Re: Why make Dua when everything is pre written??
Dear kakaballi, are you expecting to become a learned person without going through the needed hard work by yourself. You cannot rely on others to give you cake in the plat to eat son. others can only help a little but most of the work has to be carried out by yourself if you want to know things. In the wall of text I explain things from my point of you not yours. I already asked for link to your point of view so that if you have explained things any better I could learn from that. You have not provided anything and are only arguing for argument sake. This is not the mindset, attitude and behaviour conducive to learning. I do not argue with people by putting up one liners because my point is helping others learn and if anyone has something better than what I offer then I may do the same ie learn things of them. I do not come along needlessly and try to undermine others without having anything worthwhile to contribute. So kindly come out of your comfort zone and please contribute sensibly to that end.
The context in which I am talking is, originality of the text of the quran beyond any reasonable doubt. The reason I did that was because if the text of the quran itself is doubtful anything else we say about it will be useless. If you are aware the quranic authentic is under heavy attack by nonmuslims but it is mullahs who have given the opportunities to them to do that through some reports in the hadith books which tell us the quran is incomplete.
Beside that I have explained away many other arguement agauinst the quran by nonmuslims. One cannot know all this till one reads the writings. Yes they are very long texts but if you have read tafaseer on the quran one will find a tafseer of the quran in hundred volumes. Of course it is not necessary for everyone to have very long text to have sense of things but some do need that long text. If you need less then you may have produced soemthing better but I am not aware of it. I am only making you aware of what I have done so when you make me aware of anything better I will gladly accept your invitation to comment on your work. Meanwhile you should show good spirit and do what needs to be done.
You will find a lot more answers to your lot more questions in my these writings but if I have not touched on something then you can bring that too to my attention and I will see if I can offer anything yet more to include answers to those questions as well.
Here also my point is mullaism exists among muslims and that mullaism is responsible for state of muslim ummah. I have explained the psychological tricks and mechanisms whereby mullaism brain washes people and the reason it does it for. This needs quite a bit of explanation for muslims because most of us are ignorant, illiterate, uneducated, untrained, unskilled and unthinking people. If we are any better we will not be in this state of existence as we can clearly see by our own eyes.
Make beliefs helped dominant people brainwash or condition submissive people through doctored indoctrination. This is why belief about QADR is of high importance. The context in which mullahs explain worship, reward and punishment, intercession and forgiveness or atonement as well as hereafter are a proof that mullahs are part of the ruling elite and money lending gang. They try to provide legitimacy for all the religious nonsense in the name of God and his revelation. I am explaining how they do that and why they do it. So people who are interested in finding out have no choice but to read my explanation and see it for themselves whether what I have explained makes sense or am I talking utter nonsense. That is all. If I am talking rubbish then people should remain stuck to whatever they already believe otherwise they will have to find alternative explanation. That is all. If you are not interested in reading my writings then I cannot force you do that but then whatever you will say about my writings will not carry much weight and there is no point in arguing for sake of argument because then there is nothing there to learn from each other, is there? May be you will reconsider your stance in this regard. BTW I am not talking about post 32 but links given in there.
Nonetheless regards and all the best.