why joint,why seprate???

[Jolie]

Re: why joint,why seprate???

@Deeba1234

^I only said it was forbidden if there are non-mehrams around which is TRUE, perhaps u should learn to read properly.

And where are these (non-desi) scholars who encourage the desi joint family system (or even staying with MIL and FIL unless there is an actual need ie. not ‘my parents are v.sensitive and my mummy will cry if I leave’)?? OH YEAH, THERE AREN’T ANY.

So would your scholar also say women working is also ‘forbidden’ as they are so many non mehrams around their workplace? Its not about me not knowing how to read, its about your point lacking credibility to view. You can’t pick and choose when existance of non-mehram becomes an issue or when it doesn’t, if women remaining in a close of proximity of na-mheram is forbidden alltogether then its forbidden be it in the house, Uni or the work place. If you follow *that extreme *brand of Islam then I don’t even see a point in having any discussion with you.

How about you find me evidence that says women are absolutely forbidden to be in a close proximity of na-mehrams, I know they are required to remain modest in front of na-mehrams but thats not what we’re talking here.