Its not about giving into his wife. This isnt a battle,
but that is what you said..what you said was exactly that he should listen to one over the other, and my point was that he should listen to all, but drive towards whatever is the right decision. Maybe that is not what you meant, but that is what it reads as.
*
A mama's boy in my opinion is someone who makes his marital decisions according to what his mother thinks and not what his wife thinks. r.
*
its the way things are. Its a marriage, which is a partership between HUSBAND and WIFE. No where in my nikah nama does it state that I am bound in matrimony to my MIL.
So, marital decisions should be discussed and executed by husband and wife. No one else.
...
It depends on what you mean by 'marital decisions' if it is something that solely is between the 2 ppl and has no real impact on anyone else then by all means
just because an individual is married does not cut of all other ties, once individuals get married they dont cease to be sons, daughters, brothers, sisters, uncles, aunts, etc etc. The impact of many decisions is not limited to the couple but affects others as well. and just getting married do not end one's obligations and responsibilities towards people other than spouse and kids.
That is further complicated when there is a joint family, whether the couple is living with one individual's parents, or the parents living with them. Impact of decision is one more than just the couple. so it should not be discussed and executed only by the husband and wife.
Life is simple and complex at the same time, the less complicated we make it, the less complicated it will be, and as long as the couple has mutual respect, trust and love there, they will be able to make even the toughest decisions without massive conflict.
I will however note that it is usually not the guys who tend to discuss their issues, situations etc with a large number of people but it is women who do that, and a good example of that is by doing a sampling of desi events, forums, advice columns etc.