Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

Often people mistake this restriction as a sign of inequality that degrades women, when in fact it’s the exact opposite. …anndddd the best way to find the reasoning behind why Muslim women are not permitted to marry non-Muslim men is by quoting Hadiths and even the Quran itself :slight_smile: :

^ This Hadith talks about a few of the rights of a Muslim wife, which are the responsibility of the husband. If a Muslim women married a non-Muslim, he would not be required to abide by these rules, therefore the wife’s rights could be lessened. By marrying a Muslim man, a Muslim women is assured all the things listed in the above Hadith.

^ The above Hadith is another proof that this commandment was to save the rights of Muslim women rather than take them away. The Hadith gives Muslim wives permission to take money (just enough to suffice - “ma’roof”) from there husbands when necessary if the husband is not properly providing for the family. A Muslim woman would not be able to do this with her non-Muslim husband, because he would not consider it one of her rights.

^ Again, specifics on how the Muslim husband should treat his wife. A non-Muslim wouldn’t have to abide by this. Same reasoning, just more proof.

^ Muslim men are not to talk about intimate relations between himself and his wife with others. It is a part of the wife’s privacy as well as the husband’s. Once again, a non-Muslim husband is not restricted from talking about such things with others.

^ This is a major Hadith which covers this issue perfectly. Muslim men are to allow their wives to visit the Mosques without their permission. This might be a problem with non-Muslim husbands, since they might expect to be told every time the wife leaves the house, or they might not even allow them to go to the Musjid at all, for that matter.

^ It says “A believer”, meaning Muslim men. They are to respect Muslim women. If a Muslim women married a non-Muslim, he wouldn’t necessarily be required to act the same.

The basic reasoning behind why Muslim women are not allowed to marry non-Muslim men is because a Muslim man is required to follow through with certain responsibilities that a non-Muslim man is not. So, it’s really all about strengthening the women’s rights, rather than restricting them.:slight_smile:

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

Phatima, WHY are you studying this subject?

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

^ mashallah..what validity in haing muslim husbands..they won’t beat you, give you money and food, won’t talk about intimate moments with their wives to others, let you pray and respect you… apparently god needs to write common sense down for muslim men which without his word would be all too uncommon. :hehe:

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

I'm marrying a 40 year old man I've been stalking on the internet for the past 7 years. You all are invited to our virtual Nikkah.

haha, no really. I dunno just lots of people don't know about it and they think the reason Muslim women can't marry non-Muslims is because Islam favors the men, making it unequal which isn't true.

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

what are you trying to say Pinny,
phatima...put your hands over your young lil ears...he's trying to take you off this path of rightiousness with his sarcasm.

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

That’s what makes the Quran so different from other “holy books”. It’s got guidelines just in case there is a debate over something (as well as specifics noted in Hadiths), and believe it or not people would debate over the smallest and stupidest things.

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

i think the reason these muslim women marry those nonmuslim men is because they feel they are better life partners for them

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

oy that’s not what we’re discussing :mad: we’re discussing WHY Muslim women ARE NOT PERMITTED to marry non-muslims. Why they disobey this command is a totally different story.

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

^ yeah debate, whether shooting women in the head in soccer stadiums is haram or not. I am sure it is very clear.

Quranic dictats create more debate than they subside. Just go to religon forum. You can't even agree whether allah wants you to wear a piece of cloth on just your head or like a burlap sack around your body.

You are right, quran is very different from the other holy books. It has some fastastic messages. Mostly for the arabians of the 7th century. Apparently they treated women like chattle and needed step by step instructions on how to act or be around them in a civilized way. The rest of the world evolved on it's own.

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

^^^ He's not in a good mood today.... which is lovely and what I like to see but Phatima he'll pull you apart.

if this is a religious thread Im leaving

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

How dare you say I am not in a good mood? I am in a fantastic mood. I am getting angry that you think I am not in a good mood. I will get very upset if you don;t take that back. What makes you think I am not in a good mood? I enjoy phatima’s posts, I think pink is good as it is the navy blue of India. I like Nina simone songs while stirring a 3 olive martini at Ono in in the Gaansevoort hotel.

:kiss:

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

go on get angry...your anger lines will become more pronounced and you will need botox to look 55 again!

and that smiley is not right for the religiousness of theis thread!

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

hm yea the reason i didn’t post this in the religion fourm was because i didn’t want to read replies like this from people. turns out they’re all over the place. you’re obviously not a muslim, so this thread wasn’t meant for you, really. i’m not expecting you to follow any of the quotes given because you’re not even a muslim in the first place.

and yes, shooting women in the head in soccer stadium is haraam :frowning:

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

phatima sweety, you are darling girl and the royal princess of pink but when you post threads anybody can write what they want.... his view on the subject is just as valid as yours
even though it is an opposing view it is still something you can learn from... learn to turn lemons into lemonade as they say.

there is a lot to learn from the ramblings of that clearly old and DARK skinned man!

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

ugh i think i’ve learned my share.

oh, i almost forgot…

Allah Hu Akbar. :flower2:

Re: Why muslim women can’t marry non-muslims

yea he seems pretty worked up to me, what do you think lazy?

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

I think he has a hangover AND forgot to have have breakfast...
but it could be anything...people his age are prone to be crabby

its called Grumpy Old man syndrome

it will come to you too one day Phatima

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

oh so do all humans turn into "grumpy old MEN" when they get old? Funny, I always thought minah_pa was a woman. :D

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

nope princess phatima's turn intogrumpy old men because as they are royalty they gain the respect to the value of men and can then be called grumpy old men.

Minah, isnt grumpy!

Re: Why muslim women can't marry non-muslims

what's with the royalty "princess phatima". you're gonna make me puke. please.

burp

yea i know minah's a doll i just wanna see her raise hell because she tends to do that when people call her old. :p