Re: Why We Say That?
Many people consider it a hadeeth, albeit with weak narrations.
But even if its narrations are accepted to be weak, doesn’t mean that it may not be a hadeeth. Calling it weak only means that it could be a hadeeth, even though the possibility is small.
I don’t think anyone considers it a false hadeeth altogether.
There are also many who consider it a fair hadeeth. See below.
Hadith: Seek knowledge even in China
Al-Munawi, like Ibn Abd al-Barr before him, gave an excellent explanation of the hadith in his Fayd al-Qadir (1:542). See also its discussion in al-Ajluni’s Kashf al-Khafa’ under the hadith: “Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim,” itself a fair (hasan) narration in Ibn Maajah because of its many chains as stated by al-Mizzi, although al-Nawawi in his Fatawa (p. 258) declared it weak while Dr. Muhammad Ajaj al-Khaatib in his notes on al-Khatib's al-Jami (2:462-463) declared it “sound due to its witness-chains” (sahîh li ghayrih). Cf. al-Sindi’s Hashya Sunan Ibn Maajah (1:99), al-Munawi’s Fayd al-Qadir (4:267) and al-Sakhaawi’s al-Maqaasid al-Hasana (p. 275-277).
My personal opinion, which of course doesn’t count for others, is that this may be a true hadith. But our maulanas like to reject it because if it is true then it collides with their claim that knowledge is only the knowledge of religion. This is why our madressahs are so adamant to keep the “corrupt” science subjects away. If it is accepted that prophet asked people to go to China then it would mean that prophet considered maths, physics, and chemistry to be knowledge as well.
So in order to keep their claim, it is NECESSARY to consider this hadith forgery, and if it is not possible then at least consider it “weak”.