Why oh why!

I completely agree!! the adverse effects of demeaning and complex creating remarks have a LOT to do with how and why people spend the way the do...
and then...after spending and putting on a show.... they feel obligated to brag about it.

I hate hate hate these traditions!! they have caused such bad mazgi in wedding parties yet people dont learn.....
I was disgruntled after my cousins pulled the stupid act...even after my asking them not to..the night before...good thing my husband was prepared ( i am guessing his side either warned him..or he is just very intuitive... :) ) ah well..

So that's great!! My husband didn't paid anything for my house...My parents bought everything for me for my house...furniture etc etc....My husband was also saying that I should change my kitchen and bathroom...coz it will be difficult to do it when we'll be together...coz all the costs etc...
I was really angry and I told my mom...She said that they aren't giving anything to him...they are giving all the things to me...So that I'll be happy to live in my house with all the things I like.....So they also want to make a kitchen.....and yeh maybe also the bathroom....It all depends on me...they only say that I should take things I like...And yeh I'm not buying as a dumb blond...but I think 10 times before buying something for my house...Will I use it?? Do I need it?? etc etc

And yeh I work....all the little things I've bought myself...

In Pakistan my parents bought furniture for me...only for my bedroom...I've heard several times my MIL saying that they bought everything for her daughter when she married...irritating....every person who came to see my furniture said ooh only bedroom furniture?? Damn...so pathetic.... However my bedroom furniture was much more expensive then alll the things they have in their home!!! My parents could buy things for me in PK...but I'm not going to live there...so why should they buy?? I'm going to live here.....My parents didn't bought things for me to show off..and to show others that: WE GOT MONEY!!..but bought things for me so that I'll be happy!!

And yeh I'm really happy!! I love my furniture..here and in PK...I love my jewellery (I don't even wear it), i love my house I bought....and I love my parents...Sometimes I have to explain my parents not to buy unnecessary things for me!!
Yes I have two elder sisters...who both are married...and same story with them also!!

My brother is going marry next year....My mom is buying everything for my Bhabhi....Bedroom furniture in PK and here.....jewellery....etc etc..everything......coz her parents can't afford....They haven't said it...but my parents don't care about it!!
She is their fourth daughter....She got the same rights as we(3 sis)do...

You may not have meant it that way but it does sound quite pathetic.

A couple of years back, a daughter of one of our family friends’, a chemical engineer in Canada, tied the knot with one of her first cousins who lived in Pakistan. The girl’s family had a few dholkis, mehndi, and a reception in Canada besides all the events that were held in Pakistan. The girl was also given a fully furnished house as a wedding present by her parents.

After that, what she gets to hear from her ma-in-law is GHAR DIA TO KIA DIA. MORTGAGE TO LARKE KO HI DENA PAREGA :smack: The guy hadn’t even set his foot on Canadian land at that time, let alone having a job that could pay the mortgage but if you tell this fact to people like her, then all hell would break loose.

Oh you thinks so??
I don't...I think it's pathetic to count things that DIL brings....

wth! i am guessing…lack of self worth..respect…serious complex issues??
my mom always says..bhookay people are like a deep dark kuuaaan (well) it will never feel full… :slight_smile:

Re: Why oh why!

Iksa :) while these things are great and all, your parents are not required by any law to buy for you and your husband (and for your sisters and their husbands) the essentials. What happens in our society (especially) is that, if one person or family does something, everyone follows and expects it..thus making this into a tradition. The thread is not about what you can afford, its about how and when can we break away from the traditions that make us weak as a society...instead of being proud of ourselves....

I agree with sumo, and that is exactly what my husband said when we got married! It is very important for a man to be self-sufficient. If you give a man everything on a silver platter, what has he got to be proud of?? It is he who should be providing you with a bed to sleep on...the car to drive....and the china to eat off of...although i am sure the inlaws already have those...and shouldnt be expecting the bride to bring a dowry. Yes it is a dowry, no matter what you call it..."gesture of love" "things we can afford" "stuff i dont want bother buying after i get married" it is a dowry, and it is STILL expected when we get married, whether we decide to live with our in laws or not.
Parents love their daughters....and its a shame some/most inlaws and brides take advantage of the love and twist it for their own benefit.

Re: Why oh why!

Parents love their daughters....and its a shame some/most inlaws and brides take advantage of the love and twist it for their own benefit.

Chanda I agree with you!

Re: Why oh why!

Parents love their daughters....and its a shame some/most inlaws and brides take advantage of the love and twist it for their own benefit.

Chanda I agree with you!

The thread is not about what you can afford, its about how and when can we break away from the traditions that make us weak as a society...instead of being proud of ourselves....

The best way is to do what you want.....Why should we follow traditions that others made?? So what if people say Hay aise kyu waise kyu.....We live for ourselves not for others!!!!
Mahatma Ghandi said: You must be the change you wish to see in the world!!

Ofcourse we can change the people who are greedy...Not giving them anything!! Maybe they won't learn their lesson..but their next generation WILL!! I don't think these traditions make us weak....You are weak if you want to follow these traditions...or even think about it!! Being proud of ourselves?? Why?? By giving and taking a lots of things...Nehhh I don't think so...But that's my way of thinking..

Sorry if anybody disagree!!

Re: Why oh why!

^agree with the above...except you may have misunderstood the last part :)

"..instead of being proud of ourselves" meaning...why be proud of yourself by following the traditions that make us weak as a society?

Re: Why oh why!

about the Gandhi reference...What if he had said, "I dont want to stand up...what will the British say?"
I am proud of the young women and men who stood up and said NO to the outrageous suggestions, demands..ignoring the annoying aunties who will literally comment on just about anything...
are we doing whatever that is we are doing to please the same aunties that are being bashed in the Life section of this forum....hmmm what does that make us?