Why do Shias beat upon themselves on 9/10 muharram

[aqeel123]

Re: Why do Shias beat upon themselves on 9/10 muharram

@Nussairee

^bro,** u r a learned man**…r u seriously trying to prove successorship of the khulafa and tht too using Nahjul Balagha?..r u sure u r not quoting the letter of Imam Ali out of context once again?..a large portion of Nahjul Balagha is compilation of letters exchanged between Ameerul Momineen and Muawiya…and if u r genuine abt it then u wud have already studied the prior and later correspondence along with the historical context…and I think that u already know what Ameerul Momineen is saying to the corrupt king of Syria in this letter but u just want to have a debate…Imam AS is throwing his logic back to him…but anyway if it pleases u then I too am happy to discuss the correspondence in terms of language and background…

A person who beleives Abu Bakar is better than Ali a.s coz Abu bakar is first Caliph and Ali is fourth… Knowing that the decision was made by humans can not be a learned person.

Based on this After Prophet s.a.w list of best people muslims goes like this.

1. Abu Bakar
2. Umar
3. Usman
4. Ali a.s
5. Hassan
   **6. Muaviya
6. Yazeed**