Re: Why make Dua when everything is pre written??
Dear psyah, please explain what do you mean by qadr and you will find your answers in there even today. It is you who believes Allah knows already what anyone is going to do so let us see what you mean by it. If any of your mullahs have explained it already please let us have it. It is your aqeedah that all good and evil comes from God. All I want to know is how do you explain all this or for that matter any of your mullahs. I have explained this in a very different way in the links I provided above.
Your aqeedah includes other make beliefs as well not just qadr. Once you explain qadr I will bring other things to your attention as well should you like me to do that. Why mullahs thought it necessary to include qadr in aqeedah if it was as simple a thing as you think? So I will start with your good self if you do not mind. Who taught you your aqeedah? IMAAN MUJMAL and IMAAN MUFASSAL are creedal declarations, can you tell me their origin and the reason for that? Many quranic terms have been twisted by mullahs not just word qadr but it is a good start to begin with. If you or for that matter your mullahs fail to explain qadr then I have nothing to say because truth will speak for itself. By the way this is not just your creed but creed of all those who claim to be bound by this creed including mullahs who invented it and promoted it.
Do you remember your discussion with me about miracles? The concept of miracles was also invention by mullahs and it was promoted by them. So it will be a good idea for you to study what I explained because that will strengthen your position in answering my questions one way or the other. If you learned something from my explanations it will prove good for you and if you thereby helped me discover something new that too will benefit both of us. Discussions never hurt if they are carried out in good spirit of learning. You simply attacked me because I put up point of view of ghulam ahmed parwez but I do put up opinions of various people of various sects to emphasise certain points. When I talk about sir syed for example, I do not mean whatever he said about anything at all he is right about all of it. He was a human being and was born ignorant just like all of us. He learned somethings better than the rest of us and for that he should be appreciated not condemned. His contribution to this ummah was, interpret the text of the quran in light of real world realities. Mullahs called him naitury=naturalist. Tell me was he right or are your mullahs right? From his point of view we should study the real world realities and then interpret the quran in that light. From your mullahs’ point of view, we should study the quran and then interpret the universe in that light. Which position is more logical and consistent in your view and why? I hold sir syed’s point of view right and mullahs point of view wrong for reasons explained in my study of the quran. Of course anyone is welcome to prove my point of view wrong including yourself but none has been able to do so and I do not think anyone can because if anyone could they will have done it by now many times over.
Hameedduddeen farahi another schoar of the quran in time of sir syed, came up with idea of context of the quranic text. He emphasised to ummah that people should try their best to make sense of the quranic text in its own context. Before him mullahs used to think the quran is just a collection of verses which have no connection to each other whatsoever. This was due to concept of shaane nazool the way it was invented and promoted by mullahs. Was he right or wrong in your opinion? In my view he was right and mullahs were wrong.
Soon after them iqbal came on stage who told ummah islam was a deen not a mazhab. Not only that he also dismissed mullahs’ concept of shariah clarifying how shariah is supposed to be derived from the quran in light of real world realities that face the generations of the ummah in their own times. Was he right or wrong? In my view he was right and mullahs were wrong and I have reasons to say this which are explaied in detail in my work on the quran.
To understand what my view of deen of islam is, one has to read through by work, it is mainly based on points emphasised by people like sir syed, farahi, iqbal and parwez etc.
regards and all the best.