Re: Why do Shias beat upon themselves on 9/10 muharram
I never understood this fact, if Shia believes are true. How Allah SWT guarantees the protection of his final book and chooses an oppressor Umar R.A (who did so much harm to Ahle-Bait-Athaar) and his successor Uthman R.A to do this great job that will remain on Earth till Qiyamat in its original form.
Please, only Shia brothers answer this. I really want to know what they think of this fact and how they feel when reading Quran in the order that these two Sahaba compiled it (with consensus of ashaab-e-sufa and top notch Sahaba including Ali R.A). Why an alleged munafiq (who turned from Islam after Prophet SAW death and who beats her daughter etc etc) will do such a great job. When I am asking this question, I am assuming you don’t believe in tahreef-e-Quran, or 10 para eaten by goat or real Quran being in the cave with 12th Imaam, you know what I mean. The things that you openly admit in public, that is that this Quran that we have in our houses (shia or sunni) is the complete Quran.
I would really appreciate if Sunni brothers don’t reply to my post and let Shia brothers answer this one. Thanks. This question is bugging me for so long and every shia that I spoke to say that he believes this Quran is complete and there is no ‘real sahifa’ thingy in cave.
Brother I would suggest you to open a separate thread on this issue because in this thread we are discussing a different topic. I also want to know the answer from our Shia brothers / sisters on the issue you hilighted.