than other girls.
I do believe in modest dress, but I don't believe that a hijab is any indicator of morality. It's become a social statement that allows you to be part of a certain clique that's all. I know my experiences certainly don't speak for the entire population, but little incidents over the years have colored my view such that I think sharafat is a multi-pronged virtue, more than just head covering alone. It's also an attitude and demeanor and many hijabis (those who claim to be the visible face of Islam) forget that.