… By Ali Sina.
I don’t know what to say …
Yeah I read that article.
Don't pay attention to B.S. like that.
as usual all these Islamophobes rejoice in all the ammo readily available in Hadith literature.. this 'history' of ours is more a liability than a benefit.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PakistaniAbroad: *
as usual all these Islamophobes rejoice in all the ammo readily available in Hadith literature.. ....
[/QUOTE]
Just like anti-christian Mullahs find ammo in the Injeel.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PakistaniAbroad: *
as usual all these Islamophobes rejoice in all the ammo readily available in Hadith literature.. this 'history' of ours is more a liability than a benefit.
[/QUOTE]
Interesting. So i take it you feel all the Qur'anic verses he quotes are also "more a liability than a benefit"!?
Many more would convert to other religions, as I am too in process of changing the fiqha.
The reason is the illiteracy of our old generation.
Such as heads of big big muslim N. Geos and muslim organizations or it is due to their greed of money that they get from other rich muslim countries and rich muslim brothers individually.
Such people delibrately or due to ignorance write things which totally does not make sense in such a technically advanced world.
Also they say GOD would forgive for all kinds of sins if you ask for forgiveness.
Another most important point which led me to think at first place to change my fiqah is the most reliable ahadeez narrated by a wife of Prophet. Muslims do not consider her as a lady; they consider her only as wife of Prophet Mohammed.
Such kind of things and stubborn attitude of religious heads, that they do not feel necessity to correct their ignorantal mistakes at all, is harming the religion to a grater extend.
The second biggest thing which made me to think that there is a great deal wrong with Hanaffee sunnah, to which my forefathers belong to is
that:
shia say that from the family of prophet they have his date of birth and date of death different from what sunni dates are for his death and birth to celibrate; sunni say they got the dates from his companions; they ignore his family members in this regard totally although they claim to love PANJATAN PAK more than shia. So I have an impression that this fiqha has a lot of hipocracy in it, and less truth.
I hope people correct themselves who are the cause of many people conversion from sunni to -------other way of lives. The world is full of logic, people are no more ignorant themselves. They know more then the claimers of religions. Bye sokoon
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by gupguppy: *
Interesting. So i take it you feel all the Qur'anic verses he quotes are also "more a liability than a benefit"!?
[/QUOTE]
the verses.. NO
their mainstream interpretation as done by 'classical scholars' of Islam using that same hadith literature.. yes... a huge liability.
^ Open your eyes please Mr. PA... Mr. Sina has criticised certain verses without the need to refer to any hadith... according to your defeatist logic those verses are a liability.
well my logic is certainly not defeatist and since it's been some years i read his site.. you're welcome to point out where he has managed to bring forth a case against just verses without having to fall back on hadith to bring in the 'juicy argument'..
^ He does so with ALL of the verses shown on that one single page.
Well when hindus and chrisitians are the potential candidate of Allah's mercy after death, why can't she be? After all she is an ex-muslim. She deserves it more than anyone.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Lines Area: *
Well when hindus and chrisitians are the potential candidate of Allah's mercy after death, why can't she be? After all she is an ex-muslim. She deserves it more than anyone.
[/QUOTE]
haha, welcome brother in the group that is just stunned at how people who call themselves muslims have rejected the clear and undeniable teachings of quran that kafirs who die after truth has been presented to them and still deny it are going to hell....
He needs a whipping.
ALI SINA is a popular convert. He has his own website. He makes money off us when we visit his website.
some of his articles r really laughable....
and his comment "Muhammad married young and beautiful women" really made me laugh....
the guy surely hasnt read the biography of Muhammad (saw)....
or he choses to ignore reality and stick to his own perverted version....
i'm familiar with some of the ahadith he uses to bash islam, he takes them out of context just like with some ayaat he has posted, sometimes even quoting partial ahadith, without giving the background or anything, like the camel milk/urine one, he doesn;t mention that them people who got the severe punishment were killed in exactly the same way they killed the Prophets :sallallaho alayhe wassalaam) shpered. eye for an eye, seems perfectly fair and just to me.
he rejected guidance for error and now God will leave him to wander astray righ into the depths of the fire, exactly what he deserves.
i tell u who's worse though, these so called reformers, modern muslims, they want to to destroy the spirit of Islam from within, plenty of them on here, may Allah guide them or break their back.
Muslims and Muslim scholars always say, learn Islam, they never say, study Islam. Why?
The author is talking of a cult issue. I think there is reason.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by anjjan: *
Muslims and Muslim scholars always say, learn Islam, they never say, study Islam. Why?
[/QUOTE]
when you learn something, you practice it. When you study something, you just know about it. you may or may not believe in it. Islam is to practice not a mere lip-service.
Learn Islam.
Live Islam.
By studying something you decide if it is true before believe in it. To practice something blindly that you have not studied is lip service.