Why do we need a madhab?

Re: Why do we need a madhab?

This is what your post said in other thread.

There are certain misconceptions and mistakes people do commonly when they speak of religion.

1- They try to compare religion with scientific knowledge to prove that just like one needs a ‘teacher’ for worldly knowledge one needs a teacher for EVERYTHING to learn about religion or do ANY act in his or her life.

Certainly if you are searching openly about the religion you must go to DIFFERENT people of knowledge and then think and make your decision. But this still does not mean one does not even try to search on his or her own to at least read the source of the religion like reading the quran or hadith books…various books. Not just one.

2- Also, the famous example given by people is: When you are sick do you go to the doctor or read the medicasl disagnosis or treatment book on your onw to find solution for any medical problem?

Here the mistake people do is that these issues and any scientific knowledge like math, physics etc. deal with something which can be proven or disproven in during your life time or be measured.

A sick person will stay sick and will know the answer.

BUT

In religious matters no one will know the answer till the person is dead and meets the Almighty.

Even though the test books for the test are available in religion, and the exam questions are available, NO ONE can be sure till death if the person did the act right or wrong.

Hence, comparing religion to scientific knowledge is flawed. Weather it is to prove the religion or disprove its validity. One cannot weigh an elephant using a goldsmith balance!

Other part of your post about being mujtahid is also a made up philosophy.

You are allowed to follow your instict if it is based on quran and sunnah and you are faced with day to day issues.

And if all four or five schools of thoughts do not agree with each other, then nothing wrong wih following ANY one at ANY time of your life. ( I think I have said this above somewhere)

I will post the answer to your long quote of abdul-hakim Murad later, since this post is already getting long and you might lose the attention. :slight_smile: