Re: Why make Dua when everything is pre written??
Peace Mughal1
Aqeedah101 … We are not discussing this topic … I will gladly come back to this point … but for the time being I would like to see categorical proof that our ulema are quote on quote … blaming "God for all their ills. when they should be “**blaming rulers, money lenders and mullahs for fractures in human community”
**That is sheer nonsense … Not only do my own shuyukh categorically require us to take blame for our actions if you look at society today no one is blaming God … they are blame each other … and you are blaming everyone else too … No one … I mean no one blames God on account of beliefs in Qadr according to traditional understandings …
In fact a book that I read entitled “Kitab ul-Tanwir Fi isqat ul-tadbir” tells us about the contradistinction between Adam (AS) the archetypal human and Shaitan The Accursed - that Iblees blamed God in the Qur’an for being put to test in prostrating to to the Adamic form whereas Adam (AS) sought forgiveness for something that he could have said that Shaitan deceived him … (AS) … We are taught this as a fundamental part of our tariqah … which is to take ownership of our lives …
Also many ulema teach … tie the camel before trusting in Allah (SWT) … so there is a strong concept throughout traditional Islam for not “blaming Allah (SWT)” … Also in the Qur’an it says all good comes from Allah (SWT) but any evil that befalls us is a direct result of our own actions … however, we are also taught that evil cannot exist if Allah (SWT) does not create it for it to exist …
I hope that you will stop spreading your lies about others … It is okay to have your own opinion but please do not lie about others … we are however not to battle with our destiny and this is quite a different matter … and we have to learn to accept past events as the Will of God … not blame Him for them …